Haley Rhinehart is out....

I really don't care who wins.When James was eliminated, i stopped watching the show altogther.I guess if i had to make a choice between Scotty(boring) and Lauren,i would choose Lauren, since she at has far more talent than the one note country singer Scotty.

I held my breath when it was Haley and Lauren left. I really felt sorry for Haley and she did look rather stunned. I love both Scotty and Lauren and will feel badly for whomever will lose..but they haven't really lost. They are now well known and will go on to make a great career and will imo do extremely well!!

I thought that Scotty and Haley was the logical choice to be the ones left standing. I know that Lauren is good, but I think she is too much like Carrie Underwood. Which means that spot in the music market (for an AI winner), is already taken. I think Scotty would win, so that AI could put out a male country singer. Of course Haley would have been the Adele-type, bluesy, rock & roll singer that AI could position in to.

I was expecting Lauren and Scotty to be the last ones out. I remember posting that to one of the discussions a few weeks ago. This is going to be a Scotty win.

I was really disappointed when I first learned about that. Seriously, I have grown to love Haley. She's not my favorite at first, but she just amazed me as time went on. She simply is the best. I really thought she'd make it to the finale. :( But it's ok. She's a fighter. I hope she makes it big in the music industry. Now, I hope Lauren wins. She's my second choice anyway. :)

scotty has a unique voice..what i mean is that he has one of the unique voices in AI, while lauren has this very sweet voice that can sing any song... but honestly, i really did not expect that they would go this far in the competition, i believe Kacey and Haley, should be in the finale.. but i'd rather pick lauren because she really blooms and improved a lot during the competition...

lost my interest watching AI. it was only Haley that kept all of us in the family to still watch though KC lost. Haley deserves to win because she has that confidence, voice, style, performance that a winner has to have. some people are talking about attitude when it should not be a point against her because as a performer, one has to have that character and attitude.

I think Haley lost out due to her attitude more then her singing abilities. I now don't care who wins it all because both Scotty and Lauren are really very good. If you had asked me from the beginning who would have been standing there next week I would have thought for sure it would be Pia and Jacob. I think it will be Scotty winning because there are so many young girls out there in love with him.

Too bad, I loved Haley too..now I really don't like Scotty since he has so many fan girls that vote for him even though he doesn't really deserve it. He is a nice kid though.. Well, I just hope Lauren wins it.

Oh, I feel sad to hear that. Haley was a powerhouse yesterday. Oh, well. Of the two remaining, I think that Lauren is the more powerful singer. But, Scotty is such a gummy bear! Calling all ye, women out there, young and old...

i am not a fan of haley, neither to the remaining top 2. I like Pia a lot, too bad she got eliminated early..