sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Carrots, what kind should I plant?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 94/100. Nykkee (1424)   ranked 99 out of 1,674 in gardening 4 years ago

I have been starting a vegetable garden this Spring and I was thinking about planting some carrots. However, when I went to the store to get some seeds, I was shocked to discover that there are actually several different kind of carrots, and I don't know one from the other. Does anyone here at Mylot know anything about carrots? What is the difference between the types? Is one better tasteing or easier to grow than the others? Does it make a difference or are they all pretty much the same? Can someone tell me what type of carrot seeds I should get. My grandmother used to have babay carrots and they were really good but I always thought that was just about how early you harvested them, not the type of carrot, but maybe I'm wrong. The picture that hoepfully will attach with this discussion shows the type of carrots I would like. Please help.


Carrots
 

gardening
sponsors
AeroGarden® Holiday Deals
Special Offers + Free Shipping Guaranteed for Xmas, Shop Now!
www.AeroGarden.com

carrot cake recipes
carrot cake recipes + 100's of Free Recipes with Download
FindRecipeNow.com

Gardening Deals
Pretty plants don't have to cost pretty pennies. Save on gardening!
www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up

edigital (2341) response was accepted on 6/9/2008.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  gardening, carrot, carrot types, carrots, hobby
 
1. myLot reputation of 97/100. peavey (7320)   ranked 39 out of 1,674 in gardening   4 years ago

The type of carrot you should grow depends on your soil and growing season. Most carrots like sandy, loose soil, but there are kinds that grow in heavy clay. Here's a page that explains the difference: http://www.carrotgardenin...

Maybe that will help make up your mind which one you need to grow.


myLot reputation of 94/100. Nykkee (1424)   ranked 99 out of 1,674 in gardening  4 years ago

Thanks for the website, I looked it over and i think I will look for the baby carrots they emtion on there, they sound good.


myLot reputation of 97/100. peavey (7320)   ranked 39 out of 1,674 in gardening  4 years ago

You're welcome. Good luck with your carrots!

AeroGarden® Holiday Deals Special Offers + Free Shipping Guaranteed for Xmas, Shop Now!  www.AeroGarden.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 99/100. pergammano (3539)   ranked 79 out of 1,674 in gardening   4 years ago

I would love to answer all your questions...and might be able to, but first I have to ask a few questions;
a) What is your soil type? Sandy? Loam? Rocky?
b) what is your growing season?
c) Sweet or standard?
d) Early or late harvest

Carrots usually range from 72 to 125 days to harvest. Most grow best in somewhat sandy loam, because as they are growing they need to be able to move the soil. It helps to cultivate them! They range from "Healthmaster F1 Hybrid"-which is a deep reddish orange, which has 30-35% more beta-carotene (because of color) to "Yellowstone F1 Hybrids" which are canary-yellow colored and have the sweetest flavor when eaten raw.......And then there's the old standby "Nantes" which our grandmothers grew...and hundreds in between! Haven't helped you much but if you like, you can sign me up as a friend and then you can PM me, and would love to help! ( owned a Nursery for 13 years)
Happy Gardening! Cheers!


myLot reputation of 94/100. Nykkee (1424)   ranked 99 out of 1,674 in gardening  4 years ago

I don't know what loam is, but out soil is reddish, so and it has alot of rocks and stuff in it. I would prefer sweet carrots if they will grow here. My garden doesn't get alot of sun, it only has partial sun to shade at times. I need to cut some trees down from behind it.

carrot cake recipes carrot cake recipes + 100's of Free Recipes with Download  FindRecipeNow.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 92/100. royal52gens (3634)   ranked 41 out of 1,674 in gardening   4 years ago

I like both the long and the short kinds. Our soil is very hard and we have lots of clay. Normally, the carrots would grow crooked and knarly. So I mix my carrot seeds with my radish seeds. The roots of the radishes keep the soil broke open enough for the carrots to grow straight. When the radishes are ready to be picked, they also help to space the carrots out from each other. This process is called Companion Planting.


myLot reputation of 94/100. Nykkee (1424)   ranked 99 out of 1,674 in gardening  4 years ago

Your soil sounds like mine and I thank you for the tip but I really don't like radishs. So far all I have planted it beets and they are growing sooooooooo slow, I don't know what to do, I fertilized them yesterday, I hope that helps.


myLot reputation of 99/100. pergammano (3539)   ranked 79 out of 1,674 in gardening  4 years ago

I like you plant radishes, but with everything I grow. They are the first to propogate, so they mark every row, early! And when you harvest them, they both aerate & loosen the soil!

