sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Is John Lennon a communist  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 82/100. raulgc01 (163)   ranked 16 out of 486 in the beatles 5 years ago

I you would study John Lennon's compositions, Revolution and Imagine, he is encouraging communism to be the world's form of government.

 

the beatles
sponsors
Free The Beatles Music
Listen To Your Favorite The Beatles Songs. Get Downloads& More Free
Music.PureDef.com

Free History Magazine
Get the world's biggest events. Get a free History Channel® Magazine.
Thehistorychannelclub.com

King of Pop's influences
The King of Pop's musical influence James Brown, Stevie Wonder, more
thegrio.com/king-of-pops-music

jend80 (1666) response was accepted on 9/29/2007.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  john lennon, communism, communist, the beatles, was lennon communist
 
1. myLot reputation of 91/100. lpetges (2311)   5 years ago

um,,, hes dead.


myLot reputation of 82/100. raulgc01 (163)   ranked 16 out of 486 in the beatles  5 years ago

ok, let me rephrase my question, WAS John Lennon a communist?

Free The Beatles Music Listen To Your Favorite The Beatles Songs. Get Downloads & More Free  Music.PureDef.com
 
2. strawbfan (24)   ranked 439 out of 486 in the beatles   5 years ago

like the other guy said hwo cares he isn`t around any longer

Free History Magazine Get the world's biggest events. Get a free History Channel® Magazine.  Thehistorychannelclub.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 97/100. sarahruthbeth22 (15799)   5 years ago

I don't think John was a communist. He was for peace but I don't think he ever said that he for a communist or a capitalist government.


myLot reputation of 82/100. raulgc01 (163)   ranked 16 out of 486 in the beatles  5 years ago

he would never say than he is a communist, he will be arrested if he did that. The messages of his songs, Revolution and Imagine have sommunism ideals, you know, he was pushing for revolutionm, no religion and no government in his songs.


myLot reputation of 97/100. sarahruthbeth22 (15799)  5 years ago

Just because he wasn't for religion doesn't make him a communist. There are many Agnostics and Atheists here in the States and they are not communists.And a lot of people were anti government in the 60's. His government and ours were sending young men ti die in a war many didn't believe was right.So that doesn't make him a communist either.


myLot reputation of 97/100. kaplya (1135)   ranked 336 out of 486 in the beatles  5 years ago

yes one can not tag somebody as being communist if he is in favor of peace and unity in the world!:)


myLot reputation of 82/100. raulgc01 (163)   ranked 16 out of 486 in the beatles  5 years ago

Being a communist does not mean being brutal, sowing terror or war-freaked. Communism is a peaceful coexistence with one another with all people being equal, without religion or god and government (That's why I think it is impossible). What's inhuman is the process of the transformation and education from the present set up to communism. So when I say that John might be a communist, I do not mean that he wanted a world full of wars and chaos.


myLot reputation of 89/100. sageivyberyl (703)  5 years ago

John Lennon believed that religion was a personal issue. That people did not have to congregate with or convert others. That what you believe should be respected instead of being used as an excuse to hate. That your beliefs were yours and yours alone to teach your children, pray to your higher being and to find peace within yourself. If you look at his history, you will see that he did not believe that anyone should control anothers beliefs. Religious, political, or otherwise. In saying no religion and no politics, he was showing that these are walls that separate people from really getting to know others beyond the surface. In Revolution, he was saying to break the chains that bind us, use us as excuses to start wars, and in general, teaching hate and violence rather then love and peace. To stop letting others decide and control what we do, what we think, what we say, and what we believe in based on what others decide. He wanted us to start thinking for ourselves based on open minds and love. With world peace as the ultimate goal. This is not communism. This is freedom.


myLot reputation of 97/100. sarahruthbeth22 (15799)  5 years ago

Sageivyberyl, I couldn't say it any better. These are the times when I wish I could vote for the best comment.


myLot reputation of 89/100. sageivyberyl (703)  5 years ago

Thank you Sarah

King of Pop's influences The King of Pop's musical influence James Brown, Stevie Wonder, more  thegrio.com/king-of-pops-music
 
4. myLot reputation of 84/100. jend80 (1666)   ranked 5 out of 486 in the beatles   5 years ago

Lennon had left/far(ish/radical left leaning during parts of his life and musical carear and once described himself as a zen Marxist.

Have you actually listened to or read the lyrics of Revolution?

John's not wanting Revolution but challenging someone who is and expects his support.

You say you want a revolution
Well you know
We all want to change the world
You tell me that it's evolution
Well you know
We all want to change the world
But when you talk about destruction
Don't you know you can count me out
Don't you know it's gonna be alright?
Alright?
Alright?

You say you got a real solution
Well you know
We'd all love to see the plan
You ask me for a contribution
Well you know
We're doing what we can
But when you want money for people with minds that hate
All I can tell you is brother you have to wait
Don't you know it's gonna be alright?
Alright?
Alright?

You say you'll change the constitution
Well you know
We all want to change your head
You tell me it's the institution
Well you know
You better free your mind instead
But if you go carrying pictures of Chairman Mao
You ain't going to make it with anyone anyhow
Don't you know know it's gonna be alright?
Alright?
Alright?

Alright!

