sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Compost Pile versus Tumbler  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 92/100. katprice (464) 6 years ago

Currently I have my composting material in a bin that I rotate once a week. I have some other barrels that hold the material until it's ready to be put in the bin.
Are you composting, and if so how long does it take you to get some good compost? Also, are you using a compost pile or a bin/tumbler?

 

sponsors
Open BIN File (Best)
Instantly Enable Your PC to Open BIN Files.
Open-File.com/BIN

Compost Tumblers, Bins
Wide variety Compost bins, tumblers- Envirocycle, ComposTumbler, more.
gardenersnet.com/shop

ComposTumbler
Make compost in 14 days with the best compost tumbler. Buy now& save.
www.ComposTumbler.com

blackbriar (6633) response was accepted on 7/16/2007.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  compost, tumbler, barrels, bin, compost tumbler
 
1. myLot reputation of 72/100. Willowlady (8976)   6 years ago

We have pallets forming compost bins. We through all our stuff in there all year and each new growing season we take off the top layer and get at the gold beneath. Our garden has gotten so good in spots with this stuff that I do not even have to dig it up to plant. The ground is so pliable and the plants so happen that grow there. Hope all my garden gets alot like that in the next few years.


compost bin of pallets

myLot reputation of 92/100. katprice (464)  6 years ago

That seems to be a good system, I may have to switch to something like that. I really want the http://www.compostumbler.com Compost Tumbler but I'm not sure which size to get. I like the fact that it creates compost more rapidly than a pile or other system and in today's instant society where we want everything quickly, that sure fits the bill.

Open BIN File (Best) Instantly Enable Your PC to Open BIN Files.  Open-File.com/BIN
 
2. myLot reputation of 99/100. ElusiveButterfly (9602)   6 years ago

I am a newbie to composting. The extent of my composting is to toss my food scraps onto a pile of leaves. My husband balks at this practice. He worked for a landscaper too! You would think that he would understand the benefits of using compost. And, if you can make it in your back yard even better. I need tips.


myLot reputation of 92/100. katprice (464)  6 years ago

I think a compost bin or tumbler is the way to go, something that animals can't get into. There's a guy down the road who throws scraps out his back door and you can just imagine the attention that attracts from the local stray and wild animals. Our dog even went over there a couple of times, before we put the fence up.

Compost Tumblers, Bins Wide variety Compost bins, tumblers- Envirocycle, ComposTumbler, more.  gardenersnet.com/shop
 
3. myLot reputation of 54/100. Greyback (429)   5 years ago

Yes I compost. And I think that I can help you alittle, both with composting and saving a little money.
You can easily build your own compost tumbler for less than $50.
1st the cradle. I used and old cheap steel framed table and removed the wooden top. You can use 4 posts if you need to. Build a simple square frame on top with old wheelbarrow tires pointed upward. The barrel will set on top of these.
Make sure that the cradle is high enough to get a wheelbarrow under it, to dump the finished compost into.
2nd the barrel. I used and old 50 gal drum with a removeable lid. Paint the inside and out flat black, this helps with temperature. Now run a piece of threaded rod through the barrel, end to end. On this rod secure 3-4 old lawnmower blades. Make a handle on the outside of the drum on the treaded rod. Cut a 1' square hole in the side of the drum, use a piano hinge and barrel bolt to open and close door.
If this dosent make sense, I'll try to send pictures.
It usually takes me about 3 weeks to make a batch of compost.


myLot reputation of 92/100. katprice (464)  5 years ago

Oh my gosh, thanks for posting that! Sounds like a great solution and much cheaper than the $300 plus freight for the store-bought tumbler that I had been thinking about buying. Now that the weather is nicer, I will go find all those materials and put my hubby to work building one of those tumblers for our yard.


myLot reputation of 99/100. blackbriar (6633)  5 years ago

Think I'll just stick with my Compost Tumbler. lol Actually, you really don't need a frame for the barrel. Just sit it on it's side in some out-of-the-way place and roll it around on the ground. Remove the lid to dump the finished compost out. There are no drums in my area with removeable lids. All the barrels are fixed and used for trash/burning or storing flammable liquids.


myLot reputation of 54/100. Greyback (429)  5 years ago

No you dont need the frame, but it does make it easier to unload directly into a wheelbarrow.

ComposTumbler Make compost in 14 days with the best compost tumbler. Buy now & save.  www.ComposTumbler.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 95/100. drakan291 (698)   5 years ago

I just have a big heap out at the back of my garden. It really dosn't need much work! All you guys have to do is turn it once a year! And that isn't even that hard..Well maby a little...okay a lot but anyway it is worth it!


myLot reputation of 92/100. katprice (464)  5 years ago

I actually have been using a dog crate that my puppy outgrew. I filled it with food scraps as well as scraps from the yard, like leaves, sticks, etc. I turn it every week, but it's taken like a year to get the material to look like mulch. I SO want to get the ComposTumbler because it will produce a load of mulch in 2 weeks.

