Why are models skinny?

@suchi60 (912)
India
August 19, 2009 9:31am CST
Models on FTV look extremely thin I comparison to most other women in general. I have read that to become a model one has to maintain an hour-glass figure for which they go on strict diet and take harmful drugs. Can't average and above average figured women succeed in this industry? Shouldn't models look like another women on the street?
3 people like this
19 responses
@Margajoe (4709)
• Germany
19 Aug 09
It should be that way. Normal women (men) as model figures. Problem is the close they wear have to look good. The thinner the person is the better the close fall. Normally. Thin people don't look so thin on a picture. Where as normal people look fat on a picture. This (so they think) make the close not seem to fit good. Sad. In the early days it was the other way around. A women that was to thin was poor. The ones that were heavier, were the rich. They got painted and hung on walls as beautiful women. Personally I think heavy in more beautiful than skinny. My BF lost weight, he looks awful. I like my man to be a little heavy. Skinny people look old very fast. Where as heavier people seem to look a lot younger longer. I think so anyway.
1 person likes this
@suchi60 (912)
• India
19 Aug 09
I think we need to get this message across to those who run the show some more respect to those women who fast and go on strict diet to maintain their figure. I don't think some fat is going to cost them their show. I have a friend who did a couple of modeling assignments only to be discarded later on because she was short (5'4 inches) and heavy (54 Kgs).
1 person likes this
@Margajoe (4709)
• Germany
19 Aug 09
Yes me too. Have you never been to a painting gallery? With old paintings? They normally always painting big women. That was beautiful.
• United States
19 Aug 09
I did not know that about that early days . You know in Africa the queens are always much bigger and that shows their status and all . So maybe in parts time has not changed . With culture maybe plays a huge rule . I think thicker is much better.
1 person likes this
• India
19 Aug 09
well i guess the really slim girls can carry off a lot more dress designs than not. i am not saying that all designs suit only slim figures, but most of them definitely look better on models with good figures. so, i guess it is justified.
1 person likes this
• United States
19 Aug 09
Well, mkrishna22 has a point. In the industry you are expected to show up for a runway or a photoshoot and be able to fit in what they give you (which is normally extremely small). If you can't fit in any of the clothes you are supposed to wear for a shoot, no agency wants to hire you because they can't make money off of when you work. In a way, the skinny situation in modeling IS practical for the business, but that doesn't make it right.
@suchi60 (912)
• India
19 Aug 09
A dress design is not a standard for modelling. If you think there is just one size available for models, then thats wrong. A dress can be made to different shapes and sizes, so why the fuss about just a single size? I don't think there should be any specs on how a dress should be or what kind of body it should fit.
@iskayz (5420)
• Philippines
19 Aug 09
Hi there! My aunt who is a dressmaker said that models are suppose to be skinny so that the dress or outfit they'd have to wear would fit them always. They don't really need to be sexy so as the focus of the viewers would be on the dress and not on their bodies. If models would like other women in the streets, unfit, with body figures not perfect, somewhat fat, or some too thin, how are they going to model a one size fits all dress? Just try to imagine how it will look like hehe. Ciao!
@suchi60 (912)
• India
19 Aug 09
I'm sure many women will disagree with this view. Not all have the body of a model and I don't think that's fair to the millions who watch the program on FTV. Does this mean that the dresses on show are meant only for those who are thin? What I would think is more appropriate would be to have models of all shapes and sizes on the ramp so that there is absolutely no bias and also more and more women get the chance to model.
@iskayz (5420)
• Philippines
19 Aug 09
No that's not what I meant. Surely not all women has a figure of a model but when clothes are made for a ramp show they don't have sizes for everyone. I mean they make the dress only for the size of the models. Now if these dresses will come out in the market, that's when sizes will be available for everyone.
1 person likes this
• Indonesia
20 Aug 09
Well,models are supposed to be skinny because fashion is about beauty and imagination, and I think generally all women wants to be skinny right? But I think the designers is pushing this skinny border so this girls look like walking skeleton. It is very unhealthy for this girls to be that skinny, especially since many of these girls are so young when starting modelling, probably in average are 16 years old. That is why usually when they entering the 20s, their body start to develop into curvier and more voluptous, but still skinny though. The problem also that fashion magazines are doing photoshopped to make this girl not looking that skinny and having healthy skin. In truth if you see like Fashion TV, many of these girls look tired and exhausted because the pressure of work and being skinny. I really hope the trend of supermodel bodies in the late 80s where Cindy, Claudia, Linda, Christy, Naomi etc that really have great sexy bodies will resurge again. I see the hype right now with models like Lara Stone and Edita V.
