Shakespeare....to read or not to read?

United States
January 16, 2007 12:02am CST
In school we all learned about William Shakespeare, his poems, his plays, and his life. Many people like him and many do not. There is the "controversy" over the authenticity of his work, and there are those, that say he did not even have the right to make up all the words that he did in the English language. In general, I liked his work in school, even though there were poems (sonnets) and plays, that I like more than his, I can appreciate his work. My sister-in-law, sent me a collection of his best plays, and I have begun reading them. There are some that I had never read, and find very interesting. Once I read them all, I will pick my favorites...and if I get a chance, I will get his poems and then pick a favorite also. Even though what we were required to read in school and college (supposedly) his best work, we all have our own favorites. How do you feel about Shakespeare?
8 people like this
35 responses
• United States
16 Jan 07
I heard he did not like muslims, which makes him seem racist. I have only read a few of his poems, and I liked them. I think there are a lot of rumors about him, but how can we know what to believe. I think we should just judge his work and not him as a person because we know more about his work.
• United States
16 Jan 07
Yes, that is true. We should criticize his work for its value and what it has done for the rest of the world. Just as Da Vinci, and all other people that have made an impression on history. There are always people that don't like others, but their work is something to be appreciated. That is really what you get from someone who is an "artist," there is always some kind of eccentricity that we have to get past.
16 Jan 07
I think something that most people forget is that Shakespeare's plays were not written to be read, they were written to be seen when performed on the stage. As a lot of people I didn't think a lot of his work when I had to study it at school, having to dissect each bit to find the 'hidden meaning', and that always destroys a piece of work for me, but I felt totally differently the first time I actually SAW Hamlet performed, it really brought it to life and made me have a different take on him completely.
2 people like this
• United States
17 Jan 07
Yes, watching the plays, or even participating in them, is a very fun experience. And, the funny thing is that the plays were all performed by men, back then. So, that probably made them even more interesting.
@scorpius (1792)
• India
16 Jan 07
shakes peare either was a ake or was one of the greatest writers that this world has ever seen.i really love his works and once on a while i go on a shakespeare binge.anyway in high school i had acted in a couple of his lays as well.they were the merchant of venice and macbeth. loved acting in them both and i was in the lead role in both of them,portia and macbeth respectively.it was really fun acting it al out!
1 person likes this
@nana1944 (1365)
• United States
16 Jan 07
I enjoy Shakespeare. I know he had a lot of hidden meanings in his literary works but I always liked trying to figure the meanings out. How do people think the languages got started if not by the words being made up? Thank you for this topic. I have enjoyed readinf the different views on here. That is what myLot is all about.
• United States
16 Jan 07
Thank you for such a nice response, I am grateful to my sister-in-law for sending me the collection of his best works. And, I remember in my poetry class in college, my English professor had started the Shakespeare Academy, so he loved to discuss everything about Shakespeare. And he used to say that we would not have such a broad dictionary, without Shakespeare.
@cuddleme01 (2725)
• Philippines
16 Jan 07
There is nothing wrong in reading shakespeare's works. He is a known authority in his field. while we may not always find interests in all his works, we know we always get to learn something from him. reading stimulates our brain and if you are having some problems understanding some of his works due to figurative speech or whatever they call it, at least you are stretching the capability of your brain trying to get his point.
@sigma77 (5383)
• United States
16 Jan 07
I remember reading the old boy in college. A lot of his works were difficult to understand and some were extremely profound. I would like to go back and read a few of his works over again. I don't care if he made up new words. I wish I could make up a few new ones to describe how I feel sometimes. Who is alive today that can compare to him? I don't know.
• United States
17 Jan 07
Yes, that is true. It will be a while before we figure out who is the Shakespeare of modern times, and then all the younger generations will be learning about that artist. And have to dissect his/her work for hidden meanings also. It is different when we read Shakespeare's work for our own pleasure and not in school/college, because it is enjoyable.
• United States
16 Jan 07
I like Shakespeare, although I don't always like trying to read his works in their original old English. Mostly because we don't talk that way anymore so it doesn't mean much to me. But I have read some using more modern language but still keeping his sentence structures. If you have seen the movie "Much Ado About Nothing" with Keanu Reeves and Kenneth Brannagh that is based on the modernized version of his play. I know because I checked it out of the library and the movie was word from word from that version. It is probably my favorite of his plays. I have also read Romeo and Juliet (what high school student hasn't), Julius Caesar, A Mid Summer's Night Dream, Twelfth Night, King Lear, and a couple others. Some of my favorite movies are based on Shakespeare's plays. "10 Things I Hate About You" was based on Taming of the Shrew. "She's the Man" the movie with Amanda Bynes pretending to be a guy is based on "Twelfth Night". I was watching that one with my dad over Christmas and knew it was based on a Shakespeare play I had read but could not remember the name of it. It was obviously Shakespeare, though.
• United States
7 Feb 07
I agree with you, that is what I had recommended to people who don't like the Old Enlgish, that they can just read modern versions. Really, only the poems need to be read in their original version. And, the movies that come out now, that portray his written work, are so much fun. There is so much to learn and enjoy from his work.
@emisle (3822)
• Ireland
17 Jan 07
I had to read Hamlet and The Merchant Of Venice in school and they weren't the fondest of times! I appreciate his intelligence as far as the writing goes because he really was a genius, but my god we wanted them to be over! But I suppose outside a study environment they would be a lot more enjoyable.
• United States
7 Feb 07
Yes, they tend to be. When we are in school, we lose the enjoyment, becuase we are on a deadline...
