Do you think brilliance and bigotry are exclusive?
By cripfemme
@cripfemme (7698)
United States
December 13, 2009 11:55pm CST
I would like to think that brilliance and bigotry are exclusive. But sadly this is not the case. Walt Disney was a brilliant animator (this is doubtless) he was also an anti-semitic tool of the media monopoly. Orson Scott Card's Ender series is brilliant beyond my telling. Yet, the man is a rampant homophobe. George Balanchine is great ballet choreographer is misogynistic in terms and leading to anorexia creating.
The deal with bigots (I've found) is to appreciate their work, honor them, but never- if you can help it- give them money. I break this rule in terms of Balanchine and Disney, because you can't often find their work for free. Still, I try to borrow their work from the library. I do this in entirely for Card.
My best girlfriend says that brilliance and bigotry are exclusive. That brilliant people can only be clever, obviously we disagree. What say you, Mylotters?
1 response
@allknowing (153544)
• India
14 Dec 09
When you say 'exclusive' do you mean to say that bigotry and brilliance goes hand in hand? It looks that way but it cannot be as those creative geniuses though look around for those who understand their works and hence appear to be bigots, at the same time the fact that the whole world recognises them proves otherwise. Why point a finger only at them we all are bigots in some way or the other. Here I am trying to level with those who I feel are intelletcually matched!!
@cripfemme (7698)
• United States
15 Dec 09
No, I didn't mean that. I meant can you appreciate the work of someone you disagree with politically. I don't like ant9-semistism, or homophobia, or racism (especially). However, I enjoy the work of Balanchine, Disney, and Card, even if I hate their politics. The way I make my value coincide with liking their work is simply to not pay money to them if I can avoid it. If someone is horribly wrong (pedophile, murder, rape...) I like I would stop liking their work no matter how brilliant they might be. Not of the people in this discussion are that way. It's mostly attitudinal and they don't injure human beings.


