Preference for homemaker or working wife

India
May 14, 2009 5:28am CST
I have always wanted to be a homemaker and nurture my family and kids.After i got married my husband and later in laws started pressurizing me for doing a job.Their financial position was in doldrums and they hid this fact from my parents before marriage.Many things were fabricated and falsified.Anyhow i had to accept the present situation and now working but i still miss and long for the time i can spend with my child. I am just curious to know from men whether they want a wife who should be a homemaker or they prefer working spouse I also want to know from ladies what they enjoy doing the most?staying at home or working full time?
3 people like this
18 responses
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
15 May 09
Hi Kirti Since I am single it gets easier for me to choose. I am a happy working woman who loves her job time and also home time. But then, I do not have any kind of string to pull me back like kids, in-laws...I can go out uninhibited. Had I been with kids, things could well have been different. My sister who is a research scholar with GRE did choose to be a home maker when she needed to. Her in laws and my parents wanted her to take up the opportunity with big brands but she refused. Her kid was very little then and she thought that was her priority. She is a perfect home maker. She wants to be the best in whatever she does and she is just doing that. It ultimately comes down to individual. While many cannot understand why and how women can stay at home without financial independence, many love it that way. I can understand how you feel because with little kid you always have him at the back of your ind. specially, when he has just come out of a crisis. Be fine dear.
2 people like this
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
15 May 09
I can understand your difficulty. But dear, sometimes we are brought to testing time which we must cross the hurdles with a smiling face and with style. Try to do best and try to love the job you have to in whatever you do and that you motivate you to do more. I know, its easier said than done but what else we can do. Lots of love.
1 person likes this
• India
15 May 09
Yes you are right dear.I have always worked hard and loved my work.I have also adapted myself to a great extent to changing situations in my life. Time is a great healer and i am emerging out of every situation with clarity of thoughts and mind. Thanks for your support whenever i am in dilemma. Blessed to have a friend like you.
• India
15 May 09
It is really tough to feel the constant agony and guilt of not providing sufficient time to my child.After marriage i have seen and faced many ups and downs in my life [b]and it is a miracle that i am still going on . I ALSO USED TO FEEL THE SAME WAY WHEN I WAS SINGLE.i HAD FULL TIME JOB BUT I WAS INDEPENDENT LIKE A FREE BIRD,WITH NO HASSLES.I WAS CAREFREE YET RESPONSIBLE.[/b] One incident after the other has really made me a different person altogether who is constantly thinking about money,kid,family etc.There is no time for myself and that is why i crave for my period before marriage. Mimpi,your sister is very lucky as she has had the experience of both the worlds.Having worked full time and now taking care of her family and kid is a great bliss.She must be a doting wife and devoted mother.
• India
14 May 09
I am a confused mixed product really. By temperament, I am a very soft and docile person, quite unfit for the world. And the image of the Indian mother, forever ready to wipe off the sweat from her child’s forehead with her pallu, forever ready to take care of her husband and in-laws…well, I really like that. Staying at home, taking care of family, doing some sewing and handicrafts, sitting with the kids with their studies, then waiting for husband to come home…this seems like the ideal life to me. But I have grown up seeing my mom to go office daily and I liked that too…the independence of money, the importance of going to office, the dress…all these were etched in my mind too. But I think given a choice, I would have stayed at home, esp. after my son was born. But finances were a problem and since ours was a love marriage, I always knew I had to work…even then sometimes I look at my son and I know that I have not given him the time he needed from me.
1 person likes this
• India
14 May 09
Ya Sudipta you are very right when you say that you you have not given sufficient time to your son.I regret the same.I have a son who is 1.25 years old and i started working when he was just 4 months old.I feel guilty as i cannot give sufficient time to him .But if we look at the other side of the coin,financial independence and confidence which i have acquired after doing job is there to balance the situation.If i would not have been working then i could not be able to bring up the child according to way i wanted. Thanks for your sharing your views.
• India
14 May 09
Is that you son on your avatar?
1 person likes this
• India
14 May 09
Ya it is his picture.It was taken during his first birthday.
