Pro-life or pro-death sentence?

@staria (2780)
Philippines
March 26, 2011 8:21pm CST
Crime rate in the Philippines is getting out of hand. Some say that it is getting worse because the Philippines only has life sentence as ultimate judgment for crooks. While some wanted the govt/supreme court to bring back death sentence, the Church (again) is not into it. I am torn between being a pro-life and pro-death sentence. Of course we wanted crime rates to lower down and we want these stopped. But do we really have the right to take away other people's lives? There are 3 people to be executed in China now because of drug mulling. But if this happens in the Philippines it would only be life sentence. So what are your thoughts on this? Pro-life or pro-death sentence?
9 people like this
10 responses
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
27 Mar 11
I am not for capital punishment. I did not give the life. I cannot take it either.
@staria (2780)
• Philippines
28 Mar 11
I hope that we can still say that even if the victim is someone close to us or a loved one.
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
29 Mar 11
That will not happen to any of my loved ones.
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
27 Mar 11
Hi staria, You can be sure of one thing, we do not have the right to take another person's life. Capital punishment is always wrong, no matter what the crime. Bringing in capital punishment will not lower the crime rate, in fact it would probably make it worse as has been shown over and over again. Blessings.
2 people like this
@staria (2780)
• Philippines
29 Mar 11
That's why I am sitting in the middle. In a way I want it to be implemented here in the PH again. In a way I am thinking about our moral responsibility. We should be preserving life and forgiving. And I am aware of that. But due to the rising crime rates, somehow I am contemplating. How come it wouldnt help, somehow they will be afraid. We are giving them something to be afraid of. If they arent afraid to kill someone, they might be afraid to lose their lives for it.
@aerous (13434)
• Philippines
28 Mar 11
I am pro-life and I don't want someone to be killed or someone to die due to some reasons of the law... But sometimes we look into gravity of the crimes being committed and the victims right...I think let the sentence being carried out not to killed the criminal beyond his/her sentences
1 person likes this
@aerous (13434)
• Philippines
31 Mar 11
But they are thinking about the consequences they do. If they are educated enough for good behavior I think they prevent to do such crimes...
@staria (2780)
• Philippines
14 Apr 11
Being educated can take you to places, apart from these situations.
@staria (2780)
• Philippines
31 Mar 11
Some because of poverty, some are just out of their minds, that imo.
@webearn99 (1742)
• India
28 Mar 11
I am pro life, without any doubt. It is not because I believe in being humane, it is because I think we are letting these criminals get away with maybe some pain. They should be made to pay for all they have done and suffer what they have done, bit by bit, year by year for as long as they live.
1 person likes this
@webearn99 (1742)
• India
29 Mar 11
That comfort has to be denied to them for as long as they live!
@staria (2780)
• Philippines
29 Mar 11
Life long suffering as they say, it is like a living hell for them. That is subjective if they will really suffer. Some prisons are even more comfortable than the homes of the poor. They can eat on time, while poor people outside's dying of hunger. There are also those rich criminals who lives like a king inside the prison.
@staria (2780)
• Philippines
31 Mar 11
True!! They should not live in comfort and ease, not thinking about how they should eat or live!
@obe212003 (2299)
• Philippines
27 Mar 11
Pro-life as life is a precious sacred gift from God.. we live our lives, make choices and decisions that seem to determine the kind of life we want to live, and the outcome of which would result to some dire consequences if there is no guidance and blessing from Him... but even if we commit mistakes i.e. to commit crime, there should always be a chance to realize and learn from these...
2 people like this
@staria (2780)
• Philippines
28 Mar 11
True, there's always a second chance and God is our ultimate judge. That's why I am double minded about this issue.
• United States
27 Mar 11
I was on a jury trial here in Illinois for the first case to be tried for the electric chair years ago. It was quite an experience for me and one that I would have never volunteered to be in. Due to my ignoring jury duty, I was summons and sort of forced to be on this. I have to say the 7 1/2 weeks that the trial lasted was the most scariest feeling ever, to learn about the heinous crimes and types of people involved. It is quite puzzling to be one of the people to determine the future of a person and one I would not wish my worst enemy to be part of. I was crossed between whether a yes or no vote because I can't imagine being responsible for ending someone's life, on the other hand the person was not a good person per se either. So fortunately for me of the jurors when it was my turn to state which route 3 others had already said no, so I never had to say yes, or no. Sometimes I feel that if the crime fits perhaps ending their life suits, but I am human too and don't know if I could be responsible for the decision. Still to date it is puzzling to me to have to make this sort of decision. Glad that I have not had to again, and keeping my fingers crossed that I don't ever have to because I really do not know which route to decide on something like this. I suppose if the crimes fit then the person does not deserve to live, and all I think about is a person sitting in prison enjoying life while their victims no longer can be breathe.. as yet this is difficult for me to be a decision maker.
@hofferp (4734)
• United States
27 Mar 11
I am in favor of capital punishment for specific crimes, murder being the most obvious. But before we execute someone, I want to be absolutely positive the individual did the crime. I'm not sure that capital punishment will or will not reduce the crime rate, but my position isn't founded on that premise anyway.
1 person likes this
@wadabski (761)
• Philippines
29 Mar 11
If you try to see it in a Christian way yes a fellow human being is never given a right to take away life. If you try to see it in another point it would discourage criminal acts and would it may decline the criminal cases because these certain people are killed and cannot do more harm to others. let this serve as a lesson for all that do not do something that you know you will regret in the future.
1 person likes this
@staria (2780)
• Philippines
30 Mar 11
it will really depend on how you perceive this issue. There will be someone who will go for it, while there will be someone who wont agree. This is a very sensitive issue imo
@zills66 (1419)
• Saudi Arabia
27 Mar 11
??? }?????? ??? ?? ???? ????? ???? ?????????? why chinese hates filipinos that much? i don't understand! regardless of what a person did to his fellow, only God has the right to take another life!
1 person likes this
@gleness1 (20)
• Philippines
29 Mar 11
on ethical and moral grounds, its always pro-life. human decisions shouldn't end another human life. lets give those people another chance, there are always second chances.
1 person likes this
@staria (2780)
• Philippines
29 Mar 11
I believe too that there's room for second chances, if God was able to forgive all of the sinners no matter how big or small their sins were, then we should be able to do that too. Though hard.