Uncle Jim's Worm Farm Live Composting and Gardening Worms. Guaranteed Live. Free Shipping.  www.unclejimswormfarm.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 99/100. blackbriar (6633)   5 years ago

I had a ComposTumbler for 10 yrs. b4 it finally rusted beyond repair last year. I had a big hole in the yard left after removing a huge concrete slab so threw all my compost stuff in there. I just dug it all out this past weekend and added it all to my garden and filled the hole in with all the ashes from my firepit out back. Now I'm debating on using one of my old plastic garbage cans as a compost bin. Can't have an open pit with all the wild animals in the woods around us. -sighs- Oh how I miss my ComposTumbler. One of these days I'll buy another and bigger one. The one I had was the smallest size they made that fit on our deck. Now that we have moved from our very small yard to over an acre yard, the bigger one will come in handy.


myLot reputation of 92/100. katprice (464)  5 years ago

They don't even make the very smallest size anymore. You have your choice of big and bigger. Prices start at $401 including shipping. Ebay has them for about $50 cheaper. I am using a plastic dog crate that my puppy outgrew and so far it's working pretty well. It doesn't work as fast as the Compost Tumbler, though. There's no way I'm getting good compost avery 14 days. I wish!


myLot reputation of 99/100. blackbriar (6633)  5 years ago

I went with my garbage can for my compost bin. It's really hot and doesn't really smell so my guess is it's working just fine. Now if I can just get my garden under control. No weeds but it's totally overgrown with vege plants. No longer can see the path I made between the rows of tomatoes and my green bean fence toppled under the weight of all the vines. This never happened to me b4 so I'm thinking this is going to be a bumper crop year for me.


myLot reputation of 99/100. blackbriar (6633)  5 years ago

Oh and thank you for the BR. :-)


myLot reputation of 99/100. ElusiveButterfly (9602)  5 years ago

We still use the old pile method. Coughing up the money to purchase a tumbler isn't easy. There are so many other ways make compsost although they are slower.

Windows Fix Free download to fix Windows 7, XP, and Vista errors. (Recommended)  pcmightymax.net/2012
 
6. myLot reputation of 81/100. oscarbartoni (1956)   4 years ago

If you want compost faster then use a blender to make the vegetable scraps smaller and where each piece will have more surface area for the bacteria to break it down for the worms to digest it even more. If you leave large pieces of material then it will take longer for it to turn to good compost. Also make sure to aerate it and keep it moist so that the bacteria and worms do not dry out and die on you.

Open .bin Files (Best) Need to Open .bin Files? Download this 100% FREE .bin Player. Voted #1  OpenAnyFormat.com/Video/BIN
 
sponsors
Uncle Jim's Worm Farm
Live Composting and Gardening Worms. Guaranteed Live. Free Shipping.
www.unclejimswormfarm.com

Windows Fix
Free download to fix Windows 7, XP, and Vista errors. (Recommended)
pcmightymax.net/2012

Open .bin Files (Best)
Need to Open .bin Files? Download this 100% FREE .bin Player. Voted #1
OpenAnyFormat.com/Video/BIN

similar discussions
Do any of you do vermiculture?
After I get into my new house I plan on having a vermiculture going. That is a worm bin to help get...
Do you create your own compost?
We just started a compost pile here. I know what can go in it but I am not sure how much of each...
Toilets of the rich and famous and Amish catalog items
The funniest things happened to me when I looked in Lehmans. I seen a luxury toilet that didn't run...
Broccoli went to seed, and corn growing in odd places.
The broccoli went to seed last week, so I broke the florets off and fed them to the guinea pigs,...
Nutrients for the garden.
My husband built a vegetables garden for me last year, I was told to put the "garbage"(like the...
Demolition Derby
I am worried. Today I sat in my planning meeting and agreed the destruction of a home and highway....
how to prepare fertilizer at home?
i am from India. I can easily get cow dung. But how to prepare good manure from it for my and other...
Why don't we dispose of food scraps in a seperate bin as we do with recyclables?
Hello fellas It is always good to reduce our wastage of food and we should do our possible to...
One Person's Trash is Another Person's Profit
Because I have a compost heap to make dirt for my garden, and I do not buy or use many processed...
in my area, there have been many articles about putting your garden to bed.
What are you going to do with your garden bed once all the harvesting is done? Some people plow it...
sponsors
Uncle Jim's Worm Farm
Live Composting and Gardening Worms. Guaranteed Live. Free Shipping.
www.unclejimswormfarm.com
Windows Fix
Free download to fix Windows 7, XP, and Vista errors. (Recommended)
pcmightymax.net/2012
Open .bin Files (Best)
Need to Open .bin Files? Download this 100% FREE .bin Player. Voted #1
OpenAnyFormat.com/Video/BIN
Discount Compost Tumbler
Compost Tumbler at Best-Price.com! Over 6.000 shops & 23 Mil products
www.Compost-Tumbler.best-price.com
--> Open .BIN Files
If Your PC Can't Open .BIN Files You Need To Download This Fix.
Update.NewestDriver.com/.BIN
tumbler
Find tumbler Online. Free Shipping $50 on 100,000 Items!
Target.com/FreeShipping
Composting
Huge Selection of Composting Bins. Shop Now and Save Money.
www.compostbintumbler.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.