husband's salary goes all to the wife

@tigeraunt (6326)
Philippines
October 17, 2010 12:15am CST
dear friends, do you think it is right for the wife to hold on to all the salary of her husband? if that is the case, isnt it like that you are not giving him the chance to help you budget the money? how do wives make the budget? is it an open book to the husband? i want to know your opinion. ann
5 people like this
10 responses
• Philippines
19 Oct 10
Well, well, well, ammmhhhhppp.. I think it is not a good idea. Before I also wanted to get all the salary of my husband, because he doesn't know how to budget his own money and I believe, I am more capable of handling money than he knows. But lately I had realized that it is not good for the reason that he worked hard for it so he should have a greater control for it. I also know that most husband doesn't like their wives to hold all their income even for the benefit of the family. Let our husbands have the custody of their own money but we can ask from them or advice them if they're been very prudent.lol
1 person likes this
@tigeraunt (6326)
• Philippines
21 Nov 10
hi mac, it is one good way too to make them realize that budgeting is not easy especially if the money is just enough. you can let him have the headaches too. have a nice day. ann
1 person likes this
• Philippines
9 Jul 11
Hi aunt thanks for marking me. I would never knew that you rated me as BR, if I didn't posted discussion today about BR.thank you very much. It's been a while but still it gives me a happy feeling..thank you.lol
@bodhisatya (2384)
• India
17 Oct 10
Eh.. well I am not married yet so I will have to find out how this thing works! Ummm quite a things to learn then I guess hehehehe...
1 person likes this
@tigeraunt (6326)
• Philippines
17 Oct 10
hi bodhi, that response made me laugh. hmm, surely you will have to learn about it. i guess you need to plan how it will be when u get married. should you pool both your incomes? list the things that needs to be paid, what to buy and not to buy for that particular month.. etc. or should you take out the conjugal savings first before you budget... ?? what if it is short? that... will make you think now. hehehehehhe ann
• India
17 Oct 10
Oh! Dear! why am I getting so nervous after reading this hehehehehe I not so good with so many tasks at a time. Now if I have any trouble I know whom to come for advice
1 person likes this
@tammytwo (4298)
• United States
22 Oct 10
My husband loves it this way. He does not like to worry about the bills so he wants me to deal with it. Until recently I was OK with it but since the economy has been bad and it seems it takes every penny to make it I hate taking care of it all. We have been told that he should at least KNOW what we are paying out so if something happens to me he can deal with the bills. I have written it down and showed him. But he still has no interest in knowing. I'm not one who spends money frivolously so he doesn't worry about that. I am very conservative and am always looking for new ways to SAVE money!
1 person likes this
@tigeraunt (6326)
• Philippines
21 Nov 10
hi tammytwo, trust is the main ingredient in a couple. and one way to be trusted is by keeping him well informed of the expenses from his hard earned money. thank you for your response. ann
@youless (112164)
• Guangzhou, China
19 Oct 10
I think it is better for the wife to hold on all the income. My husband gave me all of his bank accounts to handle. So when he gets the salary every month, I can withdraw it and then pay for the bills and also deposite to my bank account. Our savings are in my bank account and sometimes I can use it for the investment. I love China
1 person likes this
@tigeraunt (6326)
• Philippines
21 Nov 10
hi youless, that is a good arrangement. whoever knows how to handle a budget has to handle the cash. have a nice day. ann
@Aaleexix (2290)
• India
19 Oct 10
It is very critical matter. As wife woman can help to make the budget of the family. But unwanted interfere may creates conflict. Some time husband want to hide a small part of their salary for some specific purpose. If such happens then I think wife should tolerate that.
@tigeraunt (6326)
• Philippines
21 Nov 10
hi aaleexix, of course the bread winner has the right to keep part of his hard earned money. the wife just needs to be told so that there will be no conflict. it is best that the wife knows or some problems may crop up and negative thoughts come up with it. have a nice day. ann
• India
17 Oct 10
Anny dear Not all in my case, all members in my family have their shares, as soon as i get my pension i put some in some recurring deposit accounts in the name of my wife, kids and grandkids, well my wife is sick, so i have to spend a good sum every month on her medicines, that's my basic duty as husband.. i also keep some money in an account to meet the expenses on gift to friends and beloved abroad.. Thanks for sharing. Cheers. Professor. .
1 person likes this
@tigeraunt (6326)
• Philippines
21 Nov 10
hi professor, its true that there are many men who can handle cash better than women. that amazes me but then, a couple can agree which is the better way. thank you for your response. have a nice day. ann
• United States
10 Jul 11
I can see if she is a stay at home wife and he is a shopaholic and she needs to make sure their bills get paid. But if they Both work and he is good with money , then it isn't fair. they both should handle the bills. Unless , she is better with figures then I go back to saying it is ok.
• United States
11 Jul 11
Thanks.
@tigeraunt (6326)
• Philippines
11 Jul 11
hi, i can say you always think practical. of course, who handles the budget well gets the bulk. ann
1 person likes this
@EdnaReyes (2622)
• Philippines
17 Oct 10
household budget is shared between me and my husband. He pays for certain things and obligations and I for the other. We have an agreement on this before we got married. If one could not do his share, one takes over but only until the time she or he could assumes paying the obligations. It's a give and take agreement but I guess this only works if both are earning and working!
@tigeraunt (6326)
• Philippines
21 Nov 10
hello edna, this is a very good agreement. it is very difficult to do the budgeting hence to make it open and transparent, both should do it. have a nice day. ann
@exx007 (167)
• Philippines
17 Oct 10
I don't think of that traditional practices
1 person likes this
@tigeraunt (6326)
• Philippines
17 Oct 10
hi, i wish you have explained further why you do not think of the traditional practice, if that is what you call it. then what should it be? what is right for you and what isnt? thank you. ann
@liewss80 (85)
• Malaysia
17 Oct 10
Its definitely not a good practice. Wife should be keep parts of the income but not entire. The husband shall be smart enough to take care of his financial need and make good use of the money instead of letting the wife to keep it.
@tigeraunt (6326)
• Philippines
17 Oct 10
hi liewss, you have a point there. but i am just curious, will you be open to your wife about these "financial needs"? then if that is the case, that you will do the budgeting, maybe it is right for the wife to know where the money goes. so what do you give her? report? no offense.. we are just discussing here. ann