Is "guy" a disrespectful word?

United States
March 28, 2017 2:53pm CST
Is using the term guy the same as calling grown up female, a girl? It is not in my opinion but I also do not know the origin of the word guy. I just think that calling an adult woman a girl is exactly the same as calling a grown man a boy.
3 people like this
3 responses
@OneOfMany (12150)
• United States
28 Mar 17
Sometimes I face this issue in writing. I might be talking about a woman, but she's referred to as a girl often. It's a form of address that we're all familiar with though. Just remember that females mature faster than males, so while a boy is pretty much a boy until he's 18 (and sometimes through college) a girl might be a woman at as early as 12 in terms of physical maturity. My mother said she was pretty much fully grown at 15, and certainly looked older than a lot of those around her. So at what point does one transition into a woman? Also, a 'college girl' might be offended if you call them a 'college woman' which implies they look old. I think in this sense 'girl' is a youthful expression while 'woman' signifies age. It could fall in line with maturity in a different sense as well. An escort would be considered a 'working girl' and an office worker might be called a 'working woman'. In this case the implication is in terms of respect of position. Many other parallels could be made, but it's one of those weird connotations.
2 people like this
@OneOfMany (12150)
• United States
28 Mar 17
@stacysdeadright A father will call his son 'boy' sometimes as a form of age hierarchy, even if the son is a full grown man. I think 'guy' became the neutral cross term for boy/man because it wasn't negative in any aspect. Just remember, that in terms of relationships the terms are established as girlfriend/boyfriend. Whereas through marriage you'll get the man & wife titles, where the unions signifies their placement in society as a man and a woman. You'd be hard pressed to find an older movie where a wife was referred to as a 'girl'. In that case girl could be a singularity as well (the exception being 'girl's night out'). There are too many inconsistencies to let it get to you. Your profile picture screams 'girl' to me, rather than woman. Sorry. :)
• United States
28 Mar 17
You make some valid points. If that is the case then maybe we shouldn't get so offended for the simple fact that we allow it in certain settings. It really depends on who is the one using the term. Just like if I say "boys" in a sentence, most men wouldn't take offense, Although I have been told by some of my male friends of a different culture that calling them " boy " is extremely disrespectful. I think it can be innocent. Men may grow up using these words towards women because of they themselves do not take age to heart. I've heard plenty of middle aged men use terms like " Me and the boys are going out for a drink" and I guess that is why I don't think that men take it as so bad a way to address them with.
1 person likes this
@MALUSE (69409)
• Germany
28 Mar 17
I've written a post on how to address each other on myLot. Many members have commented positively on it. This means it expresses not only my thoughts. Maybe you find it of interest.
INTRODUCTION Mylot is an international site spanning the globe. What we learn from reading discussions is that basically people are people. They're born, live...
• United States
28 Mar 17
Thank you but this post is not about Mylot. It is about tension between genders in everyday life. Most women would like not to be referred to as just a "girl" when they are of a certain age and most men think that we are making too big of a fuss about it. Again, this might just be an "American " issue. Here females call men "guys" and do not believe that it is as derogatory as calling a fully grown woman a "girl". I understand your post, but in the right context this is not suggesting that one Mylotter disrespect another Mylotter. Sometimes someone can properly address someone but they are very antagonistic and it can still be seen as a form of disrespect.
1 person likes this
@MALUSE (69409)
• Germany
28 Mar 17
@stacysdeadright I think this is indeed an American issue. We don't have comparable terms in German. So it's difficult for me to feel what's inappropriate with 'guy' and 'girl'.
2 people like this
• United States
28 Mar 17
@MALUSE I see. We have way too many in the states. It is so bad that words like "bling bling" which is slang for expensive diamond encrusted jewelry is being inducted into American dictionaries.
1 person likes this
@Fleura (29218)
• United Kingdom
29 Mar 17
No, I can't see what's disrespectful about it. It's a casual, informal word but not a disrespectful one. It can be used for both men and women or mixed groups, for example a person might enter a room full of friends and call out 'Hi guys!' meaning everyone. Or say something like 'Come on guys, let's go out!'