Atheist having problems with Christian friends

Morristown, New Jersey
September 18, 2011 8:53am CST
I am an atheist, but I used to be a Christian. I used to believe in the bible and go to church. I won't get into the reasons why I changed my beliefs, because they were many, but the thing is, a lot of my friends I met while in church. My church friends are having a really hard time accepting that I don't believe anymore. several of them have stopped being my friend – just stopped calling talking etc. Others are still my friend, but they hassle me about it. They're constantly talking about Jesus, more so than when I was a believer and we both believed. They keep saying things like "I wish you'd find God" and "Jesus loves you so much, why don't you love him?" there were also convinced that I was never a real Christian to begin with. That I was faking all those years. Well the truth is, I know my own mind and heart and I know I was sincere. But they're born-again Christians and their beliefs are that if someone leaves Christianity, and they were never real Christian. So they don't respect my feelings. When I asked him questions about their faith that they can answer, or tell them things that are against their religion, they get really upset. They don't want to hear it. So why then do they keep hassling me? It's like they want to talk about Jesus, but only on their own terms. They can say whatever they want but I can't reply. Then they get offended. It's really becoming a problem, and I'm wondering if I can even keep these friendships. I know they think I'm going to hell. I just don't know how to deal with them.
1 person likes this
14 responses
• Canada
23 Sep 11
opalina143, you've presented a problem but there's a lot of missing, and probably important, information: why did you become an atheist? What type of Christians were you (you say "born again" but perhaps you can be more specific)? This is a relationship problem and has at least two sides: you, your Christian friends (who may not all see things the same way), maybe other people. If we asked these other people, they may well say things that will give us a very different view of the situation ("I always knew Opalina wasn't a Christian because ..." "Opalina keeps talking about evolution when we're with her." "I think Opalina became an atheist because she got romantically involved with ..."). Your reluctance to say why you became an atheist and your claim that you have trouble explaining this to your friends, suggests that you may not be entirely comfortable with this decision. You said that the priest who led you to Christ was caught molesting children, that suggests that he's a Catholic which doesn't really fit your "born again" reference. Maybe these accusations weren't true and there can be a fuzzy line with these things - where does normal affection end and abuse begin? This also suggests that your faith was in this priest rather than in Jesus. You also make vague references to personal experiences but don't go into details. A lot of Christians would say they've had personal experiences that support their beliefs. It's possible that your friends don't believe your claims of personal experiences, particularly if you're unwilling to explain them. You've suggested that a lot of your disillusionment is because of the behavior of Christians. I can sort of relate to this but nobody's perfect except Jesus. It's also possible that you've believed gossip that isn't true or are judging others by standards that are not God's. You should also remember that people's faults are most apparent to those close to them. You may think non-Christians tend to behave better because you know the Christians better. Perhaps you should have found some way to improve the behavior of the Christians around you (could be a difficult job and you have to be careful not to become some sort of untrained amature therapist pressurizing people into questionable decisions). Perhaps you should have found a church that was more to your liking. There are problems with things like the Big Bang and Evolution, thick books have been written about this. Then you can question how the first few chapters of Genesis should be interpreted. Personally I think we need some sort of intelligent design theory, perhaps based on evidence we haven't discovered yet, to reconcile creation and the Big Bang/Evolution. Watch the news in the coming months, I think we will be seeing fulfillment of some Biblical prophecies. I don't think there's an easy way out of this problem. I suggest that you take your ideology back to the drawing board for a major re-think. Then you should be more comfortable that you're beliefs are right and be better able to defend them. Personally I'd rather you go back to being a Christian (or better still become a messianic) but perhaps not the same type.
1 person likes this
@jazzsue58 (2666)
25 Sep 11
I gave you two plusses for even getting that far!
