sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

New Media v. Old Media email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 36/100. Laurie1986 (285)   ranked 5,341 out of 37,940 in life2 months ago

It's odd that we've reached a point where something as new and innovative as the television is lumped into "old media," but with the birth of social networking and the pervasiveness of the Internet, it seems to be the case. Blogging, along with sites like Twitter and Facebook are quickly becoming the fastest ways to get news and information, but with such speed--and amateur journalism--comes problems with accuracy. Blogs like The Huffington Post have stolen the prize from more traditional media outlets when it comes to how quickly stories break, but the sheer volume of blogs and Twitter users sometimes makes it tough to get a reliable source and to verify information.

New media, along with a poor economy that's causing newspapers to get thinner and to increase layoffs, is forcing journalism to re-evaluate its definition.

How do you feel about this? What are your primary sources of media, and on which side of the debate do you fall? I personally lean heavily in the direction of new media, but I'm still glued to CNN and I still value the traditional newspaper.

Weigh in! Do bloggers have too much power, or not enough?

By the way, there are tons of great discussions about this at Mediaite.com, if you're as much of a media and news junkie as I am.:)

 
 
life
sponsors
Buy Washington Wizards Tickets
Buy Washington Wizards tickets last minute. Discount prices.
www.lastminutetickets4less.com

Young Frankenstein in Washington D.C.
See the musical Dec. 15-Jan. 10 at the Opera House! Get tickets here.
Kennedy-Center.org

Used Honda CR-V at Yahoo!
Certified Used Cars in Washington, DC. Shop for a Honda Used Car.
www.honda.com/yahoo

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  media, blogs, newspapers, new media, old media
 
1. myLot reputation of 74/100. anna728 (579)   ranked 10,940 out of 37,940 in life   2 months ago

Things are (/have been) changing an awful lot. It's definitely true that accuracy suffers as the prevalence as blogs and whatnot increases. Then again, there is something to be said for having different perspectives, as well as the speed and convenience of such things. That said, it's still good to have some "old media", established, trusted sources such as CNN or The New York Times when looking for reliable information. I also think that some people who only read certain blogs, or listen to certain pundits are doing themselves a disservice by only strengthening the biases they already had, whether founded or not. At least if you watch mainstream new stations (whether you think they have a bias or not) that is at leas much closer to neutral, than, say a political blog would be. It's probably best to have a good mix of both.


myLot reputation of 36/100. Laurie1986 (285)   ranked 5,341 out of 37,940 in life  2 months ago

That's how I feel, too. Honestly, even the lines between what*is* new and old media are so blurry...The New York Times, for example, derives its main profits from the website now. It's not from the newspaper anymore. I'm guessing it's the same for CNN, or they wouldn't be plugging the website so hard, plus they set up www.ac360.com for Anderson Cooper a few years ago and they have a nightly live blog (well, nightly during the week--he doesn't do weekends anymore) and they encourage people to join in because every click they get is like a cash register going "ca-ching" because of the advertising bucks.

I'm still in love with the speed of information we get from the web...I mean, news stories are*legitimately* breaking on Twitter now. It's crazy.

But the concern about professionalism decreasing--and with it, media responsibility--is a valid one. I'm so fascinated to see what the future brings.

Here's a really good column you might be interested in from Mediaite, wherein the columnist explores how captured journalists overseas should remind us what the press is really for.

http://www.mediaite.com/mnudm


myLot reputation of 36/100. Laurie1986 (285)   ranked 5,341 out of 37,940 in life  2 months ago

Hmm, why didn't that format? Let me try it this way:

www.mediaite.com/mnudm


myLot reputation of 74/100. anna728 (579)   ranked 10,940 out of 37,940 in life  2 months ago

Hmm sounds interesting...


myLot reputation of 65/100. anniepa (9153)   ranked 1,655 out of 37,940 in life  2 months ago

Thanks, Laurie, I read the article and it was very interesting and made some very good points.

