Were you sad when Matt was eliminated?

Well, somebody has to go... and the the weakes among them is in fact Matt Giraud... i like him... but i like the others more... especially Kris... he kinda grew on and in me... he has the most commercial potential... the looks, the voice, and that boy next door kind of thing... makes me wish i was still a teenager so i my gloating and admiration for him can be justified...

I am. But I will be sadder if any of the other four was eliminated instead. I think among the five, Matt has the least appeal to the viewers. We all know that at this stage of competition, we can really say that what's left can really sing. Matt has a good voice and great performances it's just that the others can outshine him more. I don't think it's a matter of vocal quality, performance or song choice but more of not having much "It" factor.

No. He should have left sooner. His singing is less than impressive and he looks like a cry baby.

I was a little disappointed that they got rid of Matt. I figured he was quite good, but my husband is betting on Danny. He is a good singer, mind you I prefer classical, but my husband loves popular. I wish they would not belt so much though. But I guess it is what Americans want.

Actually, I was expecting Matt to be eliminated last night. I am grateful that Danny and Allison were the first two to be saved by America. I was in a way shocked for Adam being part of the bottom two. Anyway, there are really great performers. I agree when the judges say, that this season is the best season so far. I can't wait for the next performances. I can't wait to know who will be the next American Idol.

Hey Hey ! I actually like Matt . But my favorite is Adam and always has been He is just so unique , and creative , and sings with his whole heart . I love his little rock screams as well , or how he can drawn you in with a love song . Just something about that boy ! I like Danny and was sad to see him leave , and he has such a nice blue voice and i can see him putting out soul/and a christen album . Now with Kris he has grown on me and I love him when he sings with his guitar and when he did heartless that sealed him a spot . Have to say that was awesome !

hehe ^_^ I have no idea on who Matt is, but looks like all the favourites are still in the competition.. haha =D Matt is good, but just that his votes are not as much as compared to the rest of contestants.. hehe ^_^ Though it's sad to see him leave, but it also mean higher chance of Danny or ADam winning the whole competition.. haha =D

I hated to see Matt go too...But someone had to be eliminated, It is going to be hard for me the next few weeks because i think that all the ones that are left are really good, and they have been my favorites through out the whole season.

I wasn't sad Jhordie, I think we all expected Matt would be the one to go. It will be really hard now when 1 goes home each week. I love all the top 4 and could see anyone being able to win it now. What are we going to discuss in 4 weeks?