Should the Philippine government regulate foreign artists' concerts?

@lealuvy2j (1986)
Philippines
January 5, 2011 12:03am CST
I was watching the news earlier and I saw Kuh Ledesma calling for regulation on the frequency of foreign artists' concerts being held in the Philippines. She says that regulation protects the interests of local artists. I completely disagree with her because Pinoys should have the choice on who they want to watch whether it is local or foreign. I also think local artists should look at the situation as a challenge to their artistry because we Filipinos go to the concerts of our fellow Pinoys who are really talented. Remember, the Apo Hiking Society, EHeads?? Foreign artists did not hinder us from supporting and going to their concerts so this whole thing of regulation is really pointless. How about you? What do you think about this?
2 people like this
8 responses
@rsa101 (40976)
• Philippines
7 Jan 11
I agree I think we are an open economy and we could not stop foreign artist from performing in our country at a certain point in a year. They can choose whatever or whenever they want to perform in our country. I guess the local artist should find some ways to lure the locals from watching them. That is what we call competition.
1 person likes this
@rsa101 (40976)
• Philippines
10 Jan 11
Well I think that may be possible. The only regulation that you could do in there is taxation actually. You could not stopped them from performing because that may look unfair for the foreign artists. But I disagree that the local artist would not be taxed I guess they can ask for a lower tax but they should pay for it as well. As good citizens of this country we should always contribute something to the government a portion of our income.
1 person likes this
@lealuvy2j (1986)
• Philippines
10 Jan 11
I have heard recently that Ogie Alcasid, the president of the OPM Artists is clamoring for no taxes for Filipino Concerts and higher taxes for foreign concerts. I guess what he is asking for is pretty fair if he just said, no taxes for Filipino concerts but foreign artists should pay their appropriate taxes and not necessarily higher.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
6 Jan 11
I heard this news too and on that certain morning show, it was Ogie Alcasid and Gary V who are saying to regulate concerts by foreign artists. Gary V commented that, maybe, one of the reason that many Filipinos go to concerts by foreign singers is because they are rarely seen by their fans. On the other hand, local artists are always seen on TV shows, gigs, and other out of town shows. I guess Gary V's lamentations has some grain of truth. We often see our local artist sing on shows like SOP and ASAP every weekend. With this thing in mind, why would I be elated to see their concerts if I will just see another version of ASAP or SOP at places like Araneta Coliseum? I would rather save my money for concerts of foreign artists and watch Gary V and Ogie at local TV.
@lealuvy2j (1986)
• Philippines
6 Jan 11
I would still shell out money to see Urbandub, the Eheads or APO. I guess it is just a matter of targeting the right audience and if the music is any good. If I see a singer on TV all the time, I would still go to his/her concert if I really like their songs. Gary V has a point though but it is still about making good music. If Filipino artists do that, I don't think there would be a problem if foreign artists come and go in our country.
• Philippines
7 Jan 11
Yeah. It is time for the our local artists to band together and be serious at uplifting the state of Philippine Music Industry. I read a comment on this thread wherein the commenter lamented that our music artists just kept on doing covers and rehash of old musics. I guess it is time for them to create original music that truly captures the heart of the Filipinos. Our artists are great in craft and the people are responsive to their music. Regulation is not the key because even if they raise the taxes of foreign concerts but they still dish out crappy music, then the people will still flock to foreign concerts.
1 person likes this
• United States
5 Jan 11
Do you want your wife to sleep with the mayor? I think they should not regulate foreign artists' concerts because Filipino local artists aren't as good but rather guide them as equals as they are artists too just like the ones in the country. They are all just artists but when you do have foreigners you treat them nice, why? I think the government shouldn't force-feed Filipinos with Filipino musicians because that is desperation.
1 person likes this
@louievill (28846)
• Philippines
5 Jan 11
hi friend, I agree with you every step of the way but sorry I'm a little bit low I.Q. today, what's the wife and the mayor got to do with the discussion?
1 person likes this
@lealuvy2j (1986)
• Philippines
5 Jan 11
Hi Gorillafootprints925, I was also taken aback by the whole wife sleeping with the mayor thing. lol. Anyway, I agree with what you said that the government should not force feed Filipinos with the music of Filipino Musicians. It is downright outrageous. Though I believe that we should be support OPM, forcing everyone to like OPM is somehow an insult to Filipino Talent.
