controversial topic: Is twilight a good book?

India
March 30, 2012 3:51pm CST
I really dont understand why many people hate it Is the book bad? I havent read it,just asking what's the big fuss over this small book/movie why so many haters
3 responses
@kolsti87 (521)
• United States
1 Apr 12
I think the storyline is a bit cliched and everything, but a lot of stories have cliched plots. The only reason I don't really like it all that much is the fact that it is pretty poorly written. Like the word choice, the descriptions, the sentences, they're all just pretty bad. Like, there were kids in my middle school who could write better than that! But, it appealed to teenage girls and made tons of money, so I guess it must be good for them.
• India
24 Jul 12
ok, i have heard tons of comment on her writing alone :). But, what i don't get is, if she has such a poor writing then why was her last book 'The host' is mentioned as one of the good apocalyptic books (inatleast 3 sites).
• India
24 Jul 12
Thanks for commenting, I actually thought that was a taboo word here
@lady1993 (27225)
• Philippines
15 Jul 12
Not really. I read the first book and i found it a bit boring, the writing is nothing great, but it was bearable.. I just found out that there wasn't much exciting stuff, i didn't even bother reading the next books.
• India
24 Jul 12
Thanks for commenting
@tonyllenium (6252)
• Italy
30 Mar 12
i don't know why people hate the books but in reality the twilight saga is not good in my opinion too so may be there are many oter books or stories on similar topics but sounds much more interesting than twilight so may be for that people fee bored about twilight books or saga in general..
• India
31 Mar 12
I still don't understand why they hate it soo much I came across many whom said that they are cra* thanks for your opinion tony