Sort of a sticky situation.

United States
June 12, 2009 4:18pm CST
See, I've known this one guy for a long time. Seriously, like, since first grade. A couple of years ago, he asked me out and I said sure - I didn't have any feelings for him, but I'd also never thought about it and we got along really well and so I figured giving it a shot couldn't hurt, and who knows how these things work? Well, this one didn't work out very well. Not that it was bad, but literally nothing happened and it was his first relationship so he was too shy to do anything and I'm not really the gung-ho 'take control' kind of girl so I wasn't going to do anything. I ended up breaking up with him after - get this - three days. It was just not getting anywhere and he was actually avoiding me and talking to me even less! After I broke things off, things at first seemed to go back to normal. We had classes together so we would still chat and talk and goof around. But then after a week or so, he just completely started ignoring me, and its been about two years since then and we haven't talked at all. We pass each other in the halls all the time and just kind of try not to make eye contact, and we're always running into each other because we like the same stuff and hang out in the same places. It's so awkward, and I have no idea what to do! I wish I could just tell him to get over it and stop pretending I'm a stranger, but I mean I haven't put in any effort to make it better either, so we're both kind of at fault. I don't want it to be like that, though. He was a really good friend and I wish I hadn't agreed to go out with him if I knew it would cost me our friendship, and since we're always running into each other, it seems so childish to keep avoiding each other. I know he probably won't do or say anything, so I think it's up to me. But what should I do? How should I go about doing this? And should I even try to fix it?
1 person likes this
3 responses
@khayshenz (1384)
• United States
12 Jun 09
You should try talking to him about it - life is too short for regrets. I said talk because you need to know his side of the story and let him know your side. You need to tell him that you cherish your friendship and thought you were better off as friends than being in a romantic relationship. Then you need to ask him if he can handle that - if he can't, there's no friendship to restore. But at least let him know that you don't like to be treated as a stranger, or as-if you don't know each other. That's juvenile and childish, and from what I can tell y'all are beyond that.
2 people like this
• United States
12 Jun 09
I agree, life is too short, and I suppose the worst that could happen is he says no. Alright, thanks for the advice! I've been thinking about talking to him about it for a few weeks now but wasn't sure if it would be the right move, or what I should say, or anything like that. But your suggestion sounds good, and I think I'm gonna just bite the bullet and go for it. I'd rather try and fail then never try at all.
1 person likes this
@khayshenz (1384)
• United States
12 Jun 09
It's better to know than not know at all - especially when it comes to friendships. I posted a friendship issue a while back (sadly, no one left a comment but no biggie) - and up to this day I sometimes wonder what could have been. At least you won't have wonder about that - good luck!
1 person likes this
@adam1980 (516)
12 Jun 09
have you ever thought that maybe he only was your friend in the first place because he wanted to be your boyfriend and not realy a true friend
2 people like this
• United States
12 Jun 09
Well maybe, but we did hang out in elementary school and back then he thought girls were grody... D; That is a possibility, though, and I hadn't really thought about that. So you think he wouldn't really be interested in becoming friends again if there's no chance of a deeper relationship?
1 person likes this
• Canada
12 Jun 09
Oh man... I dated a guy like that in high school too. We were in the same classes all the way through and, in our last year, he asked me out. He had always seemed like a nice guy and we got along well so I said ok. I should have sensed a problem when we both went separately to our graduation because we had already made plans with our own friends. I mean, it made sense and was the polite thing to do, but was still strange. We dated through the summer between high school and college but really didn't do a whole lot together. He'd come by every couple of days and we'd take a bike ride or just hang out. Then we started at the same college together and even shared a locker. In all this time, I was never once invited to his house and never met his family -- he always came to mine. He never took me out socially like for dinner or anything. We were kind of just "buddies." When I asked a couple of times about meeting him at his house, he would say no. Turns out he had 3 younger brothers and he didn't want them to TEASE HIM about having a girlfriend. At that point, I finally got the message that he had never had a girlfriend before and had no CLUE what to do. He's was awfully immature about the whole thing. I finally ended up breaking up with him because I felt committed to him as a boyfriend but I was never seeing him, he rarely called, I wasn't getting to socialize with him... there didn't seem to be any point to the relationship at all. The day I broke it off (at my house AGAIN LOL), he cried. I felt awful that I hurt him but it was just not a satisfying thing to be with him either. It sounds like your guy was probably embarrassed about "being dumped." You both went out on a limb and tried taking a good friendship to a relationship level. Sometimes, it's kind of like trying to unring a bell, you know? It's difficult to go back. I'd do what has been said so far -- just be the one to talk to him. It's ok to ask him if he feels too uncomfortable to be friends with you anymore. Give him the chance to explain his attitude and behavior and you explain yours. Once it's all out in the open, you're going to know if the friendship is still there and salvageable. It sounds like you still like him and would like to keep in touch... so it's worth being the one to step up and open up the conversation. Good luck to both of you! I hope it works out for you
1 person likes this
• United States
14 Jun 09
Wow, that does kind of sound like my situation. Glad to hear I wasn't the only one who's gone through something like that! I appreciate you sharing that, and I think you're right about him being embarrassed at having been dumped. It was kind of like you said, about how he had no idea what to do, and how I didn't want to hurt him but the relationship wasn't satisfying in the least. Alright, after getting some third party advice on this thing, I think I'm pretty confident about my decision to say something! :) So thanks again for your help and your story!