Would you be a witness in a criminal investigation?

@lumenmom (1986)
United States
July 15, 2010 2:50pm CST
I hear that one of the biggest problems law i=enforcement faces is that people who witness crimes do not want to come forward and testify to what they saw or know. At first I thought they were being lax in doing their civic duty, but then I thought maybe they are afraid of retaliation. I guess if someone is bold enough to commit the crime, they would surely be bold enough to intimidate or threaten a witness. What do you think?
1 person likes this
12 responses
@ucs2121 (33)
• India
16 Jul 10
Yes I am a eyewitness in a criminal investigation but my experience as a eyewitness is very bad. First the public prosecutor threaten me and show me the document of my involvement in the case which is not true. When I told him it is not true what police record said then he demand bribe to record the truth in the case and also threaten me to face prosecution if I am not paid him bribe. My experience said if I really witness a crime I will shut my mouth to avoid this kind of problem.
@lumenmom (1986)
• United States
16 Jul 10
Now that is a scary situation. It is bad enough when you think you may have problems from the criminals, but when the police and prosecutor start doing corrupt things it really is bad. That makes me never want to even think of testifying. You have no way of being assured that you don't get hurt in some in the process.
• India
18 Jul 10
Thank for understanding my situation if I have problem from the criminals, I go with truth but when it is from the law and order management any one do not think of testifying.
16 Jul 10
If someone is in trouble and I'm the only witness why not as long as my family have protection and me. But if the person is not that capable to have that then maybe just for the sake of the victim. It is our duty to help the person in need and we have our own responsibilities to the community or people around us. don't be intimidated as long as you know the truth.And if the other parties have much money well maybe a loyal lawyer will do not to be bought buy the other party. An honest investigation and proof that's the fight for real justice. no evidence of the crime low possibility of winning in the case.
@lumenmom (1986)
• United States
16 Jul 10
The problem is that there usually is not real protection for you or your family. It would be nice if you could just be honest and tell what you know without having to worry about retribution, but the reality is people love to seek revenge and criminals more than anybody hate to double crossed. They don't play fair in the first place, that's why they do the crimes they do. It is risky to testify but sometimes it's the only way to put the bad guys behind bars.
16 Jul 10
well,lumenmom thank you for responding.We all know that part but revenge is making the crimes more complicated than they think it is.Will it helps?I don't so.It is just making the twist and turns of the case and it will become more difficult resolving it. It is more risky to testify when their is twist and turn more harder and longer testimony.
@dodo19 (47095)
• Beaconsfield, Quebec
15 Jul 10
Fortunately, I haven't been in this situation. If I was, I might a little scared to come forward, but I think that I would, mainly because I know it's the right thing to do and I had witnessed a crime. A crime is wrong.
@lumenmom (1986)
• United States
16 Jul 10
It is definitely the morally right thing to do and it sometimes is the only way to get the criminals. Many of them get away with their crimes when witnesses do not testify. But there is the very real fact that testifying is risky and can cause you problems down the road and in some cases you very life. It is a tough thing to think about.
• Philippines
15 Jul 10
I have never been in that situation but if I was, I would probably be as scared as hell and I would be torn between testifying and hiding out. In the perfect world, we are all brave and we want to fight crime, but the thing is we do not live in a perfect world, we live in a world of fear and that's the reality.
@lumenmom (1986)
• United States
16 Jul 10
That is a very honest answer and probably what a lot of people think when they are actually faced with the situation. It is very easy to say what we would do when we are not in that situation, but the human side of us takes over and ultimately it sides with self preservation.
@RawBill1 (8531)
• Gold Coast, Australia
15 Jul 10
That would be a really hard decision to make. It would be scary to be in that situation as the fear of the friends or family of the criminal getting to you would be very real. If I were motivated enough by the crime and desperately wanted the criminal put away, then yes I would do it, but if I was not emotionally connected to the crime and only just witnessed it as a bystander, then it might be hard for me to stand up and testify.
