Is Pakistan cricket in a state of denial? Why are they persisting with non-oerfo

@moksha09 (467)
India
March 9, 2011 2:26am CST
Why is Kamran Akmal still the wicket keeper? He has been regularly fluffing chances behind the wicket but their administration feels he is one of their batting mainstays and can compensate with the bat. Like how? By dropping Ross Taylor twice even before he had scored and then missing another stumping chance and then doing nothing with the bat. Kamran , I believe has missed 32 chances in 25 tests, I don't know how many he has missed in ODIs but isn't it time that he be dropped to bring in a better keeper. Abdul Razzack has bowling figures of 21-4- 111-1 and he is batting at no.8 to bolster the batting of Pakistan, why don't they have a better batsman? And he is no opening bowler then why persist with him? Yesterday against NZ he conceded 49 from 4 overs and in the last 4 overs he shared with Akhtar and Rehman Pakistan conceded 92. Quite clearly Pakistan is in a state of denial and may not win another match in this tournament. What do you have to say? I'd be delighted to be proved wrong but I don't see Pakistan winning again, particularly after yesterday's performance against New Zealand? They are shell shocked and in a depressive situation.
1 person likes this
4 responses
@isloooboy (1733)
• United Arab Emirates
9 Mar 11
Well I think he is lucky enough to stay in the team otherwise as per his states are concern which you showed in your analysis he must be sacked long ago right?. If you are following Pakistan Team than you must know about unpredictability of Pakistan Team bating line right? Did you analyse Pakistan this squad for world cup? Bating goes upto number 8 which means only 3 regular bowlers are playing in Pakistan Team. Do not count Afridi and Razzaq as regular bowler they are in the team as all rounder. Even Hafeez is bowling regularly which means Pakistan do not have real bowling power or real powerful bowling attack in this world cup squad just like India dont have. But whole world is blindly thinking Pakistan has bowling power in their hand because of Afridi's good performance. Now if we think Afridi as regular bowler than Pakistan must obtain batting upto number 7 because of batting friendly pitches. So Even I or many other Pakistani Team fan do not want Akmal in the team than it means Pakistan must drop to 6 batsman 4 bowlers and one keeper, right? Now I have one question for you, "How Pakistani Team can get success in this world cup with just 6 batsman when all other teams have their batting line up upto 8 or 9 numbers because of batting pitches? Second please tell me why Pakistan left one power blaster when his openers are not doing well in all 4 matches? Its true Kamran was too much costly in yesterday match but he was good against Sri Lanka. Pakistan Management is not in the state of denial but they tried their best to choose best available option. Look you can never predict about any cricket match because this is game of the day. Some times everything goes in your way and some times everything go against you even you try as hard as you can.
• India
10 Mar 11
You made valid points friend but Kamran but poor against Srilanka too , he missed two stampings of Sangakara and dropped a catch.Pakistan were lucky that they managed to take the wicket of Sangakara after those two misses , otherwise Sanga would have won the match on his own for sure.
@isloooboy (1733)
• United Arab Emirates
10 Mar 11
Look I am not saying he is perfect and can not do mistake but too much critism also effect players form and he is facing this criticizes continuously in last 3 months. I think its our management fault too because he has no facility for practice or any consultation or guide during this whole world cup. He is alone to do whatever he can in this tournament because we have fielding coach bowling coach, one more thing no batting coach too. Our main coach Waqar is also bowling minded, our fielding coach Aqib Javed is also bowler. What kind of respect do you think an bowler give to keeper? If he catch credit goes to bowler, if he drop all fault goes to him, no one is there for him to uplift his moral or show some way or provide any guidance. I think he is already playing in massive pressure also we want good blasting batting from him too. So I think he is the escape goat for our Captain and management because he is an easy target. Although I agree with you regarding his poor performance which is hurting us most of the time but he need some backup too.
