The Froggate : should we help these migrant frogs to stay in their adopted pond ?

Tweet

A frog is a wild animal, noisy during the love period in May and June, but what can we do against love ? Grignols is a charming old village in a beautiful area of France, Périgord, more famous until now for its painted prehistoric caves and its truffles than for its frogs, but it might change. The Pécheras, a couple living in Grignols, have a pond, and the pond is inhabited by a few frogs. The Pécheras are swearing that they did not brought the frogs in the pond, and that they are about 30. Their neighbors are telling that they are hundreds and that they were not in the pond in the past. Scientists and experts are working on these important points. The neighbors of the Pécheras are a bit litigious : they went to court for a dividing fence, and for a few bamboos that were masking the sun to them, and lost their trials. Then came these noisy migrant frogs, early in this century. They found the noise of the frogs unacceptable. They sent a bailiff at night during the love season of the frogs at the limit of their property, and this man of justice, equipped with a sonometer duly checked by weights and measures officers, found 63 decibels, approximately the noise of a washing machine. It was more than their ears could support, and they sued again the Pécheras, to shut up the frogs in their pond. The civil court in Périgueux decided that a frog was not a domestic animal and that the Pécheras could not be held responsible for the calls of love of the frogs. Outraged by this judgment, the neighbors decided to appeal, and they paid a good lawyer to cope with the situation. The pond is old and in the land register since more than a century, but the Pécheras have enlarged it, and they should better have not : actually a pond has to be at 50 m of another property, this one was only at 4 m after the enlargement, like a document established by a certified surveyor proves it. Eureka ! The lawyer asked to the court to close this illegal pond full of migrant frogs ! The Bordeaux Court of Appeal followed him and has convicted the Pécheras at the beginning of this month to fill immediately their pond, fixed a penalty of 150 Euros by day of delay, and ordered them to pay for the procedure and the expenses associated made by their neighbors : it is a 9000 Euros bill. You should have perhaps guessed it, but all frogs are protected animals in France. The Pécheras sent a SOS to an environmental protection association to save their pond and its inhabitants, and they have decided to lodge an appeal to the Court of Cassation. Besides, an online petition has been launched to save the pond and permit to these migrant frogs to continue to shout their calls of love. It has already received more than 80 000 signatures, and they expect 150 000 signatures to send it to the courts and to the French minister of Environment. I give you the link. The main point of this petition is : "Say No to a framed aseptization of Nature." My opinion is divided here : if we were not maintaining the nature in our gardens we would soon live in a jungle (I have just ended to clean my garden, and it was a jungle), but on another hand, we have also to respect wild animals when we can(I kept a tree only because a couple of turtle doves are nesting in it). What do you think about this "Froggate" ? Is it only a funny quarrel between neighbors ? What are the values to defend here : the wild calls of love of the frogs or the sleep of their human neighbors ? Something else ?