Annie

Buy Washington Wizards Tickets Buy Washington Wizards tickets last minute. Discount prices. www.lastminutetickets4less.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 93/100. justbeingtiffany (965)   ranked 3,391 out of 37,940 in life   2 months ago

i agree with everything that you have said. you are a very great writer! this should be a blog.Thats why when i read a blog about something on the news in a social networking sites i leave a open mind that some or most of this might not be true. wikipedia which i thought was so legit it turns out that any one can make a wikipedia page. and i feel that the real news has to spice it up if they want more people to watch and get interested. i don't think many teens these days watch the news.


myLot reputation of 36/100. Laurie1986 (285)   ranked 5,341 out of 37,940 in life  2 months ago

You're very sweet; thank you!

You bring up a really good point about the news spicing things up to keep people interested. That's what Walter Cronkite used to call "infotainment" and it's a big problem with all the networks but I think FOX and HLN are the worst offenders.

I didn't watch much news when I was a teen; I became a junkie in college (ha!). So I think you're right that teenagers aren't that interested...I did read the newspaper and read some news online, but I didn't become totally obsessed with news and media until I was 18 or 19...the tsunami got me hooked on Anderson Cooper's reporting, and then Hurricane Katrina brought not only his individual career, but modern media as a whole, to a completely different level.

Young Frankenstein in Washington D.C. See the musical Dec. 15-Jan. 10 at the Opera House! Get tickets here. Kennedy-Center.org
 
3. myLot reputation of 70/100. lcainiao (184)   ranked 4,129 out of 37,940 in life   2 months ago

It's a great topic. The old media and the new media both have its advantage and weakness. For me, I am working as a computer technical engineer. I usually stay on the computer 14 hours a day. The most information I got just through the new media, web, glog, BBS etc. However, I always read newspaper or watch TV at home. I am not fond of using computer out of office.


myLot reputation of 36/100. Laurie1986 (285)   ranked 5,341 out of 37,940 in life  2 months ago

I totally understand why if you spend 14 hours a day doing it for work! I do about ten hours at home, and as much as I love it, it seems like a lot...I also am on the computer constantly at my library job, so I'm pretty much glued.

Used Honda CR-V at Yahoo! Certified Used Cars in Washington, DC. Shop for a Honda Used Car. www.honda.com/yahoo
 
4. myLot reputation of 65/100. anniepa (9153)   ranked 1,655 out of 37,940 in life   2 months ago

I guess since I AM kind of old I should stick up for old media here, right...lol? Actually, I still DO like to read an old-fashioned newspaper and a few of my favorite news magazines, although most of them are also available online. When it comes to TV I rarely watch any news on regular network TV except for the Sunday morning shows now and then. It's no longer necessary for us to wait until 6:30 every night to get the evening news since we have the 24/7 cables news networks. I like CNN some of the time but I mainly watch MSNBC, especially in prime time during the week. Fox News is NOT news, as far as I'm concerned. I get "yelled at" here if I use any of the more liberal blogs as sources but there are a lot who link to WND and FreeRepublic among other right-wing sites. I think the problem with any of the blog sites is that much of what is posted hasn't been confirmed. There is a lot that true online but there are also a lot of lies and rumors and, unfortunately some people don't know how to tell the difference and some just believe what they want to believe and discount what they don't like. I think it IS important that we always have media organizations who are willing to spend the money and take the risk of sending real investigative reporters to cover the big stories nationally and internationally.

Annie


myLot reputation of 36/100. Laurie1986 (285)   ranked 5,341 out of 37,940 in life  2 months ago

Sorry this took so long--I typed a huge response earlier this afternoon, then my browser crashed and I had to leave for work.

I'll try to recap. I do think that anybody who quotes or links FreeRepublic as an unbiased resource is delusional. I have never seen so many fringe right-wing nuts in one place. That said, I would never make the claim that HuffPo is unbiased, but their fact-checking is good. Arianna does not mess around. She's a professional.

Drudge Report is a good way to see what the conservatives are pulling from the wire because it's news aggregation without original content, and most of the conservatives who are plugged in to web-based media are checking Drudge every day. Politico is one of those who claims to be unbiased and has a clear (right-wing) agenda that is no secret to anyone--particularly since they recently got themselves caught up in a scandal in which they were copying and pasting text from GOP press releases and passing it off as original reporting. Not good. Leftist as they are--and again, at least they admit it--HuffPo would never be caught dead lifting stuff from the DNC and reporting it as fact. If that happened on Arianna's watch, we'd hear the aftermath from our homes.