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
23 Jun 09
I have been a homemaker in the sense that I did not seek employment anywhere. But this still did not stop me from having an independent freelancing career for myself Bamrahkirti. I was extremely successful with my own tuition centre and have taught groups and groups of students . In fact , I used to screen them giving them entrance tests and people have come to me with recommendations. I was also invited a s a chief guest in my own college in honour of my service. I treasure these memories. I would prefer to spend my tiem productively without compromising one bit on my duties as mother and wife.This was why I was able to devote my maximum attention to my son and by God's grace he has done successfully for himself by his outstanding performance in scholastics. I never did have any intentions of taking up a job but this bit of independence was very satisfactory.
1 person likes this
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
24 Jun 09
Hi Bamrahkirti! Thanks for the comment , but I can take credit to the extent that I was always along with my son right from his childhood and though my husband is the chartered accountant in the house I took the initiative to see authorities in your institute, talk to them [before his foundation] etc.., My taking credit for his achievements would have to end tHere . I feel sorry for you that you are not able to spend enough time with your son.Is there no scope for private practice at your place/ I agree that it would not give a fat paycheque lke what you get in employment but when your husband is also earning he should have no issues .Unless everyone gets used to certain styles of living and would not let go of the luxuries they have suddenly got used to.I pray that soemthing works out for you to enable you to devote more time for the family. I was never for employment because I knew i did not have the stamina to take equal care of household and a career. If my husband had not quit his job and opted for his private practice my successful career may not even have begun.It was just God's grace.Similarly I am sure something would work out for you.Good luck!
• India
24 Jun 09
Hi Kala Ya i read the post which you posted on Mimi's discussion,it was really inspiring. You are very lucky that opportunities kept knocking at your door and you exploited them to the fullest. The kind of environment you presented before your family,it was obvious,why your son did his C.A.along with his Bachelors.Am i right? You are working from home ,that is your plus point,that you can always be at the disposal of your family members.I am not.I have to work outside and can spend only a few hours with my baby. I wish i could run a coaching academy like you,but the place where i live will deter me in fulfilling this dream.I used to give coaching to B.COM,M.COM,MBA and C.A.students before my marriage but now i just cannot.
@iskayz (5420)
• Philippines
14 May 09
Hi there! I have seen a big disadvantage when parents are both working. My sister and her hubby works 5-6 times a week and their son is left to his nanny all the time. It's been two years and the child has grown closer to his nanny more than to his parents. Sometimes proper training of the child is not supervised by the parents making the kids stubborn while growing up. If your child is still young I suggest you stay as a homemaker at least until your kid is going to school. If it can't be helped that you must work to aid in the finances, it's still good cause the future of your child depends on you and your husband. But if I were you, there's no problem if I will work but I'd rather tell my husband to go and find a better job with better income. Ciao!
@iskayz (5420)
• Philippines
14 May 09
I understand your situation that you need to help your husband. Just don't let work take all your time away from son. You still have time after work so make the most of it every time your with him. Good luck!
1 person likes this
• India
15 May 09
Thanks for your encouraging words.Ya i always make sure to spend some quality time with him.
• India
14 May 09
Well said that the future of my son lies in our hands but for his future i will have to work.My husband does not earn sufficient money and i have to work to supplement the income.I just pray to God that when my child grows up he behaves like a decent human beings.I just want to get for him the best of the world.
@kawalnarang (1095)
• Trinidad And Tobago
14 May 09
My wife used to work,, afetr the birth of a son and then daughter,, I asked her to stay home,, take care of them,,she agreed,,
1 person likes this
• India
14 May 09
You could say so because your resources were sufficient to bring up the family. I wish my husband could say to me the same but i know he can never because he is not well educated and doing a small job which is not according to our standard of living. Thanks for your response.
• India
14 May 09
You are right Kawal,if there is willingness to look for alternative means to work or to enhance finances only then a person can really explore those alternatives.But if a laid back approach is there then a person can never grow mentally or financially and that is the biggest problem of my partner.
