sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

how different is a cast iron pan from normal pans?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 95/100. katemeow (597)   ranked 184 out of 8,636 in cooking 4 years ago

I've read somewhere that the best pans to cook with are cast iron pans. Is this true? And how is it different? Right now we only have aluminum and teflon coated pans at home. Aside from the material used in making it, how different is a cast iron pan from normal pans?

 

cooking
sponsors
Designrail by Feeney
Aluminum rail frames designed for your balconies, stairs and decks.
www.designrail.com

Fence Services
Find Local Pre-Screened Contractors With Our Free Service. Search Now!
www.ServiceMagic.com

Aluminum Railings
Simple-Quick-Low Cost Installation. Easy to Maintain Handrail System
www.Hollaender.com

thebeaddoodler (2880) response was accepted on 12/23/2008.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  cast iron, aluminum, aluminum pans, cast iron cooks better, cast iron pan
 
1. myLot reputation of 98/100. thebeaddoodler (2880)   ranked 76 out of 8,636 in cooking   4 years ago

If I could only have one kind of pan, I would choose cast iron. They spread the heat evenly so even if the burner doesn't cover the whole pan you may get a little "hot spot" in the center, but the food cooks all the way out to the edges.

Clean-up is a breeze. If there's stuck food on the pan, pour in some water, bring it to a boil, then scrub. It comes off easily. Rinse well, put on a burner to dry. If it needs it after being treated so roughly, coat the inner surface with a very, very light film of oil and heat it til a little smoke begins to waft off the pan. Take it off the burner. It's clean, seasoned and ready to cook in again.

I used to cook in aluminum and teflon (silverstone actually). I found the aluminum doesn't cook foods to taste like cast iron does. Coated pans eventually get scratched and start to flake and peel, but I have 2 cast iron skillets that I got in my wedding shower 50 years ago that are a little crusty on the outside, but still are superior cooking vessels.


myLot reputation of 95/100. katemeow (597)   ranked 184 out of 8,636 in cooking  4 years ago

wow, that is amazing :) I think I will get a cast iron pan soon when i can afford it :) btw, I saw in an article that you are not supposed to use soap on a cast iron pan because it may affect the taste of the food. Is this true? If yes, the how do you disinfect it? I think I am a bit of a soap freak sometimes :)


myLot reputation of 98/100. thebeaddoodler (2880)   ranked 76 out of 8,636 in cooking  4 years ago

Cast iron is porous, so when you wash it with soap it is absorbed into the metal, which can make your food taste like soap. It also cuts the oil that you've seasoned your vessel with, so foods may stick after you wash with soap. You always heat your cast iron vessels to the point that they smoke in order to dry them and keep them seasoned so food doesn't stick. In my opinion that's more of a disinfectant than soap.


myLot reputation of 88/100. grandpa_lash (2048)   ranked 585 out of 8,636 in cooking  4 years ago

Rather than wash them with soap, or scour them, put some salt in the pan and rub it around with paper towel until the pan is clean. You should probably oil it until it builds up a black covering, but after that it only needs drying. Once it is properly seasoned, it is near enough to no-stick. Also, they last forever. The only drawback is that they can be heavy, so if you have to lift them up to pour into something else, it can be a little difficult. They are also quite cheap, at least here, and you will probably find them easiest in a camping or army disposals store.

Lash


myLot reputation of 95/100. katemeow (597)   ranked 184 out of 8,636 in cooking  4 years ago

Wow, thank you for this info! I never knew that iron pans are porous! Thanks for suggesting using salt as a cleaning agent. I am trying to make my home more "green" by trying to stay away from strong cleaning solutions. Thanks again :)

Designrail by Feeney Aluminum rail frames designed for your balconies, stairs and decks.  www.designrail.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 97/100. momiecat (505)   ranked 3,973 out of 8,636 in cooking   4 years ago

My mother, who is a great cook, has used cast iron pans forever. She uses them to fry foods as they get very hot and retain the heat in an even distribution. Also, they last forever. My mom has had other types of pans including aluminum and the handles always end up breaking. The only thing I don't like about cast iron is that it is so heavy and may be harder to clean than Teflon. PS I like your kitty picture!


myLot reputation of 95/100. katemeow (597)   ranked 184 out of 8,636 in cooking  4 years ago

yes, i think it's because of how sturdy they are built that makes them last forever :) i was just looking at how crooked my teflon pan has become because of how thin it is!

thanks for your comment on my pic- it is of my cat, nugget :) I like yours too :)

Fence Services Find Local Pre-Screened Contractors With Our Free Service. Search Now!  www.ServiceMagic.com
 
3. sparky252 (7)   ranked 4,670 out of 8,636 in cooking   4 years ago

What the previous post said is true cast iron is a much better pan,although there are some expensive pans of other metals,but cast iron is my choice nothing like an egg cooked in cast iron.

