sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Why would someone let a cat outside that has been declawed?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 98/100. moneymommy (1824)   ranked 154 out of 5,815 in cats 4 years ago

This is annoying someone in my town has a cat that was declawed and they let him outside. Don'T you think he might get hurt? I would think he wouldn't be able to defend himself. What do you think?

 

cats
sponsors
Local Coupons
1 ridiculously huge coupon a day. Save 50-90% on your city's best!
www.Groupon.com

Cat Breed Info A to Z
From experts at Cat Fancy magazine. Sign up for the free newsletter!
www.CatChannel.com

Ask a Cat Vet Online Now
8 Veterinarians Are Online! Ask a Question, Get an Answer ASAP.
JustAnswer.com/Cat/Symptoms

maezee (8880) response was accepted on 2/5/2009.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  cat defense, cats, declawed, cat, cats without claws
 
1. myLot reputation of 90/100. maezee (8880)   ranked 426 out of 5,815 in cats   4 years ago

I agree with you. I have a friend who has a de-clawed cat, and lets him go outside. I've asked her in the past, too, why she lets him go out - knowing that he could get hurt by other animals - and she says her family lets him out because "he has back-claws". This is the most absurd thing I've heard! I don't think a cat can defend themselves using their back claws.

I agree with you 100%. I wish these people would either NOT have their cats de-clawed, or keep them as indoor cats! It's unfair to the cats who have to face the big, wide world (or back-yard) with no means of self-defense.


myLot reputation of 93/100. mnflower (1050)   ranked 677 out of 5,815 in cats  4 years ago

well I have to totally disagree with you I have 3 female cats all declawed they have there back claws and believe me they can defend themselves just fine, I have seen it and it is very healthy for your cat to go outside to get some fresh air. My cats can catch birds and the whole thing with being declawed so no it is not absurbed my vet tells me i have some of the healthest cats he has seen..


myLot reputation of 90/100. dvmurphy (230)   ranked 367 out of 5,815 in cats  4 years ago

I used to live on a dead end road with a fence between our neighborhood and the local salvage yard. The owners of the yard threw out their declawed manz cat when my kids were little and the neighborhood named him Stubby. Well Stubby may have been declawed but that old boy ran the salvage yard and ruled the neighborhood for more than ten years. He chased down and beat the tar out of other cats who had claws and jumped on the back of the dogs and rode rodeo all the way down the street if a dog stepped out of line. Declawed or not he was one tough old cat.

Local Coupons 1 ridiculously huge coupon a day. Save 50-90% on your city's best!  www.Groupon.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 96/100. fasttalker (2195)   ranked 1,275 out of 5,815 in cats   4 years ago

I have never understood why people allow them outside. I don't like the whole idea of declawing them myself but I had a cat one time that was declawed (before I got her) and I never let her outside. The probelm is they have no defense if something does happen. Which is my reason for being against it in the first place. But a friend of mine had her declawed and when she had her baby she didn't want the cat anymore so I took her.
She lived for 7 years in my house and never one time did she go outside. She probably wouldn't have known how to act anyway! LOL

Cat Breed Info A to Z From experts at Cat Fancy magazine. Sign up for the free newsletter!  www.CatChannel.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 75/100. raxxie (106)   ranked 2,107 out of 5,815 in cats   4 years ago

The whole declawing thing is terrible! Cats need their claws so people should take time to educate cats or stop having cats at home if they can't train them and hate their scratch habit.
I vote for training!


myLot reputation of 90/100. dvmurphy (230)   ranked 367 out of 5,815 in cats  4 years ago

I had my male cat nuetured and front paws declawed eight yrs ago. I had never had a cat declawed before but no matter what I did he tore up my house, furniture and rugs with his claws. The vet told me that declawing him would be the best option.

Ask a Cat Vet Online Now 8 Veterinarians Are Online! Ask a Question, Get an Answer ASAP.  JustAnswer.com/Cat/Symptoms
 
4. myLot reputation of 93/100. SukiSmiles (1544)   ranked 1,907 out of 5,815 in cats   4 years ago

I agree. If you decided to declaw your cat, keep him/her inside. The cat might get hurt, might not be able to defend himself, or climb out of a tree to get away from another animal.

Puppy Love Pet Spa Dog & Cat Grooming  www.PuppyLovePetSpa.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 96/100. luvstochat (6696)   ranked 159 out of 5,815 in cats   4 years ago

When I was discussing getting my cats declawed with the vet she told me that they can still run up trees but they need their front claws in a fight. We decided to not get our cats declawed even though they do not go outside just in case they would happen to get out someday I want them to have all the protection they can get.