• Trinidad And Tobago
14 May 09
In my experience there were a lot of ups and downs,, ( Like many people)sometimes we have ,sometimes we use what we have and be happy,a job is not difficult in this side of the world,but then again ,, if we are ready to do it or be lazy is the choice
1 person likes this
• United States
14 May 09
My husband and I have been married for 2 years. We have been together for 4 years. I am so thankful that finances were not anything that we ever hid from each other! When we first met, my husband had several thousand dollars worth of credit card debt. He was working his butt off to get rid of it. I was still in school at the time, so during the school year I only made enough money for expenses. We were living together, so he was pitching in for the house expenses as well. During my breaks I would work 80 hours a week, and get as much over time pay as I could! My husband was doing the same thing while he could. We were able to pay off all of his debt before we got married. We currently have 2 car loans and a mortgage - but no other debt. He is going to school now. I have a part time job to pay for tuition, so that we didnt have to get a loan. There is only 1 payment left, so we have almost made it! He will be graduating in July. About that time, my car should be getting paid off. We dont plan on having kids for about 2 years. We are working towards getting ourselves set up financially so that I can stay home when we do. It is a dream of mine. My husband agress that he doesnt want our kids in day care. I look forward to the day that is all possible! It really sucks that you were put into a situation like that. That is totally not fair to you! I hope that you are able to dig yourselves out soon so that you can stay home with your kids again.
1 person likes this
• India
15 May 09
Thanks so much for sharing your story with me.You planned your future and have taken some concrete steps to materialize your planning.If a thing is well started ,it is half done.It was great on your part that you disclosed your finances honestly to each other but in my case my in laws as well as my husband hid the facts from my parents and from me .Since ours was an arranged marriage so i hardly knew anything beforehand.After marriage i came to know that they did not have the so called factory and my husband was not doing anything.Till that time i got pregnant,had i known these facts earlier i would have planned my family accordingly. But i have always tried to emerge myself out of these circumstances and luckily we do not have any loans to pay off,so we are building up our investments which will benefit us in later years.
• India
16 May 09
Had he communicated his failures earlier,i would not have to face these kind of situations in my life.But i am positive and have set my goals and i am all set to go.
• United States
15 May 09
That is awesome that you were able to make the best out of the situation. I hope communication between you and your husband has improved since when you first got married!
1 person likes this
• Singapore
15 May 09
My husband prefers me staying at home and taking care of the house, cook nice food for him. And I too prefer staying home that is why I am a housewife but I still earn good money from home online, so no problems. I do parttime data entry from home, besides many online surveys, and money more so I still earn some good money.
1 person likes this
• India
15 May 09
So you are a lucky lady.I wish you best of luck for your future.
@sanuanu (11235)
• India
15 May 09
The preference is on home maker wife. I would like to be in charge of the house when it comes for financial situations. I always think that it gives a good impact on children if they see their father earning and the mother is taking good care of them at home. I never liked this idea of working couple but I know that it is done due to situation demands.
1 person likes this
• India
15 May 09
You never know what the future holds for you,but you have very basic reasons to be a homemaker.I wish you very best of luck for your future and wish all your dreams and wishes may come true.
@VANILLAREY (1470)
• India
15 May 09
Personally I prefer my wife to be a homemaker. My mother was working prior to giving birth to me. She quit her job to take care of me. She has not worked since. I appreciate the care she gave to me. I would also like my child to get sufficient love from his/her mother. One of friend did not work when she had children. When her children were in college, she realised that her girls can take care of themselves. So she again started to go to work.
1 person likes this
• India
15 May 09
Nice thoughts for your future.I really appreciate your thinking. Alas my husband could think on the same lines but he is not emotionally as well as financially strong to really ponder over this issue.
• Philippines
15 May 09
if money would not be an issue, I think I'd rather be a stay at home mom. it's different when you are there at home, caring for your kids and overseeing what they are doing. it's a bit tough for working moms to actually find the time to be with their kids, sometimes they're too tired or too burned out with work. i'm not yet a mom, but when that time comes, I sure hope our finances would allow me to stay home with the kids.
1 person likes this
• India
15 May 09
Yes i also think on the same terms.Being guided by a full time housewife mother,i have always wanted to stay at home.Mine is 9.30 am to 6.00 pm job.When i get back to home,i am tired too and have household chores to do.I constantly try to do the work as quickly as possible so that i can attend to my child.
