Religion and Relationships

Philippines
August 27, 2011 3:51am CST
About 2months ago my brother broke up with his girlfriend due to conflicts with their religion. They were together for about 7months and because of the difference in the their ways of worship, they decided to break up. My brother is a catholic and his girlfriend is an INC and they did get a long most of the time until the question of where would their relationship end up. My brother would tell his girl to have a conversion but the girl would insist that he should be the one to convert. An endless cycle of arguments led to the break up where in the girl would always answer to give her time to think even though she really wouldn't convert because her family has been INC for a long time and she would be the one to represent their family when the time comes. My brother on the other hand doesn't also want to be converted to INC due such rules that doesn't appeal to him as fair and reasonable. I'd like to take sides on this one but I think it's just a matter of good communication. Opinions about how the difference in the religion of two people should affect their relationship with each other affect them.
1 person likes this
9 responses
@TrvlArrngr (4045)
• United States
27 Aug 11
Religion is one of those things that can make or break a relationship. That's why it's important to discuss these things before you get too committed. Sorry they had to go thru that.
27 Aug 11
Yah. I agree with you. Why do people still continue the relationship if from the very start they both knew that they won't give up the kind of faith they believe in.
@Triple0 (1904)
• Australia
28 Aug 11
But it's kinda sad how religion can easily break up a relationship. What if you love that person but you can't due to religious conflicts. Though, it is better to consider religion before progressing further in the relationship or else it will get worse.
@stanley777 (9402)
• Philippines
30 Aug 11
Well, as far as I have observed people f different religion would never really end up together, one of them always has to convert to the other religion. S they shouldn't be having relationships with those of different religions t begin with if they don't want to transfer to other religion. That's just how it is these days..
@skysuccess (8858)
• Singapore
28 Aug 11
justinbeltran, I believe this is one area where I've heard endless times that love conquers all and that it can overcome issues like religious differences. But, call me a skeptic I've always asked that they should be prepared to walk before they can truly say it. Like your brother, I am sure you can see that there's really no end or rather solution when neither party could come to a compromise or giving in. At relationship level, it will be the hope that one of the party relent or compromise by giving the other party the allowable space to practice and observe. As time progresses, it will be struggles about spending that weekend together at a place of worship, observance of rites or practices of faith. In some it would even mean going through certain rituals and change of name as well. Then, when the children arrives it will be decisions on what is to be taught, who to follow on a Sunday, what to observe and do for certain occasions. Imagine the struggles, conflicts and confusions they face at a tender age. To be honest, these differences does not end with both parties but are interrelated into other areas as well. So, it is good that couples should try to be as level headed and objective to consider all aspects of their paths.
@mods196621 (3652)
• Philippines
28 Aug 11
Mostly if they dont get a serious talk about it, because these will affect to their children in the future to where they baptize. Anyway before that happen first they need to agree both to where they convert or who will converted to one side religion. But i know some other families that live happily even they are separate in beliefs. Now i think that one has to give way...
@ebuscat (5935)
• Philippines
28 Aug 11
For me yes but if no one can gave up there way of living it is sound no good so better to breakup.
@pbbbsra (1214)
• Philippines
27 Aug 11
Me and my husband also have different religion when we started. I am Christian and he is a Muslim. He gave me the freedom to worship in the way I grew up with. I converted. I am now a Muslin too but not because he want, not because he is a Muslim and not to make him love me more. I started reading and listening and learning the ways of Islam and I was Enlightened. I feel a new life now. It is my choice, he did not even want me to convert because he is thinking that I am doing it for him, but I really wanted it for myself. About your cousin. If they have different views on worship and none of them don't want to compromise, then it is not easy. My uncle and his long time girl friend are both Christians from different sectors and broke up too, they have the same kind of Faith and practices, but argued a lot on which house of worship they will go. They always argue on which church they will attend a Sunday Service, and ended up breaking up. They are both happily married now with different partners but I admit that I really loved them as a couple. Religion can have a big impact on the relationship if two people are not willing to listen and give understanding to the other person.
@tessa9 (1085)
• Philippines
27 Aug 11
Religion is one big hurdle for couples of different religion to get along with. I been to a few wedding where two ceremonies took place. The latest one that I went to was my cousins wedding. She is an Anglican and her husband is Catholic. Neither one of them wanted to convert but that was not that big of a deal because from early on their relationship, they both knew and said that they wont. The church wedding was pretty long because they did the Catholic ceremonies then added Anglican ceremonies. I don't think that INC and Catholic can do the same, can they? I have yet to be aware of it occurring. I do agree that communication is key, No one should feel pressure to convert.l If they want to then it should be wholeheartedly.
@chicko (86)
• India
27 Aug 11
This is exactly the reason why many people choose someone from their own community to fall in love with....Otherwise, if they feel they are falling for someone with a different religion, they just restrict themselves right in the beginning..... Sorry that's not very helpful....but people get so lost in love, they forget to be practical! Best is for both of them to move on, and find someone from their own communities..
@viju0410 (2286)
• India
27 Aug 11
Its hurting to know there was not a happy ending. Couples do have difference of opinion which is common but we have to leave the type of prayer to their individual wishes. They should be allowed to pray as per their choice. I have seen many couples who were different religions go well together but have always noticed that both the persons give enough space and freedom to each other. May be a little more time together perhaps would have changed things.