1 person likes this
• Morristown, New Jersey
24 Sep 11
It's not that I"m not comfortable talking about my decision, its just that I didnt' want the discussion to be sidetracked and turned into an atheism vs. Christianity debate when the focus I wanted to be was on the relationships affected and not the actual faith vs. non-faith debate. Also, the guy who was molesting children was not a priest, but a baptist. There are child molesters in protestantism too, apparently. i can see why you would make that mistake though. He admitted it to me, so I know I was not believing rumors. HE made excuses,, saying that he might have been molested himself although he couldn't remember it. I don't know too many of the details other than what he told me. But he told me enough that I have an idea. Nor would I say that my faith was in him and not Jesus. I genuinely believed in Jesus. After the incident with Jason (his name) I remained a Christian for nearly ten years. I still believed, although my faith in other christians was shaken. Leaving was a combination of a lot of factors. For one thing, I felt that Christianity did not make much sense. Here we have a god who is all powerful. Yet he creates humans with a tendency to sin. Then, he decides that if a human is not PERFECT, he will torture them for all eternity in fire. Now, even Hitler did not torture h uman beings forever. WE called Hitler a monster, but he only burned Jews in ovens and tortured them for a little while. WE are to understand that God tortures Jews and all nonbelievers for an eternity? What can a person possibly do that deserves eternal torture? Would you pour gasoline over a homeless man and set him on fire? If not why is it ok for god to do it? Then God sends Jesus (who is sort of his son but not really (What's up with that, anyway) and kills him to save us from himself. Makes no sense at all. Finally, I started to reseach the bible and evolution. I found the evidence for Creationism to be nonexistent (and I read a book on it cover to cover, and looked at many websites) if the bible was wrong on that, what else was it wrong on? Also, I always knew that the bible contradicted itself in a bunch of places, I knew that from reading it. After study, I found that the bible contradicts itself in over 1000 places. Says one thing and then says another. How can something that contradicts itself be true? And yes, there were other reasons that I wont get into simply because my hands are tired from typing, although if you are really interested i will write more about my reasons later. I do talk to my friends about why I don't believe, but I try to not get into fights with them so I mainly just gloss over it. Maybe that is my mistake. I just dont' wnt to be in constant religious battles. Maybe they don't realize why I feel the way I do. I just walk a fine line between coexistence and conflict, and I try to respect their beliefs, even if they don't respect mine.
• Morristown, New Jersey
24 Sep 11
It cut me off, but there ere hundreds more.
1 person likes this
@Amfyre (512)
• Canada
19 Sep 11
Opalina perhaps I am not the right person to answer this, I may affend you and other readers... I am a Christian and a bible student... my views are different than the born again . I believe everyone including you and myself have a right to choose whether we believe in God or not. God himself has given you and myself the "right to choose to believe in him and accept him or not", this is refered to Freedom of Will . Thus if you choose not worship Him...so be it. He wants you to choose freely to believe in him. God doesn't want you to be force to believe in him and pressuring you into belief is thus wrong. God wants you to love him freely... no person on this earth can force another to love. Next and this is a great pet pev of mine... Hell and Hell Fire... there is NO place in the bible that says you will go to "hell". Hell and Hell Fire is a man made tradition- this tradition is meant to keep the masses (people) in conrtol and it comes from orginally early "man made tradtions" to frightened the uneducated into doing the churches will. ***So bottom line *** 1.)You have a right to choose to believe or not believe 2.) There is not such thing as Hell Finally Most people who choose to be an atheist do so because the contradictions of the christian churches and the people with in it. Also from Disappointments in the church and misunderstanding of the bible. Also because they have been terribly hurt by fellow "christians". And other reasons... Remember that these are my opinions and I am not trying to be arguementive. All the best to you Opalina, Take Care Amfyre
• Morristown, New Jersey
19 Sep 11
if it was for the issue of hell, I'd have a much easier time believing in God. I've always struggled with it – even when I was very religious. It just seems so strange, and wrong, that God would torture people and fire for all eternity. Just because they didn't believe in him or didn't love him. Even Hitler didn't torture people forever. He tortured people for short time, and we consider him to be evil. Were supposed to believe that God is loving and good, and all that, yet we're supposed to believe that he also tortures people. It doesn't make sense.but isn't that what it says in the Bible? What do you base your beliefs on – I really want to know. How do you interpret the Bible in a way that says there's no hell? And it's true that a lot of Christians have hurt me – I wrote a little bit about it in the response above you. But I had Christians treat me pretty horribly. I won't get into all the examples. And some questions have been really nice to me – so I know not all Christians are bad. Some are really awful. And it's hard to believe that non-Christians, or often better people to Christians, all go to hell.
• Canada
21 Sep 11
Amfyre, you're a Jehovah's Witness aren't you? You're a not a Christian. You belong to a heretical sect that has it's own distorted version of the Bible. The real Bible does teach that there is a Hell, most clearly in Reve 20:11-15. The 144,000 are NOT the number of places in heaven but the number of virgin men from the 12 tribes of Israel who will opposed the anti-Christ. Charles Taze Russel was full of it! Nobody should be stupid enough to follow his lies!
