sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

KT Tunstall or Katherine McPhee  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 95/100. zeloguy (2397)   ranked 1 out of 3 in kt tunstall 6 years ago

I loved when Katherine sang 'Black Horse and a Cherry Tree' on American Idol... when I heard KT Tunstall's version, I thought back to McPhee's version and really liked hers better.

 

kt tunstall
sponsors
Save On Local Events
Find special events in your area and save 50-90% on admission. Try us!
www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up

Visitor Information
Find Visitor Attractions& Tourism
yellowpages.com

LA Concert Calendar
Find local live music. Get tickets. Track your bands for show alerts.
Thrillcall.com

Shaun72 (11980) response was accepted on 7/2/2008.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  american idol, best, black horse and a cherry tree, katherine mcphee, kt tunstall
 
1. iamdede (62)   5 years ago

hers? kt or kats? if ur gonna say kats, are you serious? lol
kt is awesome. cant wait to see her perform live again


myLot reputation of 95/100. zeloguy (2397)   ranked 1 out of 3 in kt tunstall  4 years ago

I LOVE KT and her songs... would love to see her live... haven't heard anything much from either one of those two for quite a while now...


Thanks

Zelo

Save On Local Events Find special events in your area and save 50-90% on admission. Try us!  www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up
 
2. myLot reputation of 90/100. SuckerUpper (309)   5 years ago

Hmm I don't watch American Idol (not unless they have the funny tryouts in the episodes). SO I guess Im going to have to stick with my girl KT on this, besides I bought HER cd...


myLot reputation of 95/100. zeloguy (2397)   ranked 1 out of 3 in kt tunstall  5 years ago

Hard to compare when you haven't heard both versions. I love KT I just think Katherine did an excellent rendition of it.


myLot reputation of 90/100. SuckerUpper (309)  5 years ago

yea, you're right. Do you think Youtube has her performance??


myLot reputation of 95/100. zeloguy (2397)   ranked 1 out of 3 in kt tunstall  5 years ago

Good question. I would doubt it since it is (c) by FOX but it would be a good bootleg to see (not saying you should do anything illegal).

Visitor Information Find Visitor Attractions & Tourism  yellowpages.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 94/100. ExoticSarah (792)   5 years ago

KT's is better. Katharine doesn't project correctly and sings through her nose when she tries to hit high notes. She's commercial and isn't that good vocally. KT doesn't have the best voice, but at least she can connect with what she is singing. The song is about abortion and Katharine sang it with no meaning at all. KT, by far!


myLot reputation of 95/100. zeloguy (2397)   ranked 1 out of 3 in kt tunstall  5 years ago

We're talkin about Black Horse and the Cherry Tree right? If anything I would have to say the song is about virginity and not about abortion. I would love a link where there is evidence to prove that. I just listened to the song again and . . . abortion . . . I'm not getting it.


myLot reputation of 95/100. zeloguy (2397)   ranked 1 out of 3 in kt tunstall  5 years ago

FYI... Suddenly I See...

"The song is actually about how Patti Smith inspired KT to do what she does." Fan at concert who talked to KT.

LA Concert Calendar Find local live music. Get tickets. Track your bands for show alerts.  Thrillcall.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 96/100. Shaun72 (11980)   ranked 2 out of 5 in kt tunstall   4 years ago

I know I liked her singing a lot better then the person who won or Taylor Hicks. Of course I liked a lot of singers on season 5 better then Taylor Hicks.


myLot reputation of 95/100. zeloguy (2397)   ranked 1 out of 3 in kt tunstall  4 years ago

American Idol is like the Presidency... WHAT? Yeah, you voted for the other 'contestant' and everyone else voted for someone else but the person that got no votes in your circle won... how the heck did that happen?

Heh.

Thanks for the response

Zelo


myLot reputation of 96/100. Shaun72 (11980)   ranked 2 out of 5 in kt tunstall  4 years ago

Lol that is true American Idol is getting to be like voting for President but worser.


myLot reputation of 95/100. zeloguy (2397)   ranked 1 out of 3 in kt tunstall  4 years ago

Oh my gosh that is a horrible thing to say... putting down American Idol like that!

Heh Just kidding of course.

Thanks for the chucklerasp

happy Zelo happy

5 Foods to Never Eat Cut down a bit of stomach fat every day by never eating these 5 foods.  The6packAbsSecret.com
 
sponsors
5 Foods to Never Eat
Cut down a bit of stomach fat every day by never eating these 5 foods.
The6packAbsSecret.com

Free Printable Coupons
Print Free Online Coupons for Amusment Parks!
ShopAtHome.com/FreePrintableCoupons

Web Sites Ranking
Top million sites ranked by traffic. Unique visitors, Nielsen rating.
ranking.com

similar discussions
Why Do You Like Watching American Idol?
I love Steven Tyler soooo much!! i think he looks like a goat thou.. huhuhu a very sexy goat that...
Enough With The Freaking Singing TV Shows Already!
i know i sound like a grumpy person and even though i didnt like american idol (just not my thing...
The Beginning of the End of American Idol
I saw something on TV earlier today that said that this year will mark the beginning of the end of...
Karaoke
I dislike when "Newbies" and "Regulars" at Karaoke Establishments, expect, Karaoke Singers to...
american idol 11
american idol season 11 premier already launced and a lot of people who audition got a golden...
So this TV show starts back up tommorrow.
So alot of us on here like American Idol. I have seen others post in this topic and i know i...
Make your own sob story
Winning American Idol is now Hard if you are a female contestant or an older male contestant, Its a...
I think I already found the way to make female & older male contestants win
(I hope I wont offend the teenage and tween girls of mylot) I had discussions before on how now...
what is your favorite song from Taylor hicks?
I like Hell of a day, west texas sky and do I make you proud. i couldnt pick just one, lol. how...
American Idol
I heard on the radio earlier today that American Idol is Going Country this week. To celebrate...
sponsors
5 Foods to Never Eat
Cut down a bit of stomach fat every day by never eating these 5 foods.
The6packAbsSecret.com
Free Printable Coupons
Print Free Online Coupons for Amusment Parks!
ShopAtHome.com/FreePrintableCoupons
Web Sites Ranking
Top million sites ranked by traffic. Unique visitors, Nielsen rating.
ranking.com
My Social Network People
Social Networking
msnpeople.com
Psychic Readings Online
Free Registration Free Chat Balalnce avail Phone Chat & Email Readings
http://www.myspiritualexperts.com/
Listen To Fantasia
Get Free Music, Lyrics & Downloads For Fantasia & Other Artists
Music.PureDef.com
Hash House Restaurant
Voted Best Breakfast in Las Vegas
www.hashhouse.net
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.