How will it help or hurt your gay/lesbian high school child. . .
@HeresTheScoop (748)
United States
January 26, 2012 4:43pm CST
Does it help or hurt your gay/lesbian child if you tell them that they are not gay/lesbian?
I have a friend whose high school child is gay. Ok, he hasn't come out yet, but my son (who is gay) and I have no doubt that he is gay. We would never tell any of his friends or relatives, because that would just be mean.
This young adult has always had feminine qualities (talk, walk, mannerisms). He was in a few female sports in high school. Most all of his friends are girls. And, this is not a gay trait, but he is depressed (he's on meds for that). There have been a couple of times that I have witnessed adults and kids ask him or hint around if he is gay, and of course he says that he is not (because his parents tell him he's not so he knows how they feel about it). His parents were near at these times and they gave angry looks to the people who asked and then would pull him aside whispering to him. I can understand why they would do this since he hasn't told them he is gay. But he will never want to open up to them now because they have made it clear that they are against it. He knows they would never approve.
I know what you're thinking - My son and I are assuming that he's gay, when in fact, he might not be. This is true. We could be wrong, but we've seen this happen way too many times.
I saw a lot of the 'signs' in my son as he was growing up. It didn't cross my mind that he was gay until he was in high school. That's when I realized that it was a very real possibility. I love my son no matter who he is. Whenever I was with him and another person would hint around or ask him if he was gay, I mirrored his reaction to this person. Do you remember when your young child would look at you to see what your reaction is to something before they reacted? That's what I did. He was becoming a young adult with his own views and truths. I would never take those away from him.
What are your thoughts? Do you think it helps or hurts if you tell your gay child that they are not gay?
1 person likes this
1 response
@crimsonladybug (3112)
• United States
27 Jan 12
Maybe it's because "bullying" has become a bit of a buzz word but I see what his parents are doing as bullying. I think that they know, just as well as you and your son, and the other people asking questions, what the truth is but because of their beliefs they cannot allow their son to be true to himself. I don't think that is fair to any of them. The parents are denying themselves the chance to get to know their son for who he really is by pushing him to be something else and they are making him feel that who he is is bad.
As for what you should do... I know you didn't specifically ask for advice but reading between the lines I felt there was a kind of helplessness in your tone. You and your son, especially your son (is he openly out?) should make every attempt possible to let this other boy know he's not alone. One day he will want to come out and he's going to need a support system.
I am not saying that you or your son should mention his sexuality to him at all. But especially if your son is out and open about it, the other boy will know what's going on and know that when the time comes to tell his family, he will have the two of you to lean on and to use as an example (for lack of a better phrase).
@HeresTheScoop (748)
• United States
20 Feb 12
Hi crimsonladybug,
First, I apologize that it has taken me awhile to respond. That was great advice! It's a touchy situation. And yes, my son has been out for 4-5 yrs. He's 25 yrs old.
@soulist (2985)
• United States
20 Feb 12
I totally agree with crimsonladybug. I think this does sound like his parents are bullying him and being aggressive about forcing him to think he is not gay or that it is wrong if he is. I think it would be good for him to know he is not alone and does have the support system of you and your son. It seems his parents are added to his depression because he can't help how he feels and they are constantly telling him not to feel that or that he's wrong.
@HeresTheScoop (748)
• United States
21 Feb 12
soulist,
I agree. I think right now he doesn't want to disappoint his parents. He's in college now and will have much more freedom so maybe he can sort this out.