@moksha09 (467)
• India
10 Mar 11
That is what I said. Even you are showing symptoms of denial.You are saying no or giving excuses. Unless you accept the reality how can you make changes and improvement. This is not a three match series where a couple of good performances will win you the series. If Akmal is being criticized do you think the critics are wrong?? All of them? Shoaib is no longer match fit. Occasionally he may produce a wicket taking ball but on the whole he will be punished and what about his fielding? He is unfit and therefore he should not be in the team.Pakistan has always produced highly talented players but of late no new comer is allowed to come in, it seems. Yeah I can agree on the lack of facilities point, but why blame others. Its not as if you don't have a coach and Waqar was Pakistan captain and as a coach why can't he understand Akmal,s problems? You mean a batsman coach, a fielding coach and a wicket keeper coach, now that is being very demanding isloooboy? This Pakistan team is crazy , more crazy than any previous team we have seen.The talented players are there but they are twiddling their thums back in Pakistan as a bunch of aged, unruly and indisciplined side is having fun at the expense of the loyal fans back in Pakistan is there but no direction. Afridi is not the leader who can inspire confidence in his boys. Afridi is saying that if they finish 4th they will have to face India, he does not want that. Very surprising!! It was always India that was nervous of Pakistan. How can your captain say something like that? He means they can't do better than 4th and so what does it prove. This bunch is already mentally prepared to lose and go back home. why? Because there are groups within the team and Afridi knows that, he was part of groups when some one else was leading, right?
@grvdubey11 (1879)
• India
10 Mar 11
With all the controversies and no international cricket at home ,Pakistan cricket has suffered a huge setback.While other teams had become more disciplined and professional ,Pakistan team has deteriorated further.They have lots of talent and that is keeping them in international cricket.I hope you noticed the overthrows which Akhtar gave by throwing the ball over the head of wicketkeeper, how many times have we seen that ,Kamran Akmal has been wicketkeeping poorly not from now but from very long time,half of the matches in Australia were lost by Pakistan due to him dropping sitters .Now if you keep playing with such a wicket keeper what can you expect.About Razzak and Akhtar i dont think they are fit enough to play international cricket.Even in match against SL ,Pakistani cricketers were looking tired and hence SL managed to come so close.They were excited at the start of tournament and hence they achieved some victories but like most of the cricket experts are saying ,that teams who are fittest and with professional attitude will win this tournament and Pakistan team lack both these things.Having said that they do have immense talent but they can win two three matches here and there because of that but not the tournament.I think NZ played this game very smartly , they played with patience at the top and in the end targeted the tired bowlers of Pakistan like Akhtar and Razzaq.
@moksha09 (467)
• India
10 Mar 11
You are right. Without fitness and professionalism no team can expect to win the world cup.Pakistan is the least professional outfit. and unfit too. The way the new zealanders forced Gul and afridi to finish their quota and the way they pounced on the struggling trio of Akhtar,Razzack and Rehman was a lesson in professionalism. Otherwise Ross Taylor would have struggled to score 62 of 18 balls in the end overs.
@ram_cv (16513)
• India
9 Mar 11
Some time back I had started a discussion stating that Kamran Akmal was the worst wicket keeper currently. Most people responded back that it is his batting that keeps him in the team. But looking at his contribution it seems a stupid argument. Chappel made a great statement, that even if Kamram Akmal was as consistent a player as Don Bradman, he was not sure whether he would be able to make up for his lapses behind the stumps. Cheers! Ram
@msdivkar (23356)
• India
9 Mar 11
I agree with you moksha, Pakistan is persisting with Kamran Akmal for his batting at the risk of their own peril. He has proved time and again that he can not be depended upon for keeping. The real villain of their yesterday's loss is Kamran Akmal. How can you give the batsman like Ross Taylor 2-2 chances by missing straight forward catches. His collection behind the wicket particularly on leg side is also horrible. He has given so many easy runs to New Zealand. If he is a better batsman then he should be taken as batsman alone. I think even Younis Khan who keeps wicket occasionally keeps better than him. As about Abdul Razak, he has lost his zip in balling. He is no more the force he used to be and need to be axed for a regular batsman or baller.