You make a strong point about people using the Internet to gain access to information...and not knowing how to use the Internet. If they're believing small-time blogs--or even big-time ones who are irresponsible, like Politico--that's a problem, and if they're getting information from unsourced tweets without verification, that's a problem. Citizen journalism is just that; there is more responsibility on the individual citizen when it comes to keeping the quality of the information out there up to snuff. I love that it's on the rise, but we do have to acknowledge the lack of professionalism that comes with it, and the fact that this does allow for misinformation to become more of a problem.

12 Hrs Emergency Passports When Trust & Time Count, we offer Solutions 24/7, Was/DC-866-727-7362 www.PassportDocs.com
 
sponsors
12 Hrs Emergency Passports
When Trust& Time Count, we offer Solutions 24/7, Was/DC-866-727-7362
www.PassportDocs.com

Local Insurance Agents
Find local insurance agencies in Washington DC at YellowPages.com ®.
Www.YellowPages.com/WashingtonDC

Washington Background Check - $14.95
Washington Background Check. Statewide felony and misdemeanor records since 1997. 3-state search $29.95 or our 39-state search for $34.95. Quick results. Easy online ordering.
www.backgroundferret.com

similar discussions
The 2nd Worst Country...this is sick....
That has been considered Dangerous for the Media. I cannot believe this people, thanks a lot...
Feedom of speech is very improtant. Media is a very powerful .I am right?
Media should definitely be responsible for the content of all their news and features. It is true...
Obama tries to BAN Fox News from White House media pool. EPIC FAIL!
Welcome to Obama's new world order. Now he's trying to ban Fox News from being part of the White...
Do you like the way Christians are portrayed in the Media?
To me it seems Christians are most often portrayed as narrow minded lunatics. Has anyone else...
Fact-checking the fact checkers
I was actually going to start a thread the other day asking "Since when did they start fact...
Violence, gore, the media, and us
Not too long before, a good friend of mine showed me a short video clip (well, not too short...
Where do you go for your news?
So I'm doing a project for my media writing class and its all about where people go for their news...
Media - sensitive or insensitive
I was watching television today - our state's chief minister died in a helicopter crash, along with...
do you think that the famous role models today are good for young people?
i think the famous role model are good people towards the young people
Race should not matter but the media thinks so
I just found out that Hodges the leader of the Criminal Minds show has been told by his superior to...
sponsors
12 Hrs Emergency Passports
When Trust & Time Count, we offer Solutions 24/7, Was/DC-866-727-7362
www.PassportDocs.com
Local Insurance Agents
Find local insurance agencies in Washington DC at YellowPages.com ®.
Www.YellowPages.com/WashingtonDC
Washington Background Check - $14.95
Washington Background Check. Statewide felony and misdemeanor records since 1997. 3-state search $29.95 or our 39-state search for $34.95. Quick results. Easy online ordering.
www.backgroundferret.com
Kimpton Hotels And
Find top-rated Restaurants near you Try Citysearch® now
Washingtondc.Citysearch.com
Looking to Sell in DC? professional home staging
Home Staging in Washington DC Area including Maryland and Virginia.
www.stagingdesigndc.com
Insurance Captive Solutions
The Taft Companies, an Insurance Captive and consulting group, provides captive management in Bermuda, Washington DC, South Carolina and Montana.
www.taftcos.com
Vein Treatment - No. VA
Learn About New Treatments for Veins at McLean Vein Center.
DC.Vein-Treatment.com
Hotel in Fairfax, VA
Official Site- Hyatt Fair Lakes. Across from Fair Oaks Mall. Convenient access to Dulles Airport and Washington DC. Book Online for Hyatt.com's Rate Guarantee.
fairlakes.hyatt.com
Professional Babysitters
Find trustworthy babysitters in Washington DC. Free background checks.
www.Care.com/childcare
Mini Storage Facilities Washington
Free Truck Rental with move in & boxes only $.99. Reserve risk free.
www.MiniuStorage.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.