@lumenmom (1986)
• United States
16 Jul 10
I agree the emotional connection would be an influencing factor in deciding to testify, given the very real risks and not to mention the hassle involved. I thought it would be an easy decision to make knowing I like to do the right thing, but as I see other answers I realize there is so much more involved than one might see at first. This could really be a life altering decision.
• United States
16 Jul 10
No never i dont want to be in all this things its frealy not gud to be in these things i dont like all thois things but if that witnees is true then i would try the best to help her..
@lumenmom (1986)
• United States
16 Jul 10
I think we all hope we don't have to do something like this. A lot of people know it can cause problems for them down the road so they won't get involved either.
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
16 Jul 10
Hi Lumenmom, I have come forward with info for the cops in certain situations and I'll tell you...I don't like to at all. I have done it only when it is a crime that is hurting others and only if I am very sure. I really don't like being in that spot at all. If it is something stupid that has hurt no one then I do keep my mouth shut. With small stuff, I have managed to handle stuff without going to the cops. Like say, shoplifting...I don't involve the cops. Once a kid came in the store and was so so so drunk that he sat on the floor and was passing out. I did not call the cops. I did call his parents to come get him before the cops saw him in that condition. If it were a real crime like a murder or something, I would speak out and not think twice about it. A lot of times though, I would say you are better off just staying out of it though.
@akopoaysi (739)
• Philippines
16 Jul 10
i really cant say. i think if i've witnessed a crime ideally i will tell it to police and i will testify if it is really necessary but i cant say if i can do that because i will always think for the safety of my family and myself. but if i think testifying will be more safe than keeping myself quiet ill do it definitely. i still cant say. it will be a hard decision.
• India
15 Jul 10
You may have heard True.. The reason is the witness are not supported by Government.. The support should be Strong not just false/weak claims.. To Threaten a witness is not the solution.. it creates more problems instead.. The best is witness should be ready with their mind and soul and should not fear the near future.. As well as providing good support for witnesses.. if this happens then.. Every witnesses shall give their witness openly.. Hence Crime Rate Falls Down.
@lumenmom (1986)
• United States
16 Jul 10
Witnesses should be better supported by the government. They have a reputation that they do not care about the witnesses once they get their testimony from them. I think they also underestimate the potential of some criminals to do or cause harm to people to avoid paying the punishment for their crimes. If witnesses could feel somewhat safe by giving their testimony they probably would do it more. Another issue is people who personally know they criminals do not want to snitch on their friends or family even though they know they are doing wrong. I was faced with that with a cousin of mine who was always in trouble for one thing or another. I told him I would not lie for him or try to hide him from police and he got angry with me but he knew I was serious so he stopped coming around me. This was a few years ago and he's doing much better now, but he still keeps his distance.
@dsrp82 (676)
• Brazil
16 Jul 10
Good question. If I hadn't a family, I would. I'm not affraid to die, but thinking in loosing someone I love scares the hell out of me.
• Indonesia
15 Jul 10
depend, if i see the situation is really bad and the crime is involved with big crime organization like mafia or cartel who willing to do anything to cover up their operation i think i will keep my mouth shut, except it has something personal with me. if it's just a smile and lil time crimes it won't be a problem and i will testify 100% :) and about crime bold enough to intimidate the witnesses, i guess it's depend on how big time that crime is, if it's only a low criminal like mugger or thieft, i guess some of them don't have the courage to "intimidate" their witnesses (and it's depend on the witness attitude too)
@lumenmom (1986)
• United States
16 Jul 10
I guess that would be true of anybody that it depends on the situation. I don' think none of us wants to tangle with the mob under any circumstances, but for the average crime it might be a bit easier to testify.
@lunchz (43)
16 Jul 10
Probably not even though i witnessed it i will not testify.. i still want to live please.. ahaha lets just trust that God will do the proper sanction to those criminals that committed crimes.