• Cebu, Philippines
15 May 09
Nowadays, it's not practical if I just stay at home and just take good care of your kids. In the first place you were sent to college to get a good job or have a business of your own afterwards. And now when you get married, and your husband ask you to stay at home and to take care of you kids, but what IF, time will come your husband will leave you do you think you will get financial support?I don't think so..probably in the states they can demand a financial support but what about here in the Philippines? And what if your husband also is not capable and cannot fulfill the obligations even if you sue him, is there anything that you can do? Based on my situation my I didn't receive any single penny from him since my mom and dad separated 18 years ago, its fortunate that my mom knows how to keep going and really work hard for us to get to college that's the good trait of my mom that i really adore.Now, when your married and have kids and your applying for a job, and the employer would ask you..do you have any working experience? then it happened that you got married after graduation and never had a working experience whatsoever do you think they will hire you? Sometimes MEN is so insecure if their wife had a big salary than them so that's why they tend to ask their wife to stay at home. But do you think it's UNFAIR? You were sent to school to use it but you end up wasting your education in taking care of your kids..well YEs, i do consider that being a plain housewife is a noble job but it's not practical for me. I'm sorry if I offended some of you..but that's what I believe in..I don't want to suffer if ever my husband will leave me for someone else and I don't want my kids to suffer.
1 person likes this
• India
15 May 09
I understand your point of view and first of all thank you very much for sharing your experience with us.I am a chartered accountant by profession and had worked for 4 years before marriage.But this thing was always there in my mind that i always wanted to be a homemaker after my marriage and start off my family as i got married when i was 28 years old and you know that the biological clock was ticking too.I wanted to spend some years at home with my children and really wanted to adjust and adapt accordingly.If these wishes are wrong?I do not think so,once my children will start going to school,i would have started working again. But i am a strong woman and i know my earnings are very much needed for taking proper care of my kid.My husband's income is not sufficient to earn the household affairs and i earn 200% more than he earns .It was not my decision to work but my husband started pressurizing me to work only after few days of our marriage.
@betsyhu (207)
• China
15 May 09
As a female, I would rather do homemaker than work full time now. But family's finance status doesn't allow me to stay home. In my country, femail working though she marriaged or be a mom,is common phenomena in our life. Because if rely on hubby only to provid whole family,it's so uptight for salariat as we're. Ex rich family. So young girls around me all want to marriage man with full of fortunes.
1 person likes this
• India
15 May 09
Ya nice thoughts.One should really marry a person with lots of fortunes.What if a person still wants that his wife bear the burden of herself?
@tracydee (172)
• Philippines
15 May 09
I am born with a full-time working mother. I know it feels to have a working mother such as the lack of time to spend with her and the unsatisfied feeling of the food I eat because our helper cooks for us and not my mother since she is busy with work. Before, I had a feeling of wanting to become a working mother because according to my own mother, I should really secure my own job and not to depend too much to my future husband. But when I met my special someone right now, he made me appreciate a full-time homemaker. He wanted me to take care of our future children, to cook for them and manage the family. I hope and pray that I will be a full-time homemaker with my beloved partner.
1 person likes this
• India
15 May 09
You have gone through the phase and know very well the consequences of having a working mom.I do not want my child to be troubled by these things in life. It is great that your future partner wants you to be a homemaker,who will take care of the house and kids. I wish you all the very best and hope that you spend wonderful and happy time together.
• Philippines
15 May 09
hi! I'm married, I don't have kids yet but I'm three months pregnant right now. I was raised in a home where mom is with us 24/7 and it felt good to have her around while we were growing up. So when I was starting to think about having my own family, I wanted to stay at home and take care of the kids and hubby's needs. I didn't get pregnant right away and it has been more than two years before I finally conceived. When I got married I had a job but I guess it was a good thing I stopped because now I'm pregnant. My OB says I have a case of ovaries that produce small egg cells. I was so scared I'd never be able to bear any children. It was a decision my husband and I had to make and it was a good decision. I would like to be there for my child 24/7 when he/she (i don't know yet) comes out. And perhaps when kids already go to school maybe then I'll think about finding a job again.
1 person likes this
• India
15 May 09
First of all let me congratulate you for going on family way.I have also been blessed by a good mother who is a homemaker and always with us all the time.She nurtured us with so much affection,love,care and discipline that we owe everything to her what we are today.I am a C.A. and my brother is a doctor. It is great that you have left your job to take care of your little prince/princess.I fully appreciate your husband's view also. Thanks for sharing your experience.
