sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

Improving the gene pool - unethical? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 63/100. Valce1 (146)3 years ago

Gene therapy is a long way off, but there are a number of things we can do today to improve the gene pool.

The most obvious, of course, is mandatory sterilization for people deemed unfit to produce children. [By which, I clarify, I mean just the mentally retarded/criminally insane.]

To make up for the lack of children you can use artificial insemination etc. to give children to those who can't produce them. The effects of nature and nurture are debatable, but this way we'd at least ensure a good nature for every kid.

Doesn't seem like many people would go for a plan like that though...

I don't really see why not - at the rate we're going, severe mental illnesses and the like are going to eventually affect the entire population. And a world full of psycopaths/retards is not a happy world:(

 
 
sponsors
Enterprise Holiday Rental
Beat the holiday rush! Book your car rental now. We'll Pick You Up®.
www.Enterprise.com

Art in Fredericksburg, VA
Galleries, Museums, and the Performing Arts. Request a free guide.
www.VisitFred.com

car certified dealer used at Yahoo!
Find Washington, DC area used Honda car dealers and get a free quote.
www.promotions.yahoo.com/honda

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  genes, hitlers germany, gene pool, kill the jews, german people
 
1. myLot reputation of 95/100. TheHairDresser (3366)   3 years ago

Hello Valce
This is obviously, a highly controversial subject. Messing with genes is almost a taboo subject. For instance, religious convictions vs scientific theorys and experients.
The main thing I want to say about the gene therapy theory, is that it is quite possibly unethical.
It would be wonderful to be able to make a perfect world, but it really is an impossiblity no matter what approach taken by humans, as we are all imperfect, and the persons implementing the changes, well, who's to say that they would be perfect as well?
A world full of mean people would be the worst, period.:)*


myLot reputation of 63/100. Valce1 (146)  3 years ago

I agree!!

Maybe I'm just an idealist for believing that we can solve all our problems genetically:(

But it would be nice if people could be made smarter/healthier/happier through gene therapy:)


myLot reputation of 95/100. TheHairDresser (3366)  3 years ago

Valce
I agree with you too as well regarding the fact that it would be marvellous if we could improve quality of life through altering our genetic make-up. And yes, of course, I think you are the perfect example of an idealist, and what is the harm in wanting perfection for mankind?
Me too:)*


myLot reputation of 63/100. Valce1 (146)  3 years ago

lol, Thanks )


myLot reputation of 95/100. TheHairDresser (3366)  3 years ago

You are so welcome:)*

Enterprise Holiday Rental Beat the holiday rush! Book your car rental now. We'll Pick You Up®. www.Enterprise.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 67/100. barehugs (3947)   3 years ago

Hitler thought this way too. He tried all your ideas on the German People. He was quite successful for a while. He killed the Jews because he thought Germans were a superior Race. Perhaps you should do some research on Adolf Hitler's Germany.
You might learn a few important things that would change your Life. Hitler did, and he's never been the same since!(Heil Hitler!)


myLot reputation of 63/100. Valce1 (146)  3 years ago

lol, I was wondering how long it would take for Godwin's rule to kick in here:p

But yeah, gene therapy isn't related to the Holocaust... The idea is to slowly change people into something better (on an objective point of view, i.e. longer lifespans, fewer diseases etc.) not to discriminate based on something as trivial as race and try to enact immediate change by killing everybody you don't like.

The latter is just a recipe for disaster:(

Art in Fredericksburg, VA Galleries, Museums, and the Performing Arts. Request a free guide. www.VisitFred.com
 
3. emilywickersham (33)   3 years ago

Your stance assumes that negative traits are found by themselves. In fact, many mentally ill people are also creative geniuses and contribute far more to the world that "normal" people. Who is to say that a retarded person might not also carry a gene that might help us beat cancer or otherwise improve the gene pool? Would you want to be eliminated someday because someone decided that the world was too crowded and that your genes weren't good enough to make the cut? Beware of playing God.


myLot reputation of 63/100. Valce1 (146)  3 years ago

I know what you're saying...

And yes, a lot of scizhophrenics (sp?) and autistics have contributed to the world in general. But I never talked about killing people... Sterilization and death are a loooooong way apart.

And at the very least, do you agree that people with psychopathic/pedophilic tendencies or an inherent need to cause destruction shouldn't be allowed to have kids?

car certified dealer used at Yahoo! Find Washington, DC area used Honda car dealers and get a free quote. www.promotions.yahoo.com/honda
 
sponsors
Macy's ® Wedding Registry
Create or Find a Registry @ Macy's. Rewards Program Save 5-10%!
MacysWeddingChannel.com

DC's Condo Specialist
Rachel Valentino, your Washington, DC real estate professional agent. Proven aptitude combined with a powerful work ethic.
www.rachelvalentino.com

nuclear medicine jobs maryland
Find a Nuclear Medicine Job near DC on Washingtonpost.com's Job Guide.
www.washingtonpost.com/jobs

similar discussions
does having a diabetic family member make u more vulnerable to getting diabetes?
my maternal uncle is a diabetic for last 2 years,but there is nobody a diabetic in my family?does...
Are You a Potential Genius?
Are you a potential genius?Do you think everyone is a potential genius?
Gene Therapy!
I recenty watched a show on the History Channel that described how in the NEAR future we will be...
why it is so hard to go back my old figure
i have been dieting for years now but still no result of losing weight. i am so frustrated already...
Genetics: Fun or Freakish
Its utterly amazing how Genetics play such a huge roll in how we look, act, speak, walk, talk, gain...
is handwriting genetic?
can the way you write be genetic? i think yes because my hand writing is like my dad who i haven't...
Can parents with black eyes have baby with blue eyes?
My brother and his wife have brown eyes, both, but they have 2 doughters with blue eyes. Of...
Are people born bad?
Is it a predetermined gene that makes someone a murderer or a rapist? Are their brain structures...
Is this real?
A lot of people here believe that if a pregnant woman doesn't get what she want she will have a...
sponsors
Macy's ® Wedding Registry
Create or Find a Registry @ Macy's. Rewards Program Save 5-10%!
MacysWeddingChannel.com
DC's Condo Specialist
Rachel Valentino, your Washington, DC real estate professional agent. Proven aptitude combined with a powerful work ethic.
www.rachelvalentino.com
nuclear medicine jobs maryland
Find a Nuclear Medicine Job near DC on Washingtonpost.com's Job Guide.
www.washingtonpost.com/jobs
DC Area Attractions
Find museums, national monuments, historic homes, wineries and more.
www.fxva.com
Young Frankenstein in Washington D.C.
See the musical Dec. 15-Jan. 10 at the Opera House! Get tickets here.
Kennedy-Center.org
Insurance Captive Solutions
The Taft Companies, an Insurance Captive and consulting group, provides captive management in Bermuda, Washington DC, South Carolina and Montana.
www.taftcos.com
Self Moving Storage Washington
Free Truck Rental with move in. Reserve now. No CC required.
www.MiniuStorage.com
Single Aspx Page
Get Matched with Sexy Singles in Your Area for Free! Sign-up Now.
www-Join.com/singleaspxpage
Travel to Washington DC
Browse the Best Travel Deals to Washington DC. Use Travelzoo.
www.Travelzoo.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.