sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   news   photos

Is human born good or evil?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 76/100. kilani123 (610)   ranked 218 out of 359 in science 2 years ago

I am wondering if human was born to be good or was born to be evil and parenting and environment turned him into good?

 

science
sponsors
Vein Treatment - No. VA
Learn About New Treatments for Veins at McLean Vein Center.
DC.Vein-Treatment.com

Columbus Plumbers
Need Plumbing Repairs? Find 24/ 7 Services& Contractors in Your Area.
yellowpages.com

Cottonelle® Toilet Paper
Debate& Tell Us How You Roll! Debate& Tell Us How You Roll.
www.CottonelleRollPoll.com

ivyoon (275) response was accepted on 3/20/2008.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  evil, good, human, life, beliefs
 
1. myLot reputation of 74/100. Baltek (222)   2 years ago

I think all humans are borned both evil and good, it's the choice the person makes in his life that will tell what he will become and still at that time he will still have both good and evil inside of him.

Vein Treatment - No. VA Learn About New Treatments for Veins at McLean Vein Center.  DC.Vein-Treatment.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 86/100. ivyoon (275)   2 years ago

There has been a lot of debate over this by Theologians and Psychologists alike for many years. From a "religious" aspect, most Christians believe that humans are "born in sin" because of the sin of Eve (when she took the apple from the Tree Of The Knowledge Of Good And Evil, and gave an apple to Adam as well).
In the Christian Bibles, it is said that because Eve disobeyed God, she and Adam were punished by having "everlasting life" taken away (ashes to ashes) meaning they would no longer live forever, as God had intended, but would die of old age or disease, etc.
From a scientific point of view, many scientists argue whether people are a product of their Genes (parents and family) or their Environment (where they are raised, what they are exposed to, etc).
From that aspect, I believe it is a combination of Genes and Environment that shapes us into who we become. I think truly "evil" people have deep psychological problems in most instances.
I'm not sure what I believe from a religious aspect, except that I do believe we are given the free will to choose our own path in life.
This is a great discussion to post. Thanks!


myLot reputation of 76/100. kilani123 (610)   ranked 218 out of 359 in science  2 years ago

I really like your answer ivyoon. I wonder are you psychologist????


myLot reputation of 86/100. ivyoon (275)  2 years ago

Nope, I'm just an average stay at home mom, but I read a lot and like to have deep discussions with my family and friends. :)


colamon (1)  9 months ago

Really in depth. I agreed that personality/idiosyncrasy is the product from both intuitive and environment factors.

Like, our emotions swing from time to time and that already has impacts on our deeds in terms of good and bad..

Columbus Plumbers Need Plumbing Repairs? Find 24/ 7 Services & Contractors in Your Area.  yellowpages.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 80/100. mrpippo (720)   2 years ago

i think you are what you are ,the enviroment can change you a bit ,but you are what god made you .

Cottonelle® Toilet Paper Debate & Tell Us How You Roll! Debate & Tell Us How You Roll.  www.CottonelleRollPoll.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 82/100. sparkofinsanity (3639)   2 years ago

If you think about it logically it's really a no brainer. Man just likes to complicate things.
Think about this: Every one has emotions. Negative ones like anger, envy, jealousy etc. And positive ones like, compassion, love, etc.
It is the choices we make that determine whether or not we are going to be 'good' or 'evil'. Our choices, though often based on our gene pool, environment, culture or belief system shapes those choices, but are not totally responsible for them. After all God gave us free will. Therefore the choices we make are ours and ours alone and taking responsibility for them makes us better people which basically makes us good - not pefect, who can be - but good. People who make poor choices or don't take responsibility for their actions are not good people.

Illinois Online Divorce Complete All Required Forms Online Fast, Lawyer-Free, 100% Guarantee.  www.DivorceWriter.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 98/100. moolahmagnet (2232)   2 years ago

Christians believe that beings come from God therefore has to be good. What most fail to realize is that humans are mutable, that we evolve according to our environments. Humans have the potential to be better or worse from the time they were born. What humans basically lack is a sturdy moral backbone which has to be taught, developed, exercised and practiced just as a human strengthens the bones of his legs and arms in order to stand, walk and run. It is moral integrity that humans fail to achieve or perhaps lose in their lifetime that causes complexities and life's tragedies.