I am actually thinking with the kind of soil that you have, until you have the time to amend the soil with compost & sand...and remove some trees (for more sunshine)you may NOT want to grow root crops. Carrots are inexpensive to buy (I know it's not like growing your own..or nor do they taste as good)BUT, at present your growing conditions are not optimum!

After my carrots have been thinned to about 4" apart...I plant onion sets in between them..the onions help to break up the soil...and totally deters Carrot Fly..that can dessimate a crop.

Happy Gardening!


myLot reputation of 94/100. Nykkee (1424)   ranked 99 out of 1,674 in gardening  4 years ago

Thanks for the tips. I recieved some carrot seeds from my mother in law the other day so I guess I will just use that kind. I hope they grow good. My beets are still barely visible.

Gardening Deals Pretty plants don't have to cost pretty pennies. Save on gardening!  www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up
 
4. myLot reputation of 86/100. edigital (2341)   4 years ago

Hello Nykkee ! Here is useful information about carrot you want to plant. Read it carefully and choose yourself best carrot you want to plant at a place :-

If you’re new to gardening with carrots you’ll be amazed at the number of varieties out there. Carrots come in a number of different shapes, sizes, and colors. No matter what season of the year, your experience level, or the size of your garden, you’ll find a carrot variety that’s appropriate to grow in your home garden.

Carrots are usually divided into groups based on how deep they grow. Thin, deep growing carrots (up to 10 inches) are know as Imperator carrots. Danvers grow up to 7 inches long and are also thin. The tops are thicker and the flavor of the Danvers tends to be strong. Nantes are sweet, round carrots that grow to around 6 inches long. Chantenay carrots grow around 5 to 6 inches. They are a wider variety of carrot. Amsterdam carrots are small and thin, growing no more than 3 inches long on average. Paris Market carrots are very short carrots, and grow to about 1 ½ inches in diameter.

Here, we’ve listed some of our favorite carrots for the home garden. Make sure to talk to your local extension agent for recommendations on which carrots are best adapted to your area. Also, ask your favorite nursery for pest and disease resistant varieties which will help reduce the need for pesticides and fungicides.


Favorite Carrot Varieties for the Home Garden

Carrots for heavy soils:
Look for varieties that grow shorter and don’t need to penetrate deeply into the soil.

• Amsterdam Forcing 2, Amice
• Autumn King 2
• Chantenay Red Cored 2
• Pioneer
• Nantes Half-long
• Little Finger
• Danvers Half-long
• Spartan Bonus
• Five-Star Baby
• Parmex
• Mini Round
• Thumbelina

Carrots for container gardens:
While you can use containers of various depths to grow carrots, smaller varieties are usually best. Try out some of the following carrots in your container garden.

• Amsterdam Forcing 2, Amice
• Amsterdam Forcing 3 , Sprint
• Chantenay Red Cored 2
• Danvers Half-long
• Spartan Bonus
• Nantes Half-long
• Little Finger
• Mini Round
• Pioneer

Carrots for the Fall and Winter:

• Artemis
• Autumn King 2
• Barwon
• Carotene 200

Scarlet NantesScarlet NantesScarlet Nantes:

• Scarlet Nantes
• Royal Chantenay
• Merida, Overwintering
• Nantaise
• Nelson

Disease and Pest Resistant Carrots:

• Flyaway. Resistant to the carrot fly.
• Barwon. Resistant to alternaria and leaf blights.
• Bolero. Resistant to alternaria blight, powdery mildew, and cavity spot.
• Magno. Resists cracking and cavity spot.
• Topweight. Resists most carrot pests and diseases.

Carrots with Exceptionally Sweet Flavor:

• Adonis
• Artist
• Soprano
• Royal Chantenay
• Kingston

Unusual Carrots:

• Parmex. Small, almost completely round.
• Belgian White. White skin and flesh.
• Early Horn. An old variety with a reddish skin.
• French Round. Almost complete round.
• King West. Red roots.
• Pakistani. Can be purple to red in color. Very rare.
• Sinclair's. A yellow variety.
• Cosmic Purple. Deep red to purple skin with red/orange flesh.
• Thumberline. Round carrot.
• Dragon. Purple skin with orange flesh. Highly nutritious.
• Rainbow. Grows as a variety of pastel colors.

The Carrot Museum has an interesting site with a list of different carrot varieties.


myLot reputation of 86/100. edigital (2341)  4 years ago

More tips for carrot plantation:-

When you plant your carrot seeds directly in your garden, make sure you work your soil early in the spring so that it is loose and well draining. When there is no risk of a hard frost, plant your seeds about 3/8 of an inch into the soil. You can space your rows about 15 inches or a little wider if you prefer.