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
16 Jan 07
Shakespeare, a name that either provokes images of splendid writing or nightmares of tests and memorizations. He can be enjoyable to read and to view his plays are incredible. Do I think he is the greatest writer in the English language, no I do not. He was good but one needs to remember many of his plays were reworking of old stories or they were historically based plays (not always accurate of the history). Yes he told great stories but he wasn't unique. There were others in that time period that wrote the same way and are seldom heard of. He was just more prolific then others. Do I think students in high schools should have to read his works? If they are studying English Literature yes he is one I would recommend to be read, at least one of his works. However there are many other playwrights and authors we should be exploring. We are now in the 21st century and students have a hard time being able to comprehend the older English used let alone able to connect with the characters in the stories. I'd rather see them use more modern works, get them to enjoy reading first and worry about "classics" for later. If they enjoy reading they will read more and that is more important.
• United States
7 Feb 07
That is an interesting point of view. I don't believe that he should be excluded from highschool education, because then, people would miss out on a lot of stories, that are so interesting. Yes, there are others that wrote the same, or even better work, but sometimes, there are factors involved that cause one writer to be more widespread than another. I tend to gravitate towards masterpieces, personality-wise, but there are some works, that stay with me, even though they are by people who are not so famous/infamous...I studied abroad for so many years, and I have learned, that in America, we tend to baby students, and they graduate from highschool with a degree of education that is far beneath that of what you would expect from a nation that prides itself on being so "smart." In general, there needs to be a lot more work done, to encourage students to enjoy reading (and everything else in school), and to succeed. Shakespeare is not the main problem, although many of us look back at our younger years, and blame him for the sad state of our grades, in English Lit, there is always going to be a class that we could have gone without (or a teacher). Thank you for your response, because it led to a bigger issue that really gets to me, everytime I think of the state of our educational system.
@shywolf (4514)
• United States
17 Jan 07
I love Shakespeare! ^_^ I really wasn't made to read any of his works in school, I just got interested in some of his plays on my own and read a few of them. MOstly I have watched either television adaptations, some of the movies like Kenneth Branagh's versions of Hamlet, Much Ado, etc, and/or gone to see Shakespeare plays live. We have something called the Heart of America Shakespeare Festival here in Missouri every summer. They do one or two plays each summer outdoors for free, and I used to go every year. I even had several t-shirts from the festival, but they're all too worn out now to wear in the public *laugh* ^_^ I think that Love's Labours Lost and Much Ado About Nothing are my two favorite plays so far. I haven't seen nearly all of them, though! ^_^
• United States
7 Feb 07
I will have to look into what we have for Shakepeare in my area (because I moved), that way there will be a chance for me to enjoy his work live. Thank goodness there are the movies to watch. It is good to read, I love to read, but there are times when I prefer to watch his work.
@Geminigirl (1909)
• United States
16 Jan 07
I was required to read it, discuss it, and write papers on it. I hated it. I know we are supposed to think it is just grand and all, but I thought it was super boring. I am so glad those days are behind me!!
1 person likes this
• United States
16 Jan 07
I feel that regardless of the controversy, Shakespeare (and whomever else it might entail under his name), is one of the most amazing literary minds in the world. The language he uses and descriptions he uses are very beautiful. Also, he is so smart about how he wrote these plays. If you learn the history behind them, you'll realize he's quite genius in being able to criticize the monarchy and other issues that were going on around him, without being able to be persecuted. This, I believe, is why so many in his day loved the works so much. Personally, he is amazing, and one of my favorite authors of all time. My favorites are "Much Ado About Nothing" and "A Midsummer Night's Dream." Though, I also love the sonnets.
• United States
7 Feb 07
I agree with you...there is so much hidden meaning and it is mostly aimed at politicians, and people in power. Some people get sidetracked by the complex wording and lose the real meaning.
@myjewel (268)
• Philippines
16 Jan 07
i think his books are difficult to understand or is it me who just cannot comprehend his writings.
• United States
17 Jan 07
If you have difficulty understanding the "dialect" that he used, then I recommend getting a modern-day text, using everyday words, because then you will understand the meanings that he is trying to portray, in his plays and poems. It will take away some of the excitement and authenticity, but it will at least get the meaning across.
• Philippines
17 Jan 07
shakespeare a must read books. shakespeare possessess a large scale vocabulary having been use 29,066 different words in his work and 884,647 all together.
@UcoksBaBa (800)
• Indonesia
16 Jan 07
I had not studied about shakespear honestly in fact knew the name was obtained by me from movie, according to me just so-so not there is one that is special from they related shakespear's works, what because me this di not have like shakespear and not interested in the work he to me only regarded him the normal matter.
@onesiobhan (1327)
• Canada
17 Jan 07
I feel in love with Shakespeare during my English class. We were reading Romeo and Juliet, and at some point I started to really "get" the language. I went to the library and got out A Midsummer Night's Dream - and that was it. I was hooked.
• United States
17 Jan 07
Reading is always good for you, so I encourage you keep reading things you like, especially those famous books like Shakespeare's. If something is liked, there must be some people who dislike it. It is normal. Some people may take it offensive, but some people not. It all depends all the readers themselves. And America is a free nation, right? We can do things we like.
@Mecboy (1050)
• United States
17 Jan 07
I have to read it in high school. Im fifteen a sophomore and I believe in Willian Shakespeare as an Actor Writer and famous person, thanks For asking the question because people who read about him, might go on Mylot and ask the same thing.
@jeans6618 (168)
• China
17 Jan 07
Shakespeare is well popular in our conuty . i like his play.
• United States
17 Jan 07
In school I never really liked reading Shakespeare but now that I'm older I wished I had actually paid attention in class. I'm really into history now and just wished it was more interesting than the teachers at school make it seem all boring.