@suchi60 (912)
• India
20 Aug 09
yes, you're right. I truly hope that there is a wind of change happening and we get to see the likes of yesteryear models emerging.
@jb78000 (15139)
20 Aug 09
good one. i'.m very small and sometimes get a bit annoyed when whrn peopple assume i;m younger than i am.
@jb78000 (15139)
20 Aug 09
sorry, i was commenting there without reading much as i was about to go to bed. it's ridiculous people making assumptions based on your body. again i am tiny and get slighty wound up by people assuming i'm not that bright. same goes for anyone that is not thatever is assumed to be average
@suchi60 (912)
• India
20 Aug 09
There's no harm in being small, none of us are perfect and no one should have the authority to dictate our body condition. I know some may say that noone is forcing you to model, but my argument is why should there be a norm for models? Isn't this biased? I'm sure you have your plus points. Looking young gives you more chances to indulge in other activities. Maybe, you may not be taken seriously in a relationship, but staying young is great.Consider yourself lucky!
@suchi60 (912)
• India
20 Aug 09
I can tell you right away that you're smarter than a lot of women I know. How can you be judged by your size? I had a girlfriend who was about 5 feet, meduim built, but extremely pretty. I was not ready for a serious relationship that time and so dropped out. I'm sure you belong to that breed of beauties. Sure would like to see your photo. Would you oblige?
• Philippines
20 Aug 09
i have a friend who is an international model and she said that they have to maintain a figure that way the clothes that they're modeling should fit them nicely because those clothes that are being modeled are made for a small framed. Probably this is to be blamed on the designer because they're making clothes to be modeled that are small and "not ideal" to the average persons.
• Philippines
20 Aug 09
yup they should consider that not all man/woman are skinny... if they could only put average-sized models or even fat ones... probably people won't be too conscious enough
@suchi60 (912)
• India
20 Aug 09
Yes you're right. The designers and the show promoters are to be blamed for this.I think there have to be some changes; changes which will revolutionize modeling altogether.
@YoungInLove (1254)
• Canada
19 Aug 09
Obviously they can, have you ever heard of full figured models? It all depends on what the look the designer going for is. No offence to some models, but some designers go for ugly or weird lookingones. Either because they a) look unique or b) dont want a pretty face taking away from people looking at their garments. The clothes are on showcase not the girl. So maybe before Id be a bit more worried abotut the modelling industry. But today its changing quite a bit. Even Top Model is coming out with a show for girls who are shorter then 6 feet. Its evolving. And most of the models you see these days you wouldnt even pick out on the street as a model just plain janes.
@suchi60 (912)
• India
19 Aug 09
You may be right to a certain degree, but invariably, most of those on show are skinny. I don't think you need a skinny body to showcase a dress. I'm sure there are many who would agree with me that models with some fat would definitely look sexy.
@metschica25 (5399)
• United States
19 Aug 09
For the most part those models you are talking about are scary skinny and to me they dont even have curves . What they do to their body with diets is scary ( some of them) I think it just started that way, but now their is an array of sizes and all . I think curves and thick is much better ( and its not because that is what I am LOL) I think full figure models look good and healthy . I just started watching the show more to love and to me they look awesome and sexy!
@suchi60 (912)
• India
20 Aug 09
That is indeed a welcome change. I think more and more women from the above-average physique segment should be allowed to model. If modeling is just about showing off new styles and texture, then it should be shown to all by all (by which I mean those who are curvier and fat). hope someone from the industry reads this and does something more for us.
• United States
19 Aug 09
i know right i don't know why they have very skinny modles and they say its close for people of very day i don't look like how i'm i going to compare and see if i look good in it if the person looks like the size of my arm. lol.
@suchi60 (912)
• India
20 Aug 09
Exactly persona_touch! you hit the nail on the head. This is precisely what I'm trying to say. Thanks for the response.
@sblossom (2168)
19 Aug 09
I think the world is getting crazy with beauty. Every one think skinny woman is more beautiful than normal size woman. The commercial world doesn’t care the models health and just want skinny, skinnier and skinniest models. I know because of the TV technology and the picture character, skinner people will look better on TV, but it doesn’t mean there is no limit about skinny. I don’t think more skinny more beautiful.
@suchi60 (912)
• India
19 Aug 09
Precisely! I don't think voluputous women look any less sexier. I would in fact be delighted to see more big women walk the ramp. They have absolutely fabulous body, look pretty and are much, much more livelier. Can anyone say that a Gabrielle Sabatini or a Drew Barrymore for example, looked less sexier?
