Money budgeting

@ddaguno (3107)
Philippines
March 1, 2011 4:16am CST
As a part of some wedding ceremonies, a small pouch with coins is given to either the wife or husband. This symbolizes who will become the designated 'budgeter' of the family. If the wife gets it, it means that the husband should give all his salary to his wife and then the wife will decide how to spend for the family. Do you agree with this? For me, it seems so unfair that only one would know about how the bugdeting goes.
1 person likes this
7 responses
@mtrguanlao (5522)
• Philippines
1 Mar 11
Hello there! I remember having this small pouch on our wedding but I don't believe in the meaning of it based on our traditions. Basically,the wife is really the budgeter in a family and the husband is the provider but that doesn't necessarily mean that the whole salary of the husband should be given to the wife. I think that's too selfish if that would be the arrangement,lol! Poor husband!
@thesids (22180)
• Bhubaneswar, India
1 Mar 11
Hi dear friends I must agree with mtr that wife is the budgeter and in my family she is the provider too. I merely add a few cents here and there occasionally Poor Husband
@ddaguno (3107)
• Philippines
1 Mar 11
I agree! Selfish indeed. I have a friend who gives all of his salary to his wife. Poor guy, so full of self pity and I cant blame him. He barely has money for food sometimes.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
1 Mar 11
@Sids..hello my friend! You're so lucky to have a wife like yours and she's lucky to have you too! Miss yah friend! I still have to catch up with your discussions tonight. See yah! @ddaguno..yes,poor guy! His wife should try to give something for him if she really loves him.
@owlwings (43915)
• Cambridge, England
1 Mar 11
Who decides who gets the coins? I suspect that it is one or other of the in-laws who makes the decision. That is SO 'controlling', don't you think? It is one thing to wish a couple happiness and success in their life together and to be willing to help them when they need it: it is quite another to say "We have decided that you will manage the money!" I think that the husband and wife between them should decide who does the budgeting and, in any case, a household budget should be a JOINT thing, though, perhaps, one partner may do the work involved in working out a budget because some people are better at figures than others.
@ddaguno (3107)
• Philippines
1 Mar 11
I believe it is the couple who decides who gets to keep the purse but for sure the in laws are a big influence on the decision.
• United States
1 Mar 11
I've never heard of such a tradition. But I'm with owlwings. In a marriage (or even any other similar situation), both individuals need to be able to work together to make the financial decisions. If only one person is doing it all, then that could lead to tension down the road if the other person doesn't like how the finances are being held up. And what if the "accountant" (so to speak) has an addiction like gambling? You'd never know until the card is declined when you go for some milk or the eviction notice is on the front door.
• United States
2 Mar 11
Both parties should understand how the money comes in and out of the household but often one person is better at handling finances than the other. To have some arbitrarily decide Y is better than X or vice versa can be dangerous.
@dreamy1 (3811)
• United States
1 Mar 11
Sometimes one person is better than the other with money. If it comes to the household expenses both people need have a say in where the money is spent but I also believe each person needs to have their own money to spend. One person shouldn't control everything without the other knowing but if one person is better than handling money then the other person needs to trust the one who is better at handling the money.
• United States
2 Mar 11
This is my belief too, but that money person can't be 'protecting' finances from the spendthrift in the relationship either. When my mom was in a medically induced coma, the household accounts were frozen, even to my father, because they didn't take steps to prevent that. And my boyfriend, currently separated from his wife (she walked out ten months ago) knows nothing about his finances. Apparently his wife didn't know or care either (and I won't consider marrying him either). Communication within the marriage is important. ESPECIALLY with and about money!
@anneshirley (1516)
• Philippines
1 Mar 11
I don't know this tradition since I've never seen one but when it comes to married couple, they both have the task to do budgeting for the family. I totally disagree with girls do the budgeting while males do the lavishing. It is a hard earned money that will be use only for the benefits of the family. If they are both conscious about how they spend money, surely they will have enough savings for their kids.
@ddaguno (3107)
• Philippines
1 Mar 11
Hi anneshirley! this is a tradition in Filipino weddings but I think more couples are choosing not to have it in theirs anymore which I think is wise. I know of some couples who fight because only one of them gets to decide on the budgeting. Unfortunately, she's not that good with it.
@tkonlinevn (6447)
• Vietnam
2 Mar 11
I don't think that this is unfair. Money should be focus on one person. Then, when you want to use it, you can discuss to each others. If you can do this, you can safe the money. If not, I don't think that money can be kept well for a long time.
• United States
2 Mar 11
But what if that person isn't good with money but the other one is? Money issues are one of, if not THE reason that many couples in the US divorce.
@boboypete (209)
• Manila, Philippines
1 Mar 11
I had an experience of attending actual wedding ceremonies... and even me and my wife did it in a cathedral wedding four years ago. It is normal that we did this thing as a symbol of financial cooperation, agreement and different aspects too. I don't think that the budgeting should only done by one partner especially ladies out there but of course by the two couple since there are instances that a wife has no good financial capabilities and so with the husband either. We are thinking that marriage is not only love and partnership but it is the foundation of financial structures ans establishment. Everyday people spend money in daily activities yet they are engaged in budgeting too, otherwise if one man has no target limit of spending he would lost money and might result to use credit cards or lending pennies as well. Hence, both husband and wife should agree on their finances and both of them would give extra care to shoulder the all the expenses wisely for the good and happy living on earth.