saying i do...

@rcfranz (180)
Philippines
November 26, 2008 8:32pm CST
man sues a former fiancee over engagement ring...what legal and whats proper with engagement rings?...since ring is a conditional gift,regardless who, has the fault,if the engagement break up or if you dont get married,ita proper to women to return the ring to the man,no question ask....but what if you want to keep the ring?
2 responses
@gaaruto (72)
• Philippines
27 Nov 08
If the guy gave the ring to his fiance, then the ring is not his anymore. But the girl should take care the ring.
@rcfranz (180)
• Philippines
27 Nov 08
thats true! but the poor girl bieng sues by the boy becouse of 50thousand dollar worth...how cruel?...?
@smartie0317 (1612)
• United States
27 Nov 08
I think the class thing to do is to let the woman keep the ring. She should have the choice of keeping it or giving it back. I don't understand why someone would keep an engagement ring of someone you don't want to marry. I just feel the classiest thing to do is to to not ask and in turn for the woman to return it. Legally, though, a woman has no right to it after the engagement is over. I've seen people go to court and the woman looses it unless she wishes to pay for it.
@rcfranz (180)
• Philippines
27 Nov 08
tnx for your comments...but the man sue the girl for that ring! and its worth 50thousand dolllar,what do you think about it?