Frontline Plus Flea&Tick for Dogs and Cats. Save Big! Low Prices Starting at $26.99  channeladvisor.com/ThriftyVet
 
6. kellycat (45)   ranked 1,117 out of 5,815 in cats   4 years ago

I do not think declawed cats should be let outside!!! They are less able to defend themselves. Cats do not have to be outside to be happy and content. None of my 7 cats goes outside. My one female is declawed (she came to me that way. Back claws do count for some protection, but not enough. I don't think declawing should be done. There are ways of training your cat not to scratch like making sure they have their own furniture to scratch on. Rub catnip on a scratching post they will love it. Declawing is a surgical procedure where the toes are amputated, yes toes are cut off at the first joint or knuckle. Many people belive that it is merely cutting the nails or pulling the nails out, but you must take the first joint of their toes off or the nails will just grow back. This is very painful and recovery is bloody and long. It hurts them to walk on their feet and sometimes takes months to heal. I worked for vets for the last 20 years and have seen some very painful recoveries. Please try every option before declawing!!!

Bartonella Test for cats A veterinarian can test your cat with a simple blood test.  www.natvetlab.com
 
7. ShadoCat (79)   4 years ago

I don't know.

My Mother had our second cat declawed when I was a kid (and didn't get a vote). She did OK outside. I'd say she was alpha cat for at least a 1 block radius.

I once saw another cat in our yard about 25 feet (8m) from our cat. She ran at that cat full tilt, opening her mouth at the last moment and hit it broadside. She knocked it about 1.5 feet back with that stunt. When the other cat made it back to its feet, it scrammed.

She was also a very good hunter; catching birds, rodents and lizards.

In another incident, I saw our cat climb 11 feet of tamarack tree (10" diameter, no branches for the first 20 feet) to get up onto the back porch. *That* had me boggled for a few....

Top Rated Veterinarians Need Top Rated Local Veterinarians?  yellowpages.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 93/100. loveyevi (361)   ranked 2,177 out of 5,815 in cats   4 years ago

I agree with you, cats who have been declawed should not be let outside. I don't think a cat would be able to survive on her own without claws. Especially if she was raised as an inside cat at first.

Once my cat ran away for about three weeks and we couldn't find her anywhere. In her whole 8 years of being alive she had never been outside before and I didnt think she would make it, but the whole time I was thinking thank goodness we hadnt gotten her declawed because at least she had a chance then. A neighbor finally found her a few blocks away and she had a broken leg and a few scratches, so goodness knows what kind of stuff she got herself into, but I strongly believe that the fact she had claws helped her survive.


myLot reputation of 98/100. moneymommy (1824)   ranked 154 out of 5,815 in cats  4 years ago

Its just way to dangerous to let them out like that they where not made that way. They need there claws to defend themselves.

CAT to Blow Up in 2012? Don't trade CAT until you get our trusted free weekly trading advice!  www.TheBestNewsletters.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 73/100. fifileigh (3300)   ranked 858 out of 5,815 in cats   4 years ago

yeah. that is not right. the declawed cat will mostly like die soon. it cant hand itself in society like the clawed cats who can climb and defend themselves. my late cat was declawed but she was always indoors.
my current cat has claws but he is still indoors. i think once a cat goes outside they will become more wild because it learns to be wild in order to survive outside. while the indoor cat is more spoiled and sheltered, and used to the indoor life.

cat health Find cat health Online. Free Shipping $50 on 100,000 Items!  Target.com/FreeShipping
 
10. myLot reputation of 99/100. ElicBxn (24664)   ranked 2 out of 5,815 in cats   4 years ago

A few of my rescues have been declawed.

We have reason to believe that one was actually put outside by a boyfriend (hopefully an EX-boyfriend.) You can read his story here: http://www.mylot.com/w/discussions/1273251.aspx

Pet Toys Looking For Pet Toys? Find It Nearby With Local.com!  Local.com
 
sponsors
Puppy Love Pet Spa
Dog& Cat Grooming
www.PuppyLovePetSpa.com

Frontline Plus Flea&Tick
for Dogs and Cats. Save Big! Low Prices Starting at $26.99
channeladvisor.com/ThriftyVet

Bartonella Test for cats
A veterinarian can test your cat with a simple blood test.
www.natvetlab.com

sponsors
Puppy Love Pet Spa
Dog & Cat Grooming
www.PuppyLovePetSpa.com
Frontline Plus Flea&Tick
for Dogs and Cats. Save Big! Low Prices Starting at $26.99
channeladvisor.com/ThriftyVet
Bartonella Test for cats
A veterinarian can test your cat with a simple blood test.
www.natvetlab.com
Top Rated Veterinarians
Need Top Rated Local Veterinarians?
yellowpages.com
CAT to Blow Up in 2012?
Don't trade CAT until you get our trusted free weekly trading advice!
www.TheBestNewsletters.com
cat health
Find cat health Online. Free Shipping $50 on 100,000 Items!
Target.com/FreeShipping
Pet Toys
Looking For Pet Toys? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.