Does love really bring happiness? Or one should go for an arranged marriage?

India
January 31, 2012 11:57am CST
I have been a very strong person through out my life. I have usually been against the trend which asks women to compromise on all stages of life. When I fell in love, I felt on the top of the world. This feeling lasted for a long time of 4 years. But all this changed when I first met my boy friend's parents. They were very conservative. At the first meeting itself they started telling me to change my caste(me and my boyfriend belong to the same religion, but to different castes). They wanted me to learn their language, quit my job, give them grand children immediately after marriage, and do the household works. I was shocked by their demands. When I discussed this with my boyfriend, he said that all this is wrong, but refused to talk to his parents about that. He says that I should initially adjust with his parents and slowly things will change. Honestly, I do not think that there is going to be any change in his parents attitude. Me and my boyfriend have started to get into a lot of arguments these days. We are still together, but we are not happy. I now wonder if considering an arranged marriage would have been a better choice instead of falling in love. What do you think? Does love really bring happiness? A few issues in love life are fine as nothing is perfect, but I am getting into a state of depression these days. What should I do?
1 person likes this
5 responses
• United States
31 Jan 12
People supposedly marry for love and look how many end up divorced and hating each other. The ones who would go into an arranged type marriage probaly are stronger cause they are committed more.Usually there committment is more about family and supporting there family unit. The Love people seem to want to commit til either I dont love him/her anymore or we are not having fun anymore. Im not saying all of course but the divorce rate tells you im right about some of them. I know alot of people dont think there is to many arranged marriages in the USA and there not in one sense but we all know someone who was in love with person a but didnt pursue a life with them because of religious beliefs etc. So in a sense it is arranged cause you are giving up someone you are in love with because they dont fit criteria you need and clearly then love isnt winning out. Now all that being said if you are unhappy with him either sit down and have a talk and get on the same page and be happy or leave. If he isnt forcing his parents beliefs on you in the sense there his too then stop argueing. You dont need his parents approval and more likely than not you may not ever find with anyone. As long as he is loving and supportive of you and you are on the same page then when his parents say something simply say this is our lives not yours and while I love to visit with you I am not gonna you tell me how to live my life. If they get upset so be it and if he does for you speaking your mind then you know its time to go..
1 Feb 12
this situation is really normal in every country .i guess you are indian.When the same situation in China,most people will follow the family ,for the marrige is not only related to two loved,but also involed in two family.as for your situation,I suggest that you can talk with your boy friend's family ,if its fail,you can thinking about giving up.life is short ,and maybe you can meet another man that love you .and no one is living for others.why not make ourselves unhappy? ~~
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
31 Jan 12
If you are not happy with your relationship, why keep with it. Marriage is a lifetime commitment- and should not be taken for granted. If you boyfriend cannot defend you and your feelings- think twice.
• India
2 Feb 12
Yes, thats exactly what I am doing..thinking twice. Thanks Jaiho
• United States
31 Jan 12
I dont think arranged marriages are great at all and they dont really exist in the united states and if they do i have never heard of one before. I think you should fall in love with whom you like and hopefully everything else turns out good as well. I think you should be happy and if you arent you should talk to him about it and have him help you with what needs to bring you happiness in your relationship and you both should work it out together and live your life as a happy couple. If your getting depressed and not happy all you can do is talk to someone about it and usually you should talk to your boyfriend about it so he knows and have him help you out with it.
@anncherry (406)
• Philippines
1 Feb 12
Love has a two-fold effect: it can make you feel good, it can make you feel bad. But even though there's a feeling-bad aspect to it, I would still be on love's side till the end. :) You see, having an arranged marriage is just emptiness, while what you are experiencing right now, if not good, well, it IS something. It gives you the reason to strive for what you believe in everyday. As for me, you don't have to conform to his parent's beliefs. It's their son you are going to marry after all, not them. As long as what you believe in is okay for your soon-to-be husband, all you have to do is compromise and agree to a certain degree so that things will be alright. You had been happy for four years without the interference of his parents right? Then why not live your lives a little away from them? Sometimes, the customs of the previous generation clashes with the new generation, and I think that's what's happening to you. It's not that their beliefs or your beliefs are wrong, it's just that you have to respect each others opinion. When all of your troubles had been settled and you're already happily living your life with your new baby, believe me, love really brings happiness. :)
@WakeUpKitty (8694)
• Netherlands
31 Jan 12
What is arranged? Someone else is looking for a partner for you or you use your common sense and your list of likes and dislikes (exactly the way parents would do it)? You only need to read all the discussions over here, open your eyes, observe people, watch tv to realize that love doesn't make happy. Love does not survive everything. If love is over people leave each other.
• India
2 Feb 12
Thanks, I guess you are right. And yes, arranged means that elders in the family find a life partner for you. This is a common practice in our country.