Should Bella go with Jacob?

United States
July 18, 2010 1:34pm CST
Do you think Bella should leave Edward for Jacob? Or should she get married to Edward?
1 person likes this
6 responses
@jimmy7512 (213)
18 Jul 10
Well in the film she goes with Edward because she loves him more, if she loved Jacob more then she would go with him but thats not how it is unfortunately. It would have been great if she went with Jacob but it seems Edward is more attractive to her and she loves him so nothing can change that...
• United States
18 Jul 10
WellI think you should read the script and find out. hehe
• United States
18 Jul 10
Oh I've read the book I'm just asking on an opinion
@BethannTT (222)
21 Jul 10
No, im not a fan of pedo's. I never understood why he was so tanned if he lives in a place where it NEVER rains. Ofcourse she marries edward! shes not completely stupid, although she is fairly close.
• Romania
19 Jul 10
Hello everyone! I`ve read all four Twilight books and i think i can respond to this question. Bella should certainly marry Edward because she can`t live without him,as you saw in the second film ,New Moon.You saw her reaction when she found out that he was going to the Volturi to kill himself.And by the way, Bella is not Jacob`s soul-mate. If Bella wouldn`t marry Edward,she wouldn`t give birth to Renesmee and Jacob could never find his soul-mate(Renesmee).So everyone`s happy with his/her half. In conclusion I have no doubt that Bella did the right thing marrying Edward.
• United States
18 Jul 10
I love the twilight series and have read all of the books. As I was watching the movie, "Eclipse", even though I knew what was going to happen, I found myself wishing that she would dump Edward and run off with Jacob. She admitted that she was in love with Jacob, yet she said that she loved Edward more. It would have been better for her if she would have chosen Jacob. Aside from the fact that he is gorgeous, she would have had a better life and future.
• United States
18 Jul 10
Read Breaking Dawn? Bella marries Edward and they live happily ever after, THE END!!! Well... there's a slight delay between the wedding and happily ever after but still. They're going to adapt Breaking Dawn the way it was written. The end pairing will not change. From book one, I always wanted Bella end up with Edward. Jacob was nice and he's a good guy most of the time, but he was never meant for Bella.