sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

when a movie is based on a true story but then alters the end... email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 96/100. moonlitmagikchild (7146)   ranked 21 out of 11,393 in watching movies3 months ago

it drives me nuts! i mean i have watched several that are based on a true story and not "inspired" (which pretty much means nothing) and it drives me crazy when at the end of the movie they show who the killer is and everything when in real life they dont have a clue! i mean i would rather them NOT have an ending than lead people to thinking it was some one that who knows if they existed or not!

do you like false endings to true stories? just so you can get the closure that they got him even if they havent? or do you like it to be real and end saying "dunno" so that you dont research it and am swayed to think some one is guilty that may or may not exist in the first place!

i just wonder about the people that might fit the profile of who the movie says did it that may have been around the area. i mean if they do have similar people isnt that wrong to make the movie point in their direction? im hoping they are just making up some one to pin it on in the movie that has no way of being like anyone in real life..

 
 
watching movies
sponsors
Auto Glass Repair Service
There is a Lot Riding Behind Your Windshield! Get a Quote Online.
www.RoyalGlass.DanMattMedia.com

United Kingdom Passport Service in US
Urgent Experts Handling, On time solutions. Call us for instructions.
www.passportdocs.com

Hyattsville Janitorial Cleaning Services
MaidMagic.net is your source for residential and commercial cleaning needs. Serving Hyattsville, MD and surrounding areas. Look up to us for a clean and tidy home or business.
www.maidmagic.net

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  movies, true story, true stories, killers, alphabet killer
 
1. myLot reputation of 99/100. jules67 (1907)   ranked 2,758 out of 11,393 in watching movies   3 months ago

It is really crazy that they alter what is real. It would not be called a true story if they make-up scenes. Some do it for cinematic purposes to attract viewership. They do this so that they could earn money. The sad part is it does not anymore reflect the lives of the personalities involved.


myLot reputation of 96/100. moonlitmagikchild (7146)   ranked 21 out of 11,393 in watching movies  3 months ago

yeah i mean i expect for some of them to really play up some stuff or add a little drama here and there to make it more interesting but when they show in the movie who the killer is and he just gets away but then say "they never figured out who the killer was" at the end and i am like "they just did! they said fred!" grrr drives me nuts! its like ok forget the last couple of scenes because obviously they were just crap

Auto Glass Repair Service There is a Lot Riding Behind Your Windshield! Get a Quote Online. www.RoyalGlass.DanMattMedia.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 100/100. dorannmwin (1990)   ranked 3,261 out of 11,393 in watching movies   3 months ago

It's not just the false endings to true stories that drives me nuts, it is also when a movie is based on a book and yet the movie is completely different from the book, that is the other thing that drives me absolutely nutty.
In the case of a true story, I don't think that there should by any allowance of things to be changed. How is it a true story when things are changed. It just doesn't make any sense to me at all.
In the case of a book, I think that there could be some space for a screenwriters interpretation, but I still feel like it should be pretty true to the original written word.


myLot reputation of 96/100. moonlitmagikchild (7146)   ranked 21 out of 11,393 in watching movies  3 months ago

yeah its like they expect the people that read the book to be ok with them butchering it and redoing the whole story

United Kingdom Passport Service in US Urgent Experts Handling, On time solutions. Call us for instructions. www.passportdocs.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 98/100. mentalward (4271)   ranked 30 out of 11,393 in watching movies   3 months ago

I like biographical-type movies but there's one thing I've learned about all of them: Hollywood always spices them up for the ratings. Most "true" stories are only loosely based on true events. I think that, if they were totally true to the story, they would be quite boring, unless you are one of the people whom the story affected in real life. Then, I think, I'd be fuming mad!

I was very curious about Mozart after watching the movie, Amadeus. I got a book from the library about his life and so many of the real facts were far from how the movie portrayed them. Still, a lot of real facts were in the movie, like his crazy laugh, his drinking problem and his death.

