ERP gantries reduced traffic in city area!

@ahgong (10064)
Singapore
July 8, 2008 11:25pm CST
Who is the government trying to kid? I read with interest about the recent activation of the ERP along a stretch of road that runs around the city. You can read the article here: http://www.todayonline.com/articles/264016.asp It is always human nature that when one is slapped in the face with additional charges, one would have the knee jerk reaction of trying to find an alternative. AND until one cannot find an alternative, then he will have to go back to the routine and accept the charges. So, the gantry went up yesterday. Today, the traffic improves. And all the people at the top are patting themselves in the back saying they are doing a good job using this tolls as the traffic controlling tool. Sheez!
3 responses
@applefreak (3130)
• Singapore
9 Jul 08
actually i do agree with the ERP system. it's not meant to deter people from going through that stretch totally. it's meant to divert traffic during the peak hours. it works to a certain extent in that people who doesn't Need to be there will not go through there. i used to stay in that area and i can say the traffic there is horrendous. it takes at least 20min just to clear a 1.5km stretch of road. if it can make people think twice about using that road, it's working already. ;p
1 person likes this
@ahgong (10064)
• Singapore
10 Jul 08
I have got nothing against the ERP and its implementation. I have no qualms about having tolls to go into the city. And I do know what you mean about the horrendous traffic. Cos I ever chalked up a $10 meter fare waiting in the cab that is stuck in traffic along this stretch of road. What amuses me is this: It is always human nature that having been slapped with higher charges, drivers will have the knee jerk reaction and naturally avoid that stretch of road in the first few weeks, seeking alternative routes. Only all alternatives are exhausted, they will naturally go back to the same route, bearing the extra cost due to one reason or another. So to pad oneself on the back for lower traffic usage on the first day, is... well, DUH~~~~!! And also to create so many gantrys for the various area is also, well, I feel, too much. If you are in the city, you are in the city. If it is so important to segregate them, then follow the French design of Paris! Where there are rings around the city center and you only pay one charge to travel within that same ring. You cross the rings, then you pay. But here, the ERP is like all over the frigging place. no?
1 person likes this
@ahgong (10064)
• Singapore
22 Aug 08
Well, I am sure when the traffic starts to pick up, the media will not be so quick to report it. With so many gantries being up on the major roads, most of the small roads are getting congested. And due to that, what use to take 40 mins to get to work on the smaller roads, now takes up to and hour and a half or more just to travel the same route. I am sure it is a matter of time before these congested small roads (which was the result of those knee jerk reactions to avoid the ERP gantries) will also have gantries of their own to "regulate" traffic. Sigh~~~ it is a vicious cycle!
1 person likes this
• Singapore
10 Jul 08
well i can only hope it's not a knee jerk reaction. i do consciously avoid certain places during certain hours. i don't so much try alternative routes. with petrol prices now, it's more expensive to take detours. ;o so in a way, yes i either go off work earlier or i'll just hang around town before heading home. it's easier since i've got direct train home from work. so i can meet my partner at home too. ;p
1 person likes this
@squaretile (3778)
• Singapore
9 Jul 08
You're right, it's really disgusting how they are implementing this when there are food shortages and fuel increases and electricity tariff increases. crazy time to do such an extensive increase in road charges. I'm glad that I don't own a car, but it's just getting rather ridiculous. did you hear the news that they intend to increase the total number from 60 to 90! I am amazed that they even dared to report this! in any other country there'd be protests on the streets already. sometimes i just wish i wasn't living here.
1 person likes this
@ahgong (10064)
• Singapore
10 Jul 08
I have got nothing against the ERP and its implementation. I have no qualms about having tolls to go into the city. Living here is not that bad. It is just that, somethimmes the way the policies are implemented, and how they pat themselves on the back after the implementation that amuses me. To increase from the existing 60 to 90?!? So many gantries? Well, I feel, too much. If you are in the city, you are in the city. If it is so important to segregate them, then follow the French design of Paris! Where there are rings around the city center and you only pay one charge to travel within that same ring. You cross the rings, then you pay. But here, the ERP is like all over the frigging place. Sigh~~~ I wonder what goes on in the minds of these people who are designing the allocation of the gantries.
@raclie (1732)
• Singapore
9 Jul 08
well.... all i can think is that it will decrease traffic flow, and thus make singapore a cleaner place to live as there will be more people using public transport. i think using using this tolls as the traffic controlling tool is a good idea as it will discurage people from using the major city roads and use public transport. public transport is cheaper and cleaner at a long run, so everyone wins...