1 person likes this
@Amfyre (512)
• Canada
20 Sep 11
I wrote the above from what the bible really teaches. The bible doesn't teach hell fire nor does it teach that all go to heaven... the bible teaches that only 144 000 go to heaven who will be co-rulers with Jesus, the rest will be divided into two groups... the righteous and the unrighteous, the righteous will dwell on the earth and the unrighteous will be ripped away. I can give you scriptures for you to read in your own bible to back what I have said up. The remember these are my opinions was about the atheist part :) Everything else is from the bible. you can friend me if you have more personal questions if not, then see you in the posts :)
@cupkitties (7421)
• United States
18 Sep 11
Just ask them kindly not to bring up the religious issue around you. I can relate to them having a hard time with it because I had a friend who after converting from Pagan to Muslim just changed so much in his personality that I didn't even know who he was anymore. Maybe when you were Christian they could talk to you about certain things and now they can't. They'll just have to get used to the new you and realize they can speak with you,, just not about that.
• Morristown, New Jersey
19 Sep 11
that's the thing. We can't talk about some of the things we used to. We used to talk about praying and now if they talk about it I just kind of nod and say yes. I don't really contribute much to the conversation. And if they talk about trying to save /convert other people, I'm left pretty cold by that, and it's pretty uncomfortable. It's a bad situation when we talk about religion and they try to convert me. It's not a safe topic anymore, you know? It used to be we both agreed. Now things are very different. So everyone's having a hard time adjusting. I guess it will take time, and some of my friends will come around at some of them won't. I guess we both have to be very tolerant of each other.
@galileo2008 (1141)
• Philippines
18 Sep 11
I am also a Christian, but I have friends who are athiests, but I don't question their beliefs. I mind my own business and let them do their own doings. I love Jesus, and I believe in Him, but I also think that each person has his own freedom to choose in what to believe in. They have their own beliefs too, and whatever they believe in, I don't judge them. I am a Catholic, and I also attend prayer meetings with my friends from other religions. I respect their religious rights, but when they asked me why I also believe in the Virgin Mary, that was the time when I asked them, why do you question my own belief when I don't even question yours? I think and I honestly believe that each person has his or her own beliefs and everyone should respect each other's values.
• Morristown, New Jersey
19 Sep 11
I agree with you. I wish more of my friends felt that way. I've tried to explain to them that I don't want to talk about it. But it seems like they bring up stuff about Jesus more than ever. Maybe it's just a little bit of my imagination and they always talked about Jesus, but it seems like sometimes that's all they talk about. And they know why I left the faith, but they keep questioning me anyway. They dropped hints that I'm going to hell. It bothers me to think that they actually think I deserve to suffer for all eternity. Just because I don't believe as they do. It's offensive we to believe. But I'm willing to tolerate it in them. I just don't know if there willing to do the same for me.
• Canada
20 Sep 11
galilieo2008, you should be able to defend your faith. If you can't explain something as basic (I assume) as believing in the virgin Mary, then perhaps you should re-think your religion. (All Christians and Muslims should believe in the virgin Mary as a person but the Catholics put more emphasis on her and Muslims believe that Jesus forbid her to talk again as soon as he was born.)
1 person likes this
• United Arab Emirates
19 Sep 11
It doesn't matter what religion you are in even if you don't believe in any. It takes mutual respect and understanding. I have non christian friends and we never talk about our own respective religions. I guess it is just so hard to for your friends to believe that you have become atheist. It would be a good thing to talk let them know that you can be a friend as long as you don't talk about religions.
• Canada
23 Sep 11
If you don't talk about religion around somebody who doesn't agree with your religion, where does this stop? Are you going to end up with a situation where you can't talk about religion anywhere and evangelism is impossible?
