sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

are we too accomodating?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 96/100. cher913 (21887)   ranked 251 out of 32,948 in life 4 years ago

here in canada, there is a Sikh gentleman that was told to leave the jobsite (safety reasons!)because he wouldn't shave his beard. he feels he is being discrimiated, so he is suing the company.

another Sikh gentleman went to court because he feels he cannot wear a motorcycle helmet because of his turbun that he needs to wear for religious reasons.

i am sure you have stories of your own and i am not necessarily pointing fingers at Sihks, but what do you think?

 

life
sponsors
Safety& Health Degree
Online, Flexible, Self-Paced Affordable, BCSP recognized.
www.ColumbiaSouthern.edu/OSH

IRBNet - Powerful, Secure
The world's most widely used tools for IRB, IACUC, IBC and more.
www.IRBNet.org

The Church Jesus Built
What happened to the church Jesus began? How will you recognize it?
www.ucg.org/bible-study-aid

drknlvly6781 (3437) response was accepted on 1/15/2009.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  canada, compliance, health and safety, religion, too accomodating
 
1. myLot reputation of 97/100. ShepherdSpy (4260)   ranked 326 out of 32,948 in life   4 years ago

Just wondering,in view of the second example,how the first Guy's beard could be a building site hazard? Was it so long there was a risk he'd get it caught in some rotating machinery? When the Second Guy refused a crash Helmet,did the first Guy refuse to wear a Hard Hat? I never worked on a Bulding site,or rode a motorbike,and I haven't worked with a Sikh to ask questions about this sort of thing..These issues have to have been raised previously within the English Sikh Population,so how were these issues resolved there? If the Law requires You to wear a Helmet when riding a Bike for Your own safety,You can comply with the Law,or use other forms of transport that don't need safety equipment to be worn..bus,car..Health and Safety legislation is not a Religous issue.

Safety & Health Degree Online, Flexible, Self-Paced Affordable, BCSP recognized.  www.ColumbiaSouthern.edu/OSH
 
2. myLot reputation of 79/100. drknlvly6781 (3437)   ranked 3,364 out of 32,948 in life   4 years ago

I hope the first man doesn't get what he is suing for, because if he worked for a restaurant, no matter what religion he is people don't want hair in their food!!! And for the other guy, I say let him go without a helmet. Its his brains that will be splattered all over the pavement. I feel kinda sorry for him, I don't think I could serve a God that would rather me keep up my religious habits rather than take precautions for my safety.


myLot reputation of 79/100. drknlvly6781 (3437)   ranked 3,364 out of 32,948 in life  4 years ago

Thanks for the best response!

IRBNet - Powerful, Secure The world's most widely used tools for IRB, IACUC, IBC and more.  www.IRBNet.org
 
3. myLot reputation of 98/100. raydene (5491)   4 years ago

My attitude is this

Laws are made to protect the majority.

I would say if the job for safty reasons requires

he should shave then shave or find a new job.

I have worked many places where I had to put my hair up or

wear certain clothing or footwear.We all ahve had to do

many things different then what we prefer to get or keep a job.

My attitude about the motorcycle is just find another means of

transportation or get a bigger helmet and stop wasting

taxpayers dollars with all this stupidity!

There are wayy too many real rights being walked on to waste

the court times on this stuff!

xoxoxoxoxo

The Church Jesus Built What happened to the church Jesus began? How will you recognize it?  www.ucg.org/bible-study-aid
 
4. myLot reputation of 88/100. mouse27 (1083)   ranked 8,787 out of 32,948 in life   4 years ago

i live in BC and that is a huge issue out here when it comes to sikh's wearing helmets but the way i see it is if they don't want to follow the laws of canada then their the ones that are going to pay for it by loosing their life or at the very least loosing whatever motor functions they have because they get into an accident and aren't wearing a helmet. as for the guy that got told to leave the jobsite cause he wouldn't shave his beard depending on the jobsite it could be a safety hazard. a depending on how long his beard is.

Serve God & Our Fellowman 100% Online Master Degree (MEd) in Religion for Busy Christian Workers  EducationDegreeSource.com/Free_Info
 
sponsors
Serve God& Our Fellowman
100% Online Master Degree (MEd) in Religion for Busy Christian Workers
EducationDegreeSource.com/Free_Info

Visit mormon.org
Reach Spiritual Fulfillment through Christ& the Mormon faith
www.mormon.org

Money Transfer Software
World's only Free software system for banks& money transmitters
www.remitanywhere.com

similar discussions
i want to work in the mines during summer in Canada!
I heard the safety measure in working in the mines in Canada is good and the money too...lol. I...
Cheap travel in canada
Hello i'm planning to go to Canada, and want to hear if anybody knows a cheap way to do this....
being in canada
I must say that it wasnt easy but i was successful to come and study in canada, it is a dream come...
Is canada open for work?
I am searching for new work which can compensate my family and my talent. I am happy with my...
Canada's Loss to Russia 2011
This was potentially going to be the biggest junior hockey comeback story of the decade, but then...
sponsors
Serve God & Our Fellowman
100% Online Master Degree (MEd) in Religion for Busy Christian Workers
EducationDegreeSource.com/Free_Info
Visit mormon.org
Reach Spiritual Fulfillment through Christ & the Mormon faith
www.mormon.org
Money Transfer Software
World's only Free software system for banks & money transmitters
www.remitanywhere.com
Workplace Safety
Find Workplace Health & Safety. Your Business Solution Business.com
www.business.com
Depression Information
Are You Depressed? Don't Wait. Get The Help You Need Now!
HealthVinePlus.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.