I quote this one:
"Goodness is a much deeper matter than the superficial signs of niceness and decency. It’s not something we fall into but rather something we have to choose."


Assurity Life Insurance Application Every Job. Everywhere.  www.JobsOnline.net
 
6. jenthsenth (15)   ranked 131 out of 359 in science   2 years ago

Good and evil are terms that are manmade. They mean something different to everybody. We are born as neither. The decisions we make in turn make us moral or not moral, according to what we each believe moral and not moral are. Human morality is the product of evolution, and has developed by our minds. If there is a God, any humble human should be able to admit that human morality is certainly flawed. I, however, don't see any place for God in morality, as I do not believe God affects the universe if God exists.

Motley Fool Stock Advisor Motley Fool Free Report. Our Expert Guide to the Next Tech Revolution.  www.Fool.com
 
7. bronli31 (31)   2 years ago

Hi Kilani, hows ur day? I think human is born to be good people. Only the environment nad other bad factors made the human to become evil. By the way I've already joined bUXnet, and I earned $0.31, not bad. Did you already joined the World Mail Monitor survey that was I sent you before?

Ash Fork Jobs (Now Hiring) Found: 216 Local Ash Fork Jobs. Hiring Now - Apply Today.  AshFork.searchworklistings.net
 
sponsors
Illinois Online Divorce
Complete All Required Forms Online Fast, Lawyer-Free, 100% Guarantee.
www.DivorceWriter.com

Assurity Life Insurance Application
Every Job. Everywhere.
www.JobsOnline.net

Motley Fool Stock Advisor
Motley Fool Free Report. Our Expert Guide to the Next Tech Revolution.
www.Fool.com

similar discussions
Why Did God Create Evil?
If He is indeed the Creator of all, then it would follow that evil is a creation of God. But why...
What do you think about Dowary system.
Today Dowary is think to be a necessary think. In the marriage of a girl that is very bad.
Do you consider having an apprentice if ur already at your throne?
Lets say you already had the power to control this world, everything is going your way, You had...
Creating a perfect Utopia via dictatorship
I'm really enjoying the evilness that "word domination" discussion was so I'll be embracing the...
Ever Came Accross Invisible Mylotters who do things Secretly ?????
I came accross them yesterday----they were so cool and gentle they do not disturb anyone in...
What qualities are you looking for a partner in crime?
Hello evil Mylotters of world domination discussion.For sure even the most evil villains needed a...
Do you think a gentleman still exists in this world or not anymore ?
I Always heard this word from the news or from some girl's month "good guys are hard to find !"It...
Money is NOT the root of all evil. Right? Wrong!
I don't agree with the common beliefs that money is the root of all evil! This is the most common...
How will you pick your minions?
For sure if You were an evil boss, you need to pick the best henchmen that will be loyal and...
In a movie/story have U ever rooted for the villains instead of the hero?
Despite of the dark desire of the villains to rule the world and other catastrophes, in some...
sponsors
Illinois Online Divorce
Complete All Required Forms Online Fast, Lawyer-Free, 100% Guarantee.
www.DivorceWriter.com
Assurity Life Insurance Application
Every Job. Everywhere.
www.JobsOnline.net
Motley Fool Stock Advisor
Motley Fool Free Report. Our Expert Guide to the Next Tech Revolution.
www.Fool.com
Ash Fork Jobs (Now Hiring)
Found: 216 Local Ash Fork Jobs. Hiring Now - Apply Today.
AshFork.searchworklistings.net
Shop Stylus C62 Ink Cartridge
Superior image quality, longer print life & unbeatable value.
Epson.com/StylusC62
Buy Honeyberries Here
Premium Honeyberry Plants From Spring Hill. Free $25 Coupon.
www.SpringHillNursery.com
DC Halloween Magicians
Halloween Comedy Magic. Exciting Stage Illusions and Dove Magic.
www.SpeedThro.com
Find a Psychologist at Psychologytoday
Looking for a Psychologist in Washington? Browse the vast directory of professionally recognized therapists and counselors at Psychologytoday to find a therapist near you.
www.psychologytoday.com
Access Floor Furnish & Installation
ATC is Washington's most experienced Access Floor Installer and Dealer. We stock multiple products and excel in providing original finishes and solutions.
www.accessfloors.us
Evil Tattoo Designs
Evil Tattoo Designs & Ideas! -- Largest Tattoo Gallery Online.
all-tattoo-designs.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.