@metschica25 (5399)
• United States
18 May 09
Hello my whole life all i ever wanted was to have a family and be there with my kids to be the one to teach them . I dont think there is anything wrong with wanted that , and i am sorry there is pressure (same with my inlaws) i work out of my house as a freelance writer and that is not good enough for them . so to try and make everyone happy i have an array of little jobs i do here and there . one day i would love to finish up my teaching degree , but time and money is not on my side . My hubby always thinks its okay to stay home , and wants that till kids are in school.
@crasks (49)
14 May 09
For a long time I was convinced that I just wasn't the housewife kind of person and I always worked. But a couple of years back when I had a child, I didn't want to leave home. I quit work and stayed home to raise my kid and I loved it. That was a part of me I didn't know. But then when my child was two, I started to feel bored at home. Since then, I've been working freelance so I can manage my hours. So I enjoy both work and homemaking. And now that my kid is a little older, it's fun to see her go to school, grow and hear her start to reason out on things. I hope one day, you can go back spending more time with your child. I think it brings more joy.
• India
15 May 09
Ya you are right,it is a feeling which does not have any substitute.It is only the mother who can teach the child to be a decent human being.I have seen many kids getting spoilt due to improper attendance to them by their parents.I also want to stay at home and raise my child according to my wishes and aspirations. But God has something else in store for me.But i am positive and hoping to get out of this situation as soon as possible.
@jayrene (2708)
• Philippines
14 May 09
during my early years of marriage i was working already, and when i had my daughter is was still working... during those times, i so wanted to stay at home so i can take care of my child, but my husband dont have work that time and he was the one taking care of our daughter. when he did found a job, we switched, i resigned from my work and stayed at home and became a home maker, that was really a joyful thing to do, watching your child grow, doing all those mommy stuff... lol. but now it is different, if i think of it this way, two of my kids are already in schooling and during school times, they are at school from 7 am till 5 pm... i could go back to work if i can find one and i want to also, even if i still have a 2 year old because of financial crisis. i enjoy being a full time homemaker, but if i really need to work, then i will, to help the family also.
1 person likes this
• India
15 May 09
You are lucky jaayrene that you have seen your children grow and doing naughty and mischievous things.It is great indeed that they are going to school and can take of themselves if you are not at home.The right time you spent with them,nurtured them,took care of them.I also want the ditto.I do not know if my this dream will take its shape but i am hoping for the best and i pray to the Almighty that when my child grows up,he will be able to understand my position.
@moujha (86)
• Mauritius
14 May 09
Well, in today's time, i would prefer a working wife because life is too hard. Money is very important and we cannot deny that. A working wife and a working husband brings a lot of money in the household. At start, i believe a couple should strive hard to collect some money at least in their bank account for future use. Imagine the wife bears a baby, a lot of money is needed to rear the child nowadays. Well, it is the woman to decide about if she want to work or stay at home because staying at home also has its advantages. Well, in my family, my mother never worked in her life because dad didn't like her to work as he is here to take care of her and her needs. For me, i would like an understanding wife who would know whats the best thing to do this situation. Another thing i would like if she could work somewhere and then stop to spend some time with her family and then work again to earn. Because the role of a woman is also to take care of the house and its members, god has given her the power, the strength to accomplish these tasks. Both husband and wife working can also have adverse effects on children as children are left uncared. Well, in this case, i believe a woman should stop working as soon as she bears a child as this will give her the chance to shower her affection for her child. As it is said, it is a woman who make a house truly a house.Well, in the end, i need a wife who would do both the roles as working first and then stop to work later to become a homemaker. This would be most ideal for me. Just imagine a child of 2 years is left at home with a babysitter because both parents work, what shall be the reaction of this small baby and am sure he won't get the affection he need to understand and grow well in a good boy.
1 person likes this
• India
15 May 09
If you chalk out your plans for your future,then i think there is no problem.But the difficulty arises when you have some secrets in your mind about your finances.Earning money for investment purposes to be used in later years is the best option and the saved money can be well used for the nurturing of kids. I wish you best of luck and pray to god that you get an understanding and loving wife who can understand and relate to your thinking and aspirations.