1 person likes this
@glowin100 (124)
19 Sep 11
If you were saved before, you are a saved person now. Sometimes Satan blinds us when he wants us to think things against Jesus. What made you turn against God? We turn from him but he does not turn from us. Something must have made you turn away. I am not here to criticize you, I only wonder what the problem must be. In the Bible, God says he will not leave us or forsake us. He is still there. glowin100
• Morristown, New Jersey
19 Sep 11
I'm not against God. If there is a God, I'm not against him. I just don't think that he exists anymore. I think if God existed, a lot of things would be different – in the Christian church, in other churches, and in the world. I think the evidence isn't there to support Christianity and the Bible. all the evidence is against it, like evolution. It's hard for me to believe in it. first because of the facts, then because of life in general.Especially with the things I've witnessed, observed, and experienced. so I don't really consider myself an enemy of anything spiritual, I just think it's a fantasy. It used to be so very important to me, it's strange to have changed so much. I think I'm a decent person – I don't think I deserve to be punished for not believing in God or being uncertain about God. Why would a good God want to punish me for all eternity, burning me a fire, because I'm not sure he exists? I would think that if there was a God, he would be a good God, not someone who likes to torture people. I never understood that about Christianity – about hell. Why would God torture people for all eternity – Hitler didn't even do that. And yet were supposed to believe that God loved us so much he would die on the cross for us. But then if we don't love him back, he tortures us. See how it does make sense? I believed that blindly but it never really made sense to me. Finally just got to be too much – that in seeing how most Christians really behave in real life. Probably what started the whole thing was when the church leader who led me to Jesus in the first place ended up being caught molesting children in his church. That really shook my faith, but that was only the beginning. it seemed like there were so many questions and that were bad people that were Christians and so many non-Christians that were good people. So why should all the non-Christians, who were good people, go to hell in all the Christians, were bad people, go to heaven? I know not all Christians are bad – I'm just talking about the ones that are. There are some bad Christians and some good non-Christians. So why should the bad people go to heaven and the people go to hell. Why should it just be based on what you believe and what you do doesn't matter?It didn't seem fair, it didn't seem right, and it didn't seem to make sense. Plus the fact that there's so much evidence against Christianity and the Bible contradicts itself so many places. It just became impossible for me to believe. It took years for me to drift away from my faith. And it was for a lot of reasons, not just one. so anyway, I try to explain this to my friends, but they just get upset. It's better not to talk about it with them at all. So I wish they'd stop bringing it up. I can understand the way they feel – the irony is I would've felt the same way. That's why it's so ironic. I even did have people I knew who left the faith, and I prayed for them and fasted for them I was afraid they were going to hell. So I went through exactly what my friends are going through now, and I hated it. So I can look back on it, and I can relate to what they're feeling. And I'm sorry. I really am sorry. Sometimes I think I should just lie to my friends and tell them I'm a Christian again. But I don't think I can maintain a kind of a lie.
• Canada
21 Sep 11
opalina143, you do know that the Bible says that all people are sinners except Jesus? Nobody else is perfect. I'm not sure you're using God's criteria for 'good' and 'bad' people, this isn't really a Christian concept anyway. Maybe some people you don't know well and would have a very different opinion if you knew them better. It's only those who reject the gospel who definitely go to Hell, it's not clear what happens to those who never hear the gospel. Only that's you certainly bound for Hell but you should have known better. You seem to be referring to a lot of "evidence" against Christianity without going into the details, which isn't really fair as it's hard to answer vague accusations. Perhaps this isn't really the place to discuss such things as it can get complicated (for example there are some technical problems with evolution or you can argue that the first few chapters of Genesis aren't literal but that opens the door to saying that none of the Bible is literal and that gets you into a mess). Then again, I don't think you'd like it if I said that there was evidence against atheism and didn't go into details, and there's a lot of evidence against atheism!
1 person likes this
@chaijudin (506)
• Indonesia
19 Sep 11
hmm May Jesus Change your heart As a Human we have no power to change somebody God also give us a freedom to choose Atheis is human act to pretend that there is no God God work in so many way , not just miracle like Jesus Did, like simple example : we can sleep and wake up again in the next morning , that,s miracle if we think deeply: we need air(oxygen to breath ), we need soul to still alive , so who did all that thing if not God? , if there is no God can we re-create our ancestor? God create Human as the highest creation of all kind so we can,t train any kind of animal to be same like us doctor can cure our sickness but they can,t give us extra live , only God can and About your friend I think They misunderstand , they have to be more passion not to force someone who not trust Jesus as a God , God Choose Us , we can,t force God I have friend who is the high priest of satanic bible , 6666 , also tantra magick , and any kind of magick ritual , and also Moslem , and Buddhis , but it,s ok, they force me too, to do ritual and scary thing , i reject them if they ask me to join the ritual , but everyday if for "normal" speak they are fine I Just Pray May God change they(you too) heart , if not so they choose it / God will ,we didn,t know , God will is different from Human will thanx and take care .
