An Accident of Birth

Australia
October 7, 2011 11:44pm CST
I've been involved in a couple of discussions that touch on life chances, and I find it saddening that so few of the respondents have any sense of compassion for the unfortunate, nor any sense that they themselves are lucky. This reminded me of a song a friend of mine wrote, and I'll give you the last verse of that, because it fits me and most other Wetserners as well. It happens I was born in a land of plenty, I happen to be male and I happen to be white. It happens that my bowl has never been empty, It happens that I've never been forced to fight. In everyone's life there is some power, A chance to choose which road to take. But at birth we don't choose the place, the hour, We all must hold the hand of fate. Just an accident, it's just an accident, Just an accident of birth. How is it that so few "lucky" Westerners can understand such a simple concept? Lash
1 person likes this
6 responses
@varier (5685)
• Indonesia
8 Oct 11
Really a great words :) No one can ever chose the place and the time he born. I see that message as a reminder for us, that we shouldn't be much proud with our background. It's just an accident. It's not something that we can be proud of.. At this time, only our great attitude and our contribution to world that we should think about.. And it is not about our background.. Nice share. :)
1 person likes this
• China
8 Oct 11
I have to say ur words are really emotional and sounds reasonable. We can never choose our place and time to be born, and whose family we will be born. But I think that's the true beauty of life, you don't have to worried about ur life and destiny because they r unpredictable, u just have to face it and sove it.
1 person likes this
@sharra1 (6340)
• Australia
8 Oct 11
We are very lucky in that respect but unfortunately it is our very luck that seems to make us feel superior to all those born to less fortunate backgrounds. It is so sad that so many lucky people fail to pity those not so lucky. There are so many children dying of starvation these days and it should not happen. If the lucky ones shared their luck instead of hoarding it and greedily grabbing for more then maybe there would not be so many suffering in the world.
• Australia
15 Oct 11
At last, someone who gets my point. Lash
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
14 Oct 11
It is a shame when people don't realize how good they have it. My life has not been an easy road but I remember my grandfather always saying..just remember Jenny...there is always someone out there with it tougher than you...imagine if you were in their shoes for a moment before you complain about where you are at. It is hard for people to see both sides of the fence sometimes when they have never really had to deal with it. A perception can be a narrow thing sometimes.
• Australia
15 Oct 11
It's something of a NewAge sewage truism, but the concept of walking a mile in another's shoes could have been designed to fit with my point here, and you are only the second response to pick that up. Lash
• China
11 Oct 11
I strongly agree with you.All lifes are born by accident.And I stick to this simple truth.
• Canada
8 Oct 11
Many of us are born lucky, just as many of us are born unlucky. This I understand, and accept. We should acknowledge that what we consider our superiority is nothing more than the result of our good fortune. What this means, I guess, is that we need some humility. This is also accepted. Our attitude towards the less fortunate should be more compassionate, with a will and a desire to help. This is acceptable, in theory. I say in theory because it is almost impossible to put it into practice. How do you do it? Where do you even begin? Do you simply donate, and hope it gets to the right people? Do you reach out personally to individuals? This one-to-one aid can be pretty risky. It may be taken in a condescending manner. There is the in-born resentment of the down-trodden towards the fortunate. The whole business is fraught with peril. Where does that leave us? Do we simply acknowledge all this and continue with our lives? I say all this because it seems that we must somehow feel guilty of our good fortune. And there is also the fact that what appears as good fortune on the outside isn't all that great on the inside. What we have is material plenty. But some of us are probably more unfortunate in our personal lives than many of the less well off that we consider less fortunate. I've done nothing but raise difficulties, without offering any solutions. This is for the simple reason that I really see no solution, except to let things unfold they way are meant to. I trust in fate more than I trust my own judgement.
• Australia
8 Oct 11
Very well put, and yes, you do point out the difficulties so well. There is no simple answer, and the complicated answers are extremely complicated. My solution would be very long term, and revolve around trying to change the whole system, a clearly impossible task in the face of so much vested interest. But truly, I believe that homelssness and poverty are always a result of failures in the social system, and even though it is fated to fail, I still keep trying to make those changes. Lash
• Indonesia
12 Oct 11
I agree that fortunes and power must come together with humility, and that is what I call wisdom, mankind's virtue.