Bad Credit Lenders Quick And Simple Procedure. Free Referral Service. Contact Us Today!  www.badcreditcashsource.us
 
5. myLot reputation of 85/100. rogue13xmen13 (10465)   ranked 203 out of 486 in the beatles   5 years ago

I don't think that he is really a communist, but it seems like anyone with a radical unifying idea is deemed a communist... I think that he is just a guy who had ideas that people think are radical.

Maureen Mcgovern Tickets Purchase beatles Tickets. All Orders Guaranteed!  AboutTicket.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 69/100. puchapox (528)   ranked 202 out of 486 in the beatles   5 years ago

He is a peace activist...as his song says, "Give Peace a Chance. "John Lennon was prominent during the time Vietnam War was raging and he was against it. There was even a conspiracy theory that his assasin, Mark David Chapman, was programmed by the US government to kill him because he was being a threat to mobilize the us people against the government and their war in Vietnam - ala 'conspiracy theory' movie.
Anyhoo..why do u care so much if he was a communist or what? he's a great songwriter, musician, artist. He's a legend, and that's what matters.


myLot reputation of 84/100. jend80 (1666)   ranked 5 out of 486 in the beatles  5 years ago

Vietnam was long over by 1980 - if the Us Government had wanted to kill him they could easily have done it at a point while he was visible still a threat, by making sure somebody slipped him some bad/extra pure drugs or faking a suicide - not in a way that makes him a martyr.

3 Free Credit Scores Get All 3 Credit Scores, It's Fast - Easy & Free! Check Online Now.  www.debt-tips.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 93/100. houndsgood (595)   ranked 425 out of 486 in the beatles   5 years ago

I think its easy for people in the entertainment business who no longer need to worry about personal comforts to embrace government models and promote philosophies to the masses that just won't "work." Because when you think about it - if he grew up in a Marxist society John Lennon would not have been allowed to express himself musically like he did. Many times in dictatorship or communist goverment, dignitaries and celebrities of other countries are treated like special guests of the government so they do not really "see" how people living under that philosophy - even if flawed - live. So of course they are going to think its just peachy.

John Lennon's whole life was almost the antithesis of Marxism as much as he toyed with the idea. The fact that he achieved at a much higher level and obtained not just riches but intellectual freedom would never fly.

"communism" had nothing to do with "communes"

So I prefer to remember John Lennon as a brilliant collaborator/musician/lyricist but like many celebrities, his self indulgent musings were not all based with two feet on the floor.

Money Market Rates Get The Best Money Market Rates With Exclusive Online Offers.  firstcountybank.com
 
8. GioKub (1)   1 year ago

Yes of course, john lennon is still a comunnist he was a militant of the troskyst party in England and the world. Long live to him.

Top Rated Mutual Funds 1. Find Top Performing Mutual Funds. 2. Invest and Become Wealthy, Now!  ssgaFunds.com/MutualFunds
 
sponsors
Bad Credit Lenders
Quick And Simple Procedure. Free Referral Service. Contact Us Today!
www.badcreditcashsource.us

Maureen Mcgovern Tickets
Purchase beatles Tickets. All Orders Guaranteed!
AboutTicket.com

3 Free Credit Scores
Get All 3 Credit Scores, It's Fast - Easy& Free! Check Online Now.
www.debt-tips.com

similar discussions
remember this
'Remember this' was one of my dad's favourite sayings to me as I grew up, it's odd because I think...
How John Lenon Died? Beatles
Hello friends, yesterday i was watching FOX History and entertainment channel on my TV and i...
Maybe John Lennon wasnt that nice a guy
I watched a movie on John Lennon this evening on PBS and I used to be SO in love with John. I...
Which Beatle had the best solo career?
Personally, I feel that John Lennon had the best solo career. I would say that his solo works are...
Is John Lennon and Paul McCartney best composer?
John Lennon and Paul McCartney have ever got title best composer by magazine Rolling Stones. Is the...
It Was 30 Years Ago Today....
That John Lennon tragically passed away! 30 years ago today, December 8th, 1980, Mark Chapman...
Happy BIrthday John!
John Lennon would have turned 70 today! 70! Wow. I still picture him as a young man with the mop...
Happy 70th Birthday Mr. Lennon!!!
I figured (being a hippie chick and all) I would celebrate this man's birthday all weekend long!...
John Lennon could've turned 70 years old on October 9
It's been 30 years since John Lennon was assasinated. He left us with a rich legacy of songs from...
John Lennon at 70 years old - what song do you think he could've composed?
If John Lennon were still alive today, he would've turn 70 years old this October 9. If he were...
sponsors
Bad Credit Lenders
Quick And Simple Procedure. Free Referral Service. Contact Us Today!
www.badcreditcashsource.us
Maureen Mcgovern Tickets
Purchase beatles Tickets. All Orders Guaranteed!
AboutTicket.com
3 Free Credit Scores
Get All 3 Credit Scores, It's Fast - Easy & Free! Check Online Now.
www.debt-tips.com
Money Market Rates
Get The Best Money Market Rates With Exclusive Online Offers.
firstcountybank.com
Top Rated Mutual Funds
1. Find Top Performing Mutual Funds. 2. Invest and Become Wealthy, Now!
ssgaFunds.com/MutualFunds
with bad credit
Bad Credit? Not A Problem. Rebuild It Today With a New CC.
CardWisdom.com
What Is Mutual Fund
Looking For What Is Mutual Fund? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.