• Philippines
18 Sep 11
this is so sad to hear.... the reason why you suddenly changed your beliefs are really up to you. but i think the best way for you is to at least explain to your friends why. dont convince them to change sides just inform them the reason why. anyway as a Christian i know that you are aware that your friend are only trying to help you go back to God, so you must also widen your understanding. whatever my happen im pretty sure they are all praying for you :)
@jazzsue58 (2666)
25 Sep 11
My own belief is - God dwells not in stone houses, but in the temple of the soul. How many terrible child abuse cases have been down to "religious maniacs?" How many children of "god fearing" parents are being abused right now? I bet you have a purer spirit than any of your church-going "friends." I'm not a regular church goer, I'm just someone who gets torn up inside if I see someone in trouble. Like a young girl who was beaten up by some b!tch in the street the other day. I just HAD to help her, even though she didn't really appreciate it at the time (she was in tears and just wanted to get home - wouldn't let me call the police cos she'd only suffer worse at school.) How many of those pious bigots who go to church find it an easy way to atone for the fact it makes it soooo much easier to switch off from the outside world afterwards? Most of them, I bet.
@stary1 (6612)
• United States
18 Sep 11
Wow this really is so sad. I fault some of your friends for not standing by you and and accepting your decision. I do understand some think they are trying to help you ... I am a Christian and yet I often cringe when I see some Christians trying soooo hard they don't realize they are pushing their religion and turning people off rather than helping them. This might be the time to find out who your true friends are. Explain how they make you feel and if they can't accept you then perhaps you need to find new friends..I would not limit your selection of new friends and avoid Christians because some are loving and accepting. Best wishes
@varier (5685)
• Indonesia
18 Sep 11
I am not seeing this as a religion problem.. I am seeing it as general friendship problem.. In my opinion, in most cases, you are be friend with people because you all have the same interest.. Once you changed that interest, then your friend would get upset.. Let me give some example. Say, you are be friend with people that collecting cards - while you are also collecting cards like them. Then, one day, you are stopping collect cards and find new hobby. Then, if that happened, I believe your friendship with them wouldn't be same as before... Another example: you are an atheist and you are be friend with another atheists. One day, you change and you start to believe a religion again. Then, I believe several of your friends would call you stupid and your friendship with them wouldn't be same as before.. The big problem here is about tolerance. Only a few people are being able to fully implement that.. I just can hope that your "old" friends can respect your choice and give much tolerance. Or if that's really hard to happen, I hope you can find your new friends soon. Best wishes.
@Triple0 (1904)
• Australia
19 Sep 11
Wow... your friends are very firm in their Christian faith. There are Christians who are very fundamental about their religion and reject other beliefs systems that contradicts their belief system. I'm Christian, and I know God wants everyone to embrace everyone's unique religions. I have heaps of atheist friends and I respect in what they believe in. Sometimes they complain about going to mass because it's so boring when we have to go to mass because of our school and I just make a joke out of it. I don't get offended and I like listening to other people's opinions. Your friends aren't very open minded, they need to open up a bit and accept things that doesn't go their way. If you can't change them and they're causing you more grief, I reckon it's best that you don't hang with them anymore.
@labli09 (70)
• Philippines
19 Sep 11
i am a catholic here and i respect the beliefs of those people who belongs to other religion. i think your friends can understand you soon, just be patient on explaining them.if they're really your friends, they will understand you and respect your present religion.
19 Sep 11
O.. I see.. you are angry.. it is not good for you! I have many friends and college that are atheist in spite of my believe in God. You know I have not problem with friendships with them. Why? Maybe because that I am not push on them, do not tell them every time about God, I am crazy women...They see how I live, that they could trust me and I am the person that could ask the help and get it. I will do what I can..But many of them without my pushing on them now believe in God, but still think about themselves that they are atheist :)) I respect them, as they are!! They saw many miracles in my life and now it happen in their life too.. :)) Try to explain them, that you do not like that they phsilogicaly push on you and everyone have their own way of life! Your real christian friends must understand it and let you go by your way, have your own opinion! Do not be angry and agressive on them! If you find peace inside you and you fill yourself it means that you find God inside you, because God is inside everyone! But for you I can say, that maybe you can try to understand them what they fill inside, why they want that you find God and etc.. It would be easy for you to communicate with them! And you are right.. that some time the Christian in real life they are not Christian ;/// But you can be as you are! I hope that a little bit help you. If you have any questions I would be glade to unswer for its! Have good time!