Note that carrots are not usually grown as transplants because when you place them in the garden, the roots have a propensity to fork.

Cover the seedlings with a thin layer of organic mulch such as straw or shredded bark. This will keep your soil moist while the seedlings are developing. Once your seedlings emerge, you can add more mulch around the plants. A layer of mulch about 3-4 inches deep is recommended after the seedlings emerge.

Once the carrot seedlings begin to appear, you should thin them out a bit. They’ll need at least ¾” between plants. As the carrots mature, thin them out to about 3-4 inches apart. As a general rule, the larger the carrot you want, the wider the spacing should be. Wider spacing also helps with an easier harvest.

Thin your carrots when they are about 1 inch tall. Be careful not to disrupt the other plants while you’re thinning your garden. Root vegetables are often sold as pelleted seeds. These seed varieties will help with even spacing and will reduce the time you spend thinning out your carrots.

If you want to have carrots throughout the growing season, you can grow a new batch after the first carrots have grown for about 3-4 weeks. Carrots will germinate after about 2 weeks, and sometimes your plants will germinate unevenly throughout your garden.

If you want a fall crop of carrots, give yourself at least 2-3 months before the first fall frost. This will ensure that you carrots will be ready to harvest before a hard frost hits.

Check with your local extension agent to get an idea of when the first frost is likely to occur in your area.


myLot reputation of 94/100. Nykkee (1424)   ranked 99 out of 1,674 in gardening  4 years ago

Oh my god the information! Thanks. Actually my mother-in-law gave us some carrot seeds so I think I will just use those this year. Maybe next year I will try thr Five star Baby or something.


myLot reputation of 86/100. edigital (2341)  4 years ago

Thanks for information and I pray for your success !

Survival Seed Vault 37.95 Same Day Shipping - Jumbo Seed Packets - Free Shipping  MyPatriotSupply.com
 
sponsors
Survival Seed Vault 37.95
Same Day Shipping - Jumbo Seed Packets - Free Shipping
MyPatriotSupply.com

Uncle Jim's Worm Farm
Live Composting and Gardening Worms. Guaranteed Live. Free Shipping.
www.unclejimswormfarm.com

Cheap Container Gardening
Container Gardening at Best-Price! Over 6.000 shops& 23 Mil products.
Container-Gardening.best-price.com

similar discussions
I want to grow celery in my garden this spring
Has anyone every grown celery in their gardens? What was your experience with it? Is it easy to...
garlic in a pot
hi! mylotter friends, i need your opinion about this. i was thinking of planting plants that can...
What can I do to help out the organic garden that I will be growing?
I will be putting in an organic garden this spring (I am in the process of buying a house and...
Third Time Lucky Trying To Post This!
I don't know why but, whenever I try to post anything in this category I get nowhere! Oh...
My tomatoes have fruits!
I planted tomato seed this Winter, but did not know how they would come out. I planted 2 kinds of...
Gardening in home
In our living place we had some extra place were we used to grow few plants for flowers and also we...
Seeding brocolli
Lately, I tried to seed brocolli in a small seeding container. To my surprise, each seed was able...
Growing vegetables
Last year my mother gave me tomato plants, I don't eat tomatoes but I grew them and everyone I gave...
Do you think planting our own food is better than frozen food?
So do you think that planting our own food is a much better move than eating frozen food. The...
Do any of you do vermiculture?
After I get into my new house I plan on having a vermiculture going. That is a worm bin to help get...
sponsors
Survival Seed Vault 37.95
Same Day Shipping - Jumbo Seed Packets - Free Shipping
MyPatriotSupply.com
Uncle Jim's Worm Farm
Live Composting and Gardening Worms. Guaranteed Live. Free Shipping.
www.unclejimswormfarm.com
Cheap Container Gardening
Container Gardening at Best-Price! Over 6.000 shops & 23 Mil products.
Container-Gardening.best-price.com
Nursery Stock Catalog
Fruit Trees, Ornimantals, Berries, Gardening Products. Free Catalog.
www.millernurseries.com
New: Hobby up to 57% less
Quality Hobby at bargain prices: Compare Hobby and save up to 57%!
www.Hobby.news72.com
Local Gardening Centers
Looking For Gardening Centers?
yellowpages.com
Gardening Coupons & Deals
Free Printable Coupons from Top Brands! Download Now
SHOPATHOME.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.