sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionsblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLot

Do you have or Have you got - which one is correct email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 75/100. servlet (136)   ranked 2,524 out of 4,471 in writing1 year ago

When I was young enough not to know the English grammar I always used this second form: “Have you got” but now I heard that it is an old form – well not used now. What exactly is it?

 
 
writing
sponsors
Vyvanse™ Official Site
Lisdexamfetamine dimesylate capsule. Get Safety and Prescribing Info.
www.Vyvanse.com

Public Storage Unit Rentals
Pay only $1 for First Month's Rent. No CC Required. Reserve Instantly.
PublicStorage.com

forsakemysoul (423) response was accepted on 8/13/2007.
denotes best response.
tags:  gramma, hpoed i helped, dialogue
 
1. myLot reputation of 83/100. kprabhu (214)   1 year ago

i supposed to think there is nothing in the old form; all are still used by the people;of course i am not perfect in grammar also; but my suggestion is the verb makes the difference between the words you used here!i hope that one answer better than me soon!

"Love endures long and is kind; love is not jealous; love is not out for display" - I.Cor.13:4


myLot reputation of 75/100. servlet (136)   ranked 2,524 out of 4,471 in writing  1 year ago

Thanks 4 that! But I don't really get it: so I think (well this is my education) that there is no difference between this two forms and that is why I ask!

Vyvanse™ Official Site Lisdexamfetamine dimesylate capsule. Get Safety and Prescribing Info. www.Vyvanse.com
 
2. cherokee3 (78)   1 year ago

Well with what the American Literature teachers and English teachers have pounded and drilled into our heads about correct grammar we use "Do you have" hope that helped you


myLot reputation of 75/100. servlet (136)   ranked 2,524 out of 4,471 in writing  1 year ago

OK - many thanks! But what about: "have you got"? - Is it correct?

Public Storage Unit Rentals Pay only $1 for First Month's Rent. No CC Required. Reserve Instantly. PublicStorage.com
 
3. cherokee3 (78)   1 year ago

I think it may be more of slang phrase than anything just like aint and when you going to be home instead of are not and when are you going to be home?!!

 
4. myLot reputation of 95/100. cher913 (7848)   ranked 32 out of 4,471 in writing   1 year ago

do you have sounds so much nice than have you got...i just sounds more right lol! is there a website that you can look up stuf like that? just wondering...that would be a great help to writers!!


myLot reputation of 75/100. servlet (136)   ranked 2,524 out of 4,471 in writing  1 year ago

So this is not the matter of grammar!

 
5. myLot reputation of 98/100. patgalca (5055)   ranked 1 out of 4,471 in writing   1 year ago

If you are writing dialogue, you can write it any way you want because it is the manner in which the speaker is talking. I would think someone more educated and perhaps upper class would say "Do you have" whereas if you had a teenager speaking or a biker dude, they would say "have you got". If you are writing dialogue you want to portray the traits of the character in the way they talk.


myLot reputation of 75/100. servlet (136)   ranked 2,524 out of 4,471 in writing  1 year ago

Many thanks - now it looks much clear now

 
6. myLot reputation of 93/100. charlene2350 (4857)   ranked 537 out of 4,471 in writing   1 year ago

Do you have a pencil? Have you got a pencil? Correct form is Do you have...

In .. Have you got a pencil... you are starting your sentence with a verb and it is awkward. I forgot the term for such a sentence.

 
7. myLot reputation of 23/100. forsakemysoul (423)   ranked 1,102 out of 4,471 in writing   1 year ago

I personally prefer "Do you have". For some reason, the word "got" always sounds completely unkind to me. I don't like the way it sounds and I don't like the way it represents. I've always preferred the words "received" or "was given" or*anything* but "got".

As for which is grammatically correct, I honestly don't know. I always try to avoid the word "got" completely in any type of writing I do because I've never thought it sounded like a very nice word. I, personally, believe it just disrupts the text and the "flow" of the entire passage. But that's just because I'm weird.