Should We Just Send Half of the 11 Home Tonight and Shorten the Season?

This week's performances were pretty dreadful. I was just wondering what were most of them thinking. Song choices were horrible. Arrangements were all over the place. The talent that we thought we saw during Hollywood Week was non-existent. It was bad. Though I love the girl and her personality, based on tonight's performance I'm gonna have to say Paige will be going home. The girl with the big voice seems to be slipping away. She picked a good song, tried to deliver it in a big way but failed. Sad to say.

I agree with the point on Crystal being the most deserving winners. But I also think that she'll face some stiff competitions and one of it being Siobhan because I think if Crystal is the best, Siobhan is probably a close second. Yeah! A hairline second place to Crystal! And also, Katie is undeniably a good singer as well. Imagine if she would to step it up and improve on her pitching, well, she might just be on par or if not close to being just as great as Crystal and Siobhan. So I think its still too early to make any prediction. As for the worst, I think its definitely Paige and Tim based on this week performance. But however, I think Tim should be the one going home instead because he actually don't deserve to even be in the Top 12. Paige at least have a great voice and if she stays a while longer she might be able to proof it.

YES! Send them home! Honestly I don't think anyone has star power yet, but some have potential. I really don't care WHO goes home, I more care who stays :) I'm in a fantasy AI league and my picks that are still in the game are - Aaron, Siobhan, Michael and Didi. I thought all did well last night, even if they weren't perfect, so hope they stay. Aaron really has potential b/c he has a natural good voice. Siobhan could become a star if she gets her voice under control. I hope to see Paige gone tonight b/c honestly - she was AWFUL. I wondered if she had ever sang before! I imagine Tim and Andrew won't go anywhere b/c of their fan base. I don't like Crystal - but we don't have to get into that b/c I know I'm in the minority :)

Last night was bad. I don't know why everyone hates Tim so much, I like him. He didn't choose a good song last night, true, but he used the stage more than anyone else has and he was obviously having a good time. Paige...poor girl. She just seems to get worse every week but she was so good at the beginning. Andrew wasn't great either, I agree. I seriously believe it will be Paige. If she makes it, it will be a miracle for her.

I really don't like anyone to be honest with you. Would love to see Tim go but I have a feeling it will be Paige. Casey is another one who is so over rated never like him since his first audition. I bet the judges are like can we start over from Hollywood week and pick over. We were screwed up and picked the wrong people.