• Philippines
6 Jan 11
Hello Lealuv, The reality is that, people will like the foreign music better since we are more exposed to them in a sense. well, i would believe her if she is in the Philippines and helping the OPM and the Government. but the thing is, she is also living in the US having that greenier pasture thing so for me, i disagreed with her opinion. I believe Filipino people liking the music industry is the effort of the artist to make unique and catchy music to attract pinoys and not force them to do so. this is entertainment and we do have democracy by the way.
@lealuvy2j (1986)
• Philippines
6 Jan 11
They say music is the universal language so whether a song comes from another country or ours, a good song is still a good song. I agree that regulating music just because it is foreign would not help us appreciate OPM more. Music is a kind of art and art is pretty subjective and even if colonial mentality is a trait very common in Pinoys when an artist makes good music, it can transcend nationalities.
@greenpeas (998)
• Philippines
5 Jan 11
That is just her opinion. I think it is her knee-jerk reaction out of fear that her concert wherein she teams up with the Hitmakers (a group of oldies singers like Rico Puno) will be affected by the concert of Taylor Swift because they are very near each other in terms of date. If that was the case then that is hilarious since the people who will watch Kuh Ledesma and the Hitmakers will certainly be mostly their avid fans who knows their classic songs and most likely were matured and likes the 70s-80s music, while people who will watch the Taylor Swift concert will be mostly also her fans and people who are in the teenager and young adults bracket. My own opinion is that there is no need to regulate foreign artist doing concerts in our country. On the contrary, we should allow them to come since it will generate more revenue for our country. What should be done will be to use part of the taxes collected from their concerts to develop our music industry. Implementing stifling measures to prevent the freedom of choosing what music, movie or art that people will consume will likely only backfire, since it has been proven that the more you make something unlawful, the more people will crave for it.
1 person likes this
@lealuvy2j (1986)
• Philippines
6 Jan 11
I totally agree. The music that both artists make caters to different markets so why do they need to fret? My opinion with the whole thing is that instead of imposing this regulation thing, why not just make better music? A lot OPM Artists still make it despite the competition from foreign artists. I also suggest that TV stations should also promote our Pinoy singers not just the actors in order for the music industry to truly flourish.
• Philippines
5 Jan 11
I think this is just a matter of scheduling in order not to affect our local artists. Maybe she's afraid that less income will be going to her own concert or other Filipino concerts. Our Filipino artists are also having their concerts abroad, did they experienced this abroad? This is just also for business sake, this is in demand now with many Filipinos.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
6 Jan 11
Correct! Our artists also sing abroad and local artists there don't ask their government to collect higher taxes from them. The best thing that they should do is to double their effort to capture the heart of the Filipino people with their music.
1 person likes this
@lealuvy2j (1986)
• Philippines
6 Jan 11
I bet if foreign countries do that to Filipinos, most Pinoys would accuse them of racism. It makes me think if we are guilty of the same thing. It is just that we think so highly of foreigners that we demean our own Filipino talent. It really saddens me that colonial mentality is still present in our own society when I know that the country is flourishing with World-class talent.
@jennbart (1325)
• Philippines
5 Jan 11
I do not agree on this. Filipino artists should start writing ORIGINAL songs first and not re make a song that was re-maked and covered for like 70 times with so many versions. I cant imagine hearing OPM's "PANGAKO" with Gary V, Regine Velasquez,Kuh, the company etc's version all the time or my ears will bleed! I need other songs too. Foreign artists always comes up with different and Original songs that are refreshing to the ears of many. We should also support foreign artsists as they support our artists too!
1 person likes this
@lealuvy2j (1986)
• Philippines
6 Jan 11
I know! I cant understand it either because most of them are really good songwriters as well. It is as if they feel they can please us with mediocrity when we know they can do better. I wish instead of sourgraping, they just make good music and in time even if Foreign artists come and go, they would not be affected.
@louievill (28846)
• Philippines
5 Jan 11
Why do they have to regulate or limit something from the arts that trancends continental and cultural bounderies and barriers?. It's like robbing people the freedom of choosing what they want to see and hear. Guess we have to continue improving ourselves, although it is my honest belief that we are already at par with world standards, if we regulate, then we lose the basis for comparison if we are indeed world class.
@lealuvy2j (1986)
• Philippines
5 Jan 11
Yeah. While I was watching Kuh Ledesma earlier, I wanted to say to her that it is like she believes that foreign artists are better than them because they cannot compete with them. Instead of what they are proposing, why don't they just produce better music and not just sing revivals. I truly believe in Filipino talent, it is a shame that it is so underestimated.