sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionsblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLot

David vs. David email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 86/100. leeesa (709)   ranked 73 out of 1,436 in american idol3 months ago

I'm sure there are already a ton of similar topics, but now that we're down to the final two American Idol contestants, which David do you think will win? Which David do you want to win?

I think David C deserves to win as the better all around performer, but I have a feeling David A will win based on popularity and predictability. A rocker has never won, so it would be a nice change.

My vote is for David Cook. Although, he would probably have a better career if he didn't win because he wouldn't be tied to AI's stipulations for a year, or whatever it is.

 
 
american idol
sponsors
American Idol's Jared Cotter
Jared hosts hot new dating show "You Rock, Let's Roll." Check it out.
fuse.tv/yourock

10 Rules of Flat Stomach
Cut Out 9 lbs of Stomach Fat every 11 Days by Obeying these 10 Rules.
FatLoss4Idiots.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  american idol, david cook, david archuleta, david archuletta, american i dol
 
1. RebirthX (42)   3 months ago

David Cook will win and should win:). My vote is for David Cook because just as you said He is the better performer. I'm sure it will be a great battle in the finals.

American Idol's Jared Cotter Jared hosts hot new dating show "You Rock, Let's Roll." Check it out. fuse.tv/yourock
 
2. myLot reputation of 99/100. rx4life (1044)   ranked 68 out of 1,436 in american idol   3 months ago

I couldn't agree with you more..in every statement...I'm definitely a DC fan!!! Hopefully the popularity will fall our way!!!

10 Rules of Flat Stomach Cut Out 9 lbs of Stomach Fat every 11 Days by Obeying these 10 Rules. FatLoss4Idiots.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 94/100. emma412 (678)   ranked 150 out of 1,436 in american idol   3 months ago

My vote is definitly for David Cook. He is such an awesome talent and really brings a new light to the show. He can turn any ong into an awesome rock sound and has proved time and again how unique he can make artists songs. I am afraid David Archuleta is going to win because of all the tweeners out there voting. He's a cute guy and all the teen girls are going to want to see him win. I guess all will be told next week. Go Cook!!

 
4. myLot reputation of 98/100. marilynut (897)   ranked 269 out of 1,436 in american idol   3 months ago

cry It will be a great American Idol finale. Both Davids are really great performers. I am hoping David Cook will win. He has a wonderful voice, is a stellar entertainer, is humble and handsome and really has the whole package going for him! It's going to be so exciting ... we Idol fans have been waiting months for this. I have been hearing that David Archuletta is the favorite to win, but I don't know ... it really is going to be a photo finish horse race. Both contestants are already signed up for record contracts. We'll see!!


ai
 
5. myLot reputation of 97/100. aseretdd (3240)   ranked 32 out of 1,436 in american idol   3 months ago

I want David Cook to win... if i can only vote... i will surely vote for him like more than 100 times... i find David Archuleta very boring... it is like there is only one tone in his voice... aside for that... his father is a big turn off...

This is the time for David Cook to really shine... his career will surely flourish with or without the American Idol title... but i still want him to win...

 
6. myLot reputation of 73/100. 00BleedingShadow00 (218)   3 months ago

They are both good singers and performers. They both play musical instruments and they both look good. I can't really choose. I want them both to win the American Idol. I am going to vote for the two. They both deserve to win.


myLot reputation of 72/100. dianel (4003)   ranked 439 out of 1,436 in american idol  3 months ago

David A is much better than cook voice wise. Cook is so predictable. David A is too but he reaches notes cook couldnt even think of. It will be a good competition, but in the end I am praying david A wins he is the best i never liked cook he isnt even good looking he looks so stragily. Guess we will see next wednesday.

 
7. inapaulineabelon (67)   3 months ago

I'm a huge DC fan! I think he's more deserving to win because he is suuuuper original. And he can play the guitar and more flexible. David Archuleta can only sing ballads. But DC can do everything. I soooooooooo love his rendition of that Mariah Carey's song. I forgot the title though. Hehehe!

 
8. AnnikaM (25)   3 months ago

I'm a DC fan all the way! I sure hope all the cougars out there will be voting furiously next Tuesday! Go Cook!

 
9. myLot reputation of 96/100. Ranie19 (392)   ranked 412 out of 1,436 in american idol   3 months ago

Actually, for me, I really don't know how to decide it! Because I love them both! I love when avid Archuleta sang Imagine and With You while Always be my baby and dare you to move by David cook!. aaarrgghh~ hehehehe

 
similar discussions
Who is better Kelly Clarkson or Leona Lewis?
I love it when I read blogs and non americans think just because an American makes an opinion about...
American Idol
Who is you all time favorite winner/performer from American Idol? I would have to say for mine to...
Which is your favorite judge for american idol
1:paula abdul 2:simon cowell 3:randy jackson Mine is Simon.........
What do you think made David Cook win AI?
I thought the last season was pretty scripted and predictable. But during the final battle between...
What do you think of Reynaldo Lapuz?
I'm really proud of him!!He's so funny,, and his song is great!! I swear! I hope he gets his "We're...
DavidCookFanSinceDayOneUpToFinale
I watched American Idol since day one, I actually noticed this rocker during his audition. I feel...
kelly or carrie?
kelly clarkson and carrie underwood both came from american idol. both were talented and both were...
American Idol 2008 Winner, David Cook
Wow, what an incredible American Idol finale it was this year!Season 7 was just fantastic! Couldn't...
KT Tunstall or Katherine McPhee
I loved when Katherine sang 'Black Horse and a Cherry Tree' on American Idol... when I heard KT...
Out of the 24 left on American Idol, who do you want to win?
This is a pretty straight-forward question. Out of the 24 left on American Idol, who do you want to...