@tundeemma (894)
• South Africa
19 Aug 09
models are skinny because they just want to be skinny, they often think they will be acceptable to everyone but i don't think so because they often do it to the extreme and most times they injure their bodies
@suchi60 (912)
• India
20 Aug 09
yes, and that's what hurts. Why the restrictions?Let women be the way they are. Don't we as men, find other women attractive? I think I find those with extra flesh more appealing.
• United States
19 Aug 09
Average women can succeed in the industry, but it is extremely hard to even get in if you aren't a perfect height, weight, etc. I modeled for a few years back in middle and high school. I thought it would be a good way to get my self esteem up since I'd always been a loner, but it only ended up making me angry with the industry. I was at a convention where models could meet agents from other agencies in the tri-state area. I had a girl I knew at the time who was 5"2 and about 90 pounds, but only because that was her frame and structure. (The girl COULD eat!) One agency wouldn't accept her because she needed to lose "just a few pounds." That appalled me. Only one agency accepted me because the rest claimed I was too short. (At the time I was 4"10 ish and about 70 pounds...I've always been stick thin.) A lot of short models don't make it because to be runway "material," normally models are taller and lanky. I agree with you. Modeling should be realistic, not dangerous. I actually learned while in my short time in the industry some secrets models would use to look skinnier for just one show or just one shoot. Some girl I met use to literally eat Kleenex tissues so it would absorb the extra water in her stomach and make her stomach thinner for a photoshoot. It's disgusting, and the reason I don't model anymore is because my entire experience in the business was based on how much money they could make using your body. I don't think even fashion should be like that.
@suchi60 (912)
• India
20 Aug 09
You're right lovinglife, models go through a lot of pain and sacrifice which in the context of modern society, is cruel. Like you said,models starve and eat things which they shouldn't only survive in the industry. There has to be some norms laid down to make modeling more appealing to all kinds of men amd women. Just because you have more fat or less height does not mean that you should be discarded. If that's the yardstick to modeling, something should be done about it. All those women who are there on the streets day in and day out don't come anywhere close to those on the ramp. How then should these shows be popular?
@linyun (52)
• China
20 Aug 09
Losing weight and Keeping skinny are the most difficult things in the world.I love dilicious food.
@suchi60 (912)
• India
20 Aug 09
And you should. Keep eating to your heart's content. I don't think you're going to become that fat for men to despise you.
• Australia
19 Aug 09
Well first off not all models are stick skinny. There are regular sized models and even plus sized models. However if you are refering to the super thin figure runway models. Well yes they are way thinner than any normal person should be. That is because when fashion designers make clothes they only make the one size for the runway which is a size 2 even though when they are going to sell the clothes they have many sizes. I think you are right about every body shape being accepted thoguh. I think we should start seeing all size models, big and small on the runway because that is what the real world is made up of and I think people awho are going to buy the clothes would much rather see the clothing on real women with real bodies rather than stick thin girls Great discussion...Thanks for starting it!!!!
@suchi60 (912)
• India
19 Aug 09
Its a dangerous precedent to follow models on the ramp. Too many girls tody think of only one thing; to be as mean and lean like those they see on FTV, discarding all safety rules. It is about time models were allowed to put on weight and be of all shapes and sizes. Afetr all, I wouldn't want my woman to be like one of them.
@youless (112123)
• Guangzhou, China
20 Aug 09
Today people think being skinny is beautiful. The camera likes thin people. So some people take any means to lose weights. Since the model must have a good figure, so they want to keep fit and therefore they are even thinner than normal people. I love China
• United States
20 Aug 09
I think that models need to be skinny so they can fit in every designs easily. If there is a chubby models, she can not wear then. She will get fired. i think that is one of the reasons that midels are always skinny.
@machizmo (279)
• United States
20 Aug 09
I think there is a big problem when modeling has become so limited to a certain body type. It really does help contribute to eating disorders. I hope it does change and there are other types of models but they are not the mainstream.
@patofgold23 (5069)
• Philippines
20 Aug 09
that's one reality we have to accept suchi... fashion industries strive for perfection... it's so unrealistic...women can't have that kind of body and live normal at the same time... the secret to a happy life is eating good food.. i wonder if these models are even happy at all.. they are starvng every day! okay, they are making tons of money.. but they can't even put it into good use, like buying good food. if they gain a little, they're in trouble of losing their jobs.. tsk tsk tsk...... too bad.
• India
20 Aug 09
Extremely High heels are the reason they need to reduce their weight.The thinner you are ,the more comfortable u would be on those heels and can balance and walk properly on the ramp. Another reason as you know very well is to fit into those skimpy clothes