sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

For those who can play piano without using sheet music, what advice would you   email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 96/100. jbrowsin66 (884)   ranked 6 out of 30 in playing the piano 6 years ago

give to the rest of us who rely on it? How do we go about learning... other than taking more piano lessons. Anything that particularly helped you?

 

playing the piano
sponsors
Fast piano lessons
In-Depth Reviews of Online Piano Lessons. Smart or Scam? We Tell.
www.reviewsnest.com

Piano Restoration Experts
Specialists in piano restoration. Nationwide service available.
www.lindebladpiano.com

Piano Movers
PROFESSIONAL PIANO MOVERS -BURBANK-GLENDALE-LOS ANGELES 323 232 1480
www.bennypianomovers.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  piano, piano lessons, playing by ear, sheet music, music
 
1. myLot reputation of 90/100. Pigglies (5141)   ranked 1 out of 30 in playing the piano   6 years ago

I can sort of play piano by ear, but not much. I used to sit at the piano for hours and just play songs from the radio. If you have a good ear, you can do it. It just takes awhile to figure out what sounds come from where. But eventually, I figured out which sounds corresponded to which notes on sheet music, and stopped playing by ear at all for the most part.


myLot reputation of 96/100. jbrowsin66 (884)   ranked 6 out of 30 in playing the piano  6 years ago

There's a site I saw on one of mylot ads that charges $240 for a 12 DVD set of video lessons geared to intermediate or advanced players. Supposedly the "holy grail" of playing piano without sheet music, but it's kind of expensive. Maybe worth it though as opposed to lessons... I haven't decided yet. It doesn't seem like piano teachers as a rule teach this --just notes on a page.


shopster (21)  5 years ago

I believe that those who can play be ear have perfect pitch. Perfect pitch is a trait that is inborn and cannot be acquired. Musicians who may not have perfect pitch (or have at least relative pitch) may eventually be able, with certain limitations, to discern between various notes, but such abilities are limited.


myLot reputation of 96/100. jbrowsin66 (884)   ranked 6 out of 30 in playing the piano  5 years ago

I saw an ad recently from www.yokewong.net and I bought the improvisation home study course she offers. WOW! I'm not too far into the workbook or CDs and DVDs yet but I am really pleased with it and have been rapidly improving every day. It's like I know all this stuff anyway, from reading music, but it's like I'm able to analzye some of it now and apply it on my own. I don't have perfect pitch, BUT it can be learned! On the CDs she has ear training exercises that you can listen to so you can identify intervals of a second, a third, a fifth, sixth, seventh and octave. The DVDs are great --you watch her hands as she explains all the tips, tricks, etc. She's a great teacher.


hsududette14 (64)  5 years ago

Two things to find when you're playing without sheet music: 1) the melody; and 2) the bass line. Once you have the melody and the bass, everything else is fill in. It helps a great deal when you know what notes make up what chords. It's a lot harder when the chords in the songs aren't the standard major or minor, but most chords in songs are. It helps to go online and listen to MIDI files of the songs. They're downloadable and totally free! It also helps to find sites with guitar tabs... which give you the bass line / chords.


myLot reputation of 96/100. jbrowsin66 (884)   ranked 6 out of 30 in playing the piano  5 years ago

Thanks -- I recently bought a home improvisation study course from Yoke Wong online. 6 DVDS (2 hours each) on how to play without sheet music. I love it! You are right, I really have to study my chords more..

Fast piano lessons In-Depth Reviews of Online Piano Lessons. Smart or Scam? We Tell.  www.reviewsnest.com
 
2. 594026962 (2)   5 years ago

I took piano for two years a got AMAZINGLY good at it. my teacher repeatedly told me i was the fastest learning and best piano student she had EVER taught b4, and i went through all five levels of piano playing in that time. i was so good that you could set a sheet of music that i had never even heard of in front of me, and i'd be able to play it near perfect first time....but then i stopped piano for two years and forgot completely how to read music, so i've re-taught myself to play by ear. right now i'm in three different bands, i have one more that i'm going to start, and when my friend finishes collage (he got a FULL skolership for drumming) we're going to start a band, and do that for our lives. but as for advice, i'd say just keep pracicing at the piano, but listen to songs from your CDs, iPod, MP3, anything, and try to play them. i mean really TRY. it took me a while, but now i can listen to a song, and learn it w/ in a few minutes. so just keep at it, and never stop.


clotho9787 (13)   ranked 27 out of 30 in playing the piano  5 years ago

ditto here. playing by ear just needs practice. as long as you're not tone deaf, you'll make fast progress.

i've been learning to play since kindergarten, when my feet were to small to even reach the pedal...:p that went on til 3rd grade, then i stopped until sophomore year in high school. at that time, i couldnt say i completely forgot how to read sheet music, but i wasnt as skilled as i was before, and so i started playing by ear, and ive found out that there's more expression in oido (term for play by ear), since you've only got the chords to play with, and not really follow what's in the music sheet.

my advice, always practice, and have confidence. like i said, its an expression of you skill, you don't necessarily have to have music sheets to be able to play a piece or just a song. just a good ear will do. :)


myLot reputation of 96/100. jbrowsin66 (884)   ranked 6 out of 30 in playing the piano  5 years ago

Thanks. I'm extremely proficient with reading sheet music, but lately I've just put it away to practice by ear as you say. I bought a video course that is helping, but I'm just trying to find the TIME now! Thanks for the reply.

Piano Restoration Experts Specialists in piano restoration. Nationwide service available.  www.lindebladpiano.com
 
sponsors
Free Sheet Music
Access 1000s of Public Domain Sheet Music Scores. Free.
SheetMusicPublicDomain.com

Popular Guitar Course
Master The Guitar In The Comfort Of Your Home. Find Out How
Jamorama.com

Get "Beginner's Guide to
Playing piano." Sign up Now! For 7 Days Piano Training.
MasteringPianoNow.com

similar discussions
What do you think about boys to play the piano?
A friend asked me what musicial instrument that my son studies. Then I told her my son studies to...
Piano Notations
Hello.. music lovers...do you have any piano notations or chords of any popular songs...? If u...
What is the difference between piano and keyboard?
Please tell me what is the difference between piano and keyboard.
Do you know how to play piano?
Keyboard playing is very difficult thing?But I had learnt that?Do you know how play piano?
loves playing piano
...yah...i love playing piano...i want to improve my talent in playing piano but the hard part is,...
advise on piano course books
I did pick up some piano books at our thrift store and a friend of mine gave me the ones she used...
how true is this?
I wonder what you make of this? 'A man is as good as his tools'. We bust a gut to afford a good...
Newbie on Piano
I love music. My dad's been fond of it and that interest he passed on to me.. ^_^ Few years back...
What is your favorite musical instrument?
For me my favorite musical insrument is Drums, though i can minorly play others but still drums is...
sponsors
Free Sheet Music
Access 1000s of Public Domain Sheet Music Scores. Free.
SheetMusicPublicDomain.com
Popular Guitar Course
Master The Guitar In The Comfort Of Your Home. Find Out How
Jamorama.com
Get "Beginner's Guide to
Playing piano." Sign up Now! For 7 Days Piano Training.
MasteringPianoNow.com
Local The Piano Lessons
Find The Piano Lessons Near You. See Actual Customer Reviews!
Local.com
Save On Piano Lessons
Become a Complete Pianist Using our Proven Methods
Www.PianoAppTime.Com
Popular Piano Courses
Learn To Play Piano Now! Complete Line Of Lesson Books Up To 40% Off!
www.music44.com
Local Movers
Local Movers & Moving Services -
yellowpages.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.