Who is a better vocalist?(Gnr,Metallica,PinkFloyd)

i m gr8 fan of pink floyd. so it is gilmour and roger water for me. u also seem to be fan of floyd. isnt it/

I'd have to go with David Gilmour, not only do I think he has a great voice, but love how he plays, too. After watching the Pulse DVD, I've gained a new respect for the guy. Next would be Hetfield, followed by Rose who, to me, sounds like a drowning cat, not to mention he seems like an A-class jerk with how he treats his fans. But no matter lol.

Axles voice is gone.I love Metallica and Floyd GNR were great for their time but I think they are done.Slash is great though.

Axl's voice is great I think he is the better vocalist.

David gilmour...... what a voice.....makes u wanna float away...... bloody soothing.....