Aluminum Railings Simple-Quick-Low Cost Installation. Easy to Maintain Handrail System  www.Hollaender.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 92/100. rocketj1 (2435)   ranked 6 out of 8,636 in cooking   4 years ago

They are currently wondering if teflon coated pans are harming us. If your pan has scratches or is peeling at all, they are recommending tossing them away. I have heard that cast iron and stainless steel pans are the best as far as there not being any leakage into our foods. Cast iron gives off a little iron but we need iron in our systems. Stainless steel does not leak at all . I'm not sure about aluminum. I use aluminum foil all the time and I've heard some similar rumors about foil too.

As far as heat dispersal, the steel and iron pans disperse the heat more evenly to your food causing more even cooking and less burning. Glass is bad for that and I think aluminum and teflon are not as good either.

New: Aluminum Fence -57% Aluminum Fence at bargain prices: Compare offers and save up to 57%!  www.Aluminum-Fence.news72.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 85/100. camomom (3575)   ranked 999 out of 8,636 in cooking   4 years ago

I have used all different types of pans and I don't like cast iron at all. I don't know the difference but I don't like using them. My favorite is teflon.

Cast Iron Looking For Cast Iron? Find It Nearby With Local.com!  Local.com
 
sponsors
New: Aluminum Fence -57%
Aluminum Fence at bargain prices: Compare offers and save up to 57%!
www.Aluminum-Fence.news72.com

Cast Iron
Looking For Cast Iron? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com

Super cheap Aluminum Pans
Aluminum Pans at Best-Price.com! Over 6.000 shops& 23 Mil products.
www.best-price.com/Aluminum-Pans

similar discussions
Do You Cook with Cast Iron Pans?
I recently was invited to dinner and the cook used cast iron pans. The meal was delicious and she...
What type of cookware do you use?
I bought my wife several non stick frying pans for Christmas, her pots are stainless steal. I got...
How do you clean cast iron pans???
My friend just asked me how to clean dried on food out of a cast iron pans. I don't cook in them or...
My politically incorrect and racist metaphor, according to a friend
I have often used the expression "that's the pot calling the kettle black", one of my friends...
cast iron pans
How many of you cook with cast iron pans? I just brought a new one and it said it was seasoned, but...
Do you like cooking with cast iron?
I love cat iron. I have several pieces in two different varieties. I have techniques cast iron...
I need the new Cookware, which one better Non Stick or Stainless Steel?
This morning I cooked some eggs for my kids breakfast. The cookware that I have in her right now is...
When cooking which do you prefer non stick teflon or cast iron classic pans?
I recently purchased an old style classic cast iron pan, and it cooks like a dream, unlike the...
Do you use your cast iron skillets?
It occurred to me that I still have a couple of cast iron skillets tucked away under the cupboard....
Removing rust & Seasoning an Iron Skillet...
I need to know how to remove rust and then season an iron skillet. Can anyone tell me how to do...
sponsors
New: Aluminum Fence -57%
Aluminum Fence at bargain prices: Compare offers and save up to 57%!
www.Aluminum-Fence.news72.com
Cast Iron
Looking For Cast Iron? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com
Super cheap Aluminum Pans
Aluminum Pans at Best-Price.com! Over 6.000 shops & 23 Mil products.
www.best-price.com/Aluminum-Pans
Now: Aluminum Pans -63%
Compare prices now and save up to 63% on great value Aluminum Pans!
www.Aluminum-Pans.best-deal.com
aluminum railing
View 10,000 images of aluminum railing
Look4Design.com
Cookie Sheets for Cooks
Chefs Knives & Sharpeners, Butcher blocks.
ww.chefdepot.com
RailingWorks by FSI
Cable, glass, picket & decorative aluminum railing systems.
www.fsihp.com/railing
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.