I think that the only way to know the REAL story is to read about it in a book. Hollywood is all about profits and they'll do anything to make a real-life story more appealing.


myLot reputation of 96/100. moonlitmagikchild (7146)   ranked 21 out of 11,393 in watching movies  3 months ago

yeah i expect some hyping up and stuff but when they act like the case of a murder was solved in the movie and then it wasnt in real life its like they were just trying to make people feel happy that everything is ok now or something.. if there is a psycho killer on the loose i wanna know and not have some movie bs' stuff to make their movie better etc


myLot reputation of 98/100. mentalward (4271)   ranked 30 out of 11,393 in watching movies  3 months ago

If you want the true facts about something like that, don't expect to see them in any movie. It's sad, I know. Hollywood is full of plastic and glitter and you won't normally see anything "real" coming from there.


myLot reputation of 96/100. moonlitmagikchild (7146)   ranked 21 out of 11,393 in watching movies  3 months ago

well i dont seek out movies for facts but have found several that i go to watch saying that they are fact based then i look up and it turns out the killer was never caught or something and then i get irritated because they convinced you its bob or whatever

Hyattsville Janitorial Cleaning Services MaidMagic.net is your source for residential and commercial cleaning needs. Serving Hyattsville, MD and surrounding areas. Look up to us for a clean and tidy home or business. www.maidmagic.net
 
4. myLot reputation of 97/100. danishcanadian (20419)   ranked 65 out of 11,393 in watching movies   3 months ago

When a movie is based on a true story, I send a friend to see it who has read the book, or heard the story. unless it is 100% historically accurate, and has the same ending, I will not go. When my teacher told me that Titanic was not historicically accurate, I was glad I didn't go see it.


myLot reputation of 96/100. moonlitmagikchild (7146)   ranked 21 out of 11,393 in watching movies  3 months ago

i didnt go see that movie just because there was so much hype over it i figured it wasnt worth it since a lot of movies they rave about i hate lol

Washington Locksmiths Find top-rated Door Repair Services Try Citysearch® now Washingtondc.Citysearch.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 86/100. doglady112 (316)   ranked 3,750 out of 11,393 in watching movies   3 months ago

I like how you think, a true story should always name the person who actually did the crime. I'm wondering what movie you were watching and why you think that the person named was not the actual person? Do you do this for a living? It just sounds like you have experience in this matter.


myLot reputation of 96/100. moonlitmagikchild (7146)   ranked 21 out of 11,393 in watching movies  3 months ago

well i love horror movies and i have had it happen several times.. the latest being the "alphabet killer" movie which i had no idea was based on a true story. well at the end it shows who the killer is (it was one of the characters in the movie.. not gonna give it away) then says at the end that they never figured out who it was that killed the girls.. im like uhh you just showed us who and how he got away!! its like they want us to think that the case is solved so we sleep better at night when if there is a killer out there we should know he is still out there and not have a preconcieved idea on who it is based on who they showed on the movie.. i have no idea what year the case that that movie was based on was so i dont know if its so old that the killer could still be alive or not..

another one was one of the zodiac movies (they made a few but the one with jake gyllenhaal is the one im thinking of i think) they showed him figuring out who it was and running away and then of course its never been solved..

there are more but i cant think of enough of the info to give good examples.. i have a horrible memory and the other ones its been years ago


myLot reputation of 86/100. doglady112 (316)   ranked 3,750 out of 11,393 in watching movies  3 months ago

Wow, sure sounds like your memory is pretty good to me. You know you should get into mystery writing, you seem to have a great knack for it. I'll bet you like suspense movies too. Maybe you could be like a true crime writer, you should try it.

Insurance Captive Solutions The Taft Companies, an Insurance Captive and consulting group, provides captive management in Bermuda, Washington DC, South Carolina and Montana. www.taftcos.com
 
6. Haraaz (70)   ranked 7,634 out of 11,393 in watching movies   3 months ago

Well, it use to be "based" on a true story, not "a totally" true story, if you get what I mean... A base is somehting which is in the ground, where other things get build upon. Like the base of a house for example. So, just cuz the movie is BASED on a true story doesn't mean they can't add some fiction to it.


myLot reputation of 96/100. moonlitmagikchild (7146)   ranked 21 out of 11,393 in watching movies  3 months ago

i expect them to add extra drama to spice it up but not make up an ending when its an open case

DC Area Attractions Find museums, national monuments, historic homes, wineries and more. www.fxva.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 88/100. leeloo (375)   ranked 892 out of 11,393 in watching movies   1 week ago

I agree with you on this generally, with the quick fix solution giving the killer in a nice clean and easily digested package whether true or not. It bugged me more before, now with these movies I always take them with a pinch of salt and if it really intrigues me will go and do the research and find out how much was embellished and why they chose that character to take the fall, normally a made up character that never existed either in real life or books.

