Defense or, Living standards of citizen... Where should we spend more?

India
March 8, 2010 9:41pm CST
Hello friends, I have been thinking of this issue for the past few days. I really can't make any conclusion so far. So I brought this discussion to here in myLot and wanted to know your opinion about the issue. Defense is a sector of prime importance. Without a strong defense no country can peacefully plan its progress. When there is no internal or external peace, all those plans and uplift programs doesn't make any sense. High standard of living for citizens with a weak defense is ridiculous. One has to give defense great consideration if it is a sustainable growth one wants. Also defense, in its core, has the foundation in a countries societal level. If this foundation is not strong enough, both morally and financially, our defense can not be expected to be strong either. The personnel who joins the force, are actually the children of the present social framework we have. With several world agencies taking care of world peace, the need for spending huge amount in defense has reduced considerably. Defense and internal development of a country both are equally important, but in the present global scenario, where do you think we should spend more? Thanks in advance for your participation God bless you all
5 responses
• Bangladesh
11 Mar 10
Hey Biswa, You're right that we should keep our resistance strong and tight. That's why a country has to pay more for maintaining a tough defense as there are aggressive nations around to attack in this world of turmoil. And at the same time, we should mind about diplomatic stances which require quality living standards in order to avoid clash with others. Because along with the improvement of living standards the sense and awareness of defense enhances. Therefore, we should spend most for the strong defense first and then for promoting living standards to attain a developed nation. May Allah bless you.
• Bangladesh
11 Mar 10
Hi friend, Yes, if the strong defense system is not implemented, it's of no use to keep a country secured. And at the same time better education is also required for confirming quality living standard to build up a defense conscious nation. May Allah give you the power of starting good discussions.
• India
6 Apr 10
Thanks
1 person likes this
• India
11 Mar 10
Hello, You are absolutely right bro. Improved living standard is of no value if there is no strong way to protect it. It will look like someone who just earns in order to get burgled on weekends. LOLzzzz. Strong defense program is necessary along with the internal enhancement of the system. But like one of our friends here suggested, true improvement lies in implementation. Thanks so much for dropping by God bless you
1 person likes this
@bobmnu (8157)
• United States
10 Mar 10
I don't know if we need to spend more money or spend it better. It is estimated that the government spends up to a Trillion Dollars a year on poverty Programs. General Welfare or Aid to Families with Dependent Children are often considered the Poverty Programs.A brief search turns up such programs that are income based: Food Stamps, Head Start, Title 1 (Education Program), Medicaid, Pell Grants, Section 8 housing, Earned Income Credit, Fuel Assistance Payments, Work programs, VISTA, America Corp, Social Security / SSI (your payments are based upon your earned income and some people receive it even if they did not work), and many others at the state and local level. If you add them all up it comes to about $27,000 per year for each man, woman and child in poverty. This is more than we spend on defense each year. You also have a government bureaucracy that is dependent on keeping people in poverty to keep their job and keeping politicians elected who will support poverty programs. I ask you who is the program really helping?
1 person likes this
• India
10 Mar 10
Hello, I got your point. Spending the money becomes meaningless if not supported with sincere effort. The wishy-washy attitude almost foils every effort that is made to uplift the living standards of citizen. Finance has never been a problem. Resources were never in short supply. Still without earnestness on the part of those who implements these social program, dreaming about a perfect society is just another wishful thinking. Thanks for such an insightful response God bless you
@vandana7 (98834)
• India
9 Mar 10
Hi Biswa, if I were given the portfolio, I would give highest payscales to people going on front, and reduce, yes, reduce annually the payscales of people in administrative government jobs! :) In the meanwhile, I would give contracts to people like Narayan Murthy, Nandan Nilekani to come up with software that would ensure we dont need government servants in other walks of life. :) I would also encourage scientists to develop medicines, and medical equipment, apart from arms, and other machinery. I would also encourage medical institutions based on number of patients that they were able to attend in any one year. :) That way, private hospitals would get no tax concessions unless they brought down their charges. :) Living standards are of no concern to me. These come down based on the number of mouths to feed. So people who want to improve their living standards would naturally think in terms of reducing their family. I would also encourage non profit organizations to come up with teams that would be good in negotiations. That would help me get good panels of negotiators (without paying) for negotiating issues on borders, and inter state. So much for commissions, and investigations. :(
• India
9 Mar 10
Hello SIS, Hey, you have made some really good points there. Like corruption starts from a certain person and slowly all the system fall into its ripple, reform also starts from a single stage, it will be carried out automatically by an avalanche effect. You've chosen to consider the entire system as a whole, which is often not feasible. There are certain parts you target at a time rather looking at it as a whole. A complete disassembling of the whole system and then troubleshooting one part at a time, that is what I mean. There are limited resources, both financial and human. So all around productivity without fixing the flaws will only make it worse. We are being the third most corrupted country, no matter how much money is sanctioned there is always a sink to suck a major portion away from implementation. Thanks so much for your insight. God bless you
• United States
9 Mar 10
we already have a strong defense department. We should focus on education reform and medical care. I just lost my job as a caregiver for my mom because of the cuts made to Medi-Cal here in California. She is no longer eligible for medical cuz she makes just over the limit per month. She makes $1350 a month for ssi and retirement combined, and the limit is $1250.00. So, she isn't eligible for Medi-Cal, which means she isn't eligible for IHSS, which means while I still take care of her, IHSS wont pay me for it anymore. I can't get another job because my mom can't stay at home by herself for longer than it takes me to rush down the st to go the grocery shopping.
1 person likes this
• India
9 Mar 10
Oh Dear, you are in such a distressing situation. Even thinking of it depresses me to a great extent. Unfortunate are those who can't take care of their parents even if they want to. We really should focus our attention to reforms in internal systems. The system is not flawless. There are people who are suffering without any apparent reason. Even those under imprisonment get better treatment than that. Dear, you have a great virtue. God knows about your sincere urge and devotion to help your mom. Lets pray to God so that he may show us the right path. God bless you
@lady1993 (27225)
• Philippines
11 Apr 10
I think we need to spend more on Living standards so people would have money for defense..
• India
11 Apr 10
Hello lady, Yes, I totally agree with you. Progress should start from inside and work all the way to outside. What I mean is that, an improved living standard is the foundation of economy as a whole. Thanks so much for your participation. God bless you