There are always exceptions and the most famous of which is the stories of Jack the Ripper, that with pros and cons in relation to their validity give one or other as the culprit, since this is very old and there is no actual proof either way any plausible theory is valid. Then there is another category, like the organized crime stories, where everyone suspects one or other person for the crime, sometimes having confessions but since there is no physical evidence or with cases that are dismissed from court due to lack of evidence it means that only in fiction can those stories have a solution.


myLot reputation of 96/100. moonlitmagikchild (7146)   ranked 21 out of 11,393 in watching movies  1 week ago

yeah jack the ripper i can understand because unless there is a miracle we may never know so at least you can enjoy the hmmm who did it or did this person do it theory

Washington D.C.'S Premier Entertainers D.C.'s Top Comedy Magician Team. Exciting Dove And Stage Illusions. www.speedthro.com
 
sponsors
Washington Locksmiths
Find top-rated Door Repair Services Try Citysearch® now
Washingtondc.Citysearch.com

Insurance Captive Solutions
The Taft Companies, an Insurance Captive and consulting group, provides captive management in Bermuda, Washington DC, South Carolina and Montana.
www.taftcos.com

DC Area Attractions
Find museums, national monuments, historic homes, wineries and more.
www.fxva.com

similar discussions
What movie has made you cry?
Don't be shy people, tell me what movies have made you tear up.. and come on guys I know there is...
Do you always plan to watch the Movie?
Helo Mylot friends this is checkmail and am starting an discussion on movies and its time.Myself I...
Team Edward or Team Jacob?
I know everyone's been talking about this lately, but I wanted to ask this question here since I'm...
What is your favorite movie??
what is your favorite movie??? And can you recommend some good movies which i can watch. I like all...
how do you encourage your man to watch romantic movies?
Hello! How do you encourage your man to watch romantic movies with you? As it is already know fact...
movies are getting nonsense?
movies nowadays have no storylines anymore. all are impossible make believe stories. even in our...
Johnny Depp
I think he is so cute:}Aside him being cute do you think he is like extemely cute or just average...
which movie you like the most and why?
many of us watch movies but some movies touch our heart and are remembered through out the...
How many movies do you see per week?
Well, when it comes to seeing movies, I see a lot of them. Even when I use to go to job, I would...
What is and/or are the best movie(s) in 2009????
I don't think I've watched a lot of movies this year. The only movie that I've watch in the big...
sponsors
Washington Locksmiths
Find top-rated Door Repair Services Try Citysearch® now
Washingtondc.Citysearch.com
Insurance Captive Solutions
The Taft Companies, an Insurance Captive and consulting group, provides captive management in Bermuda, Washington DC, South Carolina and Montana.
www.taftcos.com
DC Area Attractions
Find museums, national monuments, historic homes, wineries and more.
www.fxva.com
Washington D.C.'S Premier Entertainers
D.C.'s Top Comedy Magician Team. Exciting Dove And Stage Illusions.
www.speedthro.com
2005 honda hatchback at Yahoo!
Find Washington, DC area used Honda car dealers and get a free quote.
www.promotions.yahoo.com/honda
Young Frankenstein in Washington D.C.
See the musical Dec. 15-Jan. 10 at the Opera House. Get tickets here.
Kennedy-Center.org
Old Horror Movies
So Good, They'll Make You Scream. Watch Free Full-Length Movies Now.
www.Crackle.com
Find Washington DC Hotel Deals Now
50% 60% 70% Savings And More. More Hotel Deals Than Anywhere Else.
www.dealbase.com
End Of The Spear on DVD
A powerful true story of sacrifice & redemption in the jungles
www.ChristianCinema.com
Travel to Washington DC
Browse the Best Travel Deals to Washington DC. Use Travelzoo.
www.Travelzoo.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.