But that's child abuse!  |
|
I'm not a parent but I have helped raise my niece since she was born and she's now 12 years old. During the last twelve years I've seen and heard so many times people accusing parents, care givers, etc of child abuse. It doesn't matter what the they are doing it is still cried out at them. Parents are in a no win situation now a days. Far too often no matter what they do someone yells or harasses them saying they are abusing their child while those who are actually doing child abuse are over looked.
It's gotten very crazy with this. If someone doesn't like what a parent is doing they scream child abuse. I've seen it happen with a host of things including:
1. Not breastfeeding or breastfeeding 2. Giving children solids before a year, not giving them solids till they are that old. 3. Spanking or not spanking 4. Scolding or not scolding 5. For giving time outs or for not giving them 6. having a kid outside playing or again not outside 7. giving your child certain foods/drinks or for not giving them. 8. Drinking, smoking, watching tv, listening to music or any other things that the child might see you do.
The list goes on. Is anyone else tired of this? Why can't people learn that just because we don't agree doesn't mean it's abuse.
Add to that you keep crying child abuse sooner or later people will ignore you. Just like the child that cried wolf, the real child who needs help will be ignored.
| |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
1. lecanis (7221)  | 3 years ago | As someone who was seriously abused as a child, I heartily agree with you. Accusing every parent who looks at their kid wrong of child abuse keeps children who are really in abusive situations from getting the help they need because no one takes the topic seriously enough anymore.
Teaching children to cry abuse over nothing makes it so if they are actually abused no one will listen. I've heard teachers, doctors, and other professionals that have to report child abuse voice the same opinions. If every single kid says their parents are abusing them because the media has taught them that this silly little thing or that silly little thing is abuse, no one know which situations to actually investigate.
Frankly, I'm a little terrified of being accused of child abuse. I know I would never do anything to harm my child, but there are so many topics on which people disagree, and for any one of them someone could accuse you of abuse. And even worse than the legal ramifications of this, there's the fact that your child could grow up to actually believe you abused them, just because someone told them that some aspect of your parenting methods was wrong.
*shudders* Sorry for the rant, but this is obviously a subject on which I have very strong feelings and opinions.
| |
| |
|
|
emeraldisle (8978) | 3 years ago | It's ok to rant. If anything this is the place to do it. Believe me I do understand as a victim of abuse myself I know how horrible childhood can be and how parents can be as well.
I too have very strong feelings on it and I get very fed up when I see so many accuse when there is no cause. Far too often the ones who do need the help, who are being abused, aren't noticed or given the help they do need.
| |
|
|
kiwimac (289) | 3 years ago | Right on!
As long as everything can be child-abuse, REAL abuse DISAPPEARS.
When the social services, courts, law enforcement are having to deal with what are minor parenting issues leaves them unable to deal with abuse issues. We need to stop labeling every darn thing abuse and leave that for REAL, SERIOUS, ACTUAL abuse.
| |
|
|
|
Obama Wants You to Return to School Get Your Degree Now. Financial Aid available. www.ClassesUSA.com | add comment |
|
|
|
2. brandi_girl_16 (416) | 3 years ago | This is very true! It gets more and more stupid by the second it seems. There are things parents just shouldn't do ethically and morally to a child, which are the things that no one would say "it's okay!" such as beating a child or burning him with a cigarette but those are givens! Then there are things that mothers should do but sometimes can't or don't want to, such as breastfeeding (I say can't because some mothers just don't produce enough milk for their babies), then their are things that parents should do, if it's needed, such as timeouts and spankings, if the child is so disobedient that it affects their life! A spanking is a spanking, but a beating is a beating...some parents don't know the difference and that's when someone should cry child abuse about them!
| |
| |
|
|
emeraldisle (8978) | 3 years ago | This post contains content of a mature nature. You must be Signed in or Registered to have the option to view this content.
| |
|
|
lecanis (7221) | 3 years ago | I got much the same reaction from nurses when I had breastfeeding problems. I finally had to give up breastfeeding altogther, after only 2 months of it, and I got some pretty bad reactions from nurses, other parents, and my family members.
Thankfully I had a pretty understanding doctor for my son, and what she said to me was that it was more important that he get enough food than that I nurse. He had lost a lot of weight because I was trying to hard to get him to nurse and supplementing as little as possible, and she said it was more important that he not starve.
| |
|
|
emeraldisle (8978) | 3 years ago | This post contains content of a mature nature. You must be Signed in or Registered to have the option to view this content.
| |
|
|
|
Obama Urges Homeowners to Refinance See Rates - No Credit Check Needed. ($90,000 Refinance under $489/mo) www.LowerMyBills.com | add comment |
|
|
|
3. visitorinvasion (3599) | 3 years ago | This falls under my favorite category: People need to mind their own business ...don't jump my case here, if a child is being beaten, molested or starved, that's abuse. Other than that, people need to tend to their own kids and their own "closets." Just my 10 cents.
| |
| |
|
|
emeraldisle (8978) | 3 years ago | Mine as well. I wish people would learn to mind their own business. yes when it's actual abuse then that is different, as you said beaten, molested, starved..etc but just because you don't like something doesn't mean it's abuse.
| |
|
|
|
Obama Backs Auto Insurance Regulation Drivers Pay $44/mo on Avg for Car Insurance. Are you paying too much? Auto-Insurance-Experts.com | add comment |
|
|
|
4. roniroxas (5937) | 3 years ago | i am a mom of 4 kids, and its really hard to raise kids specially if you always rely on what other people will be saying. you can no longer raise them the way you think is best specially when neighbors or relatives are so nossy or bossing around. for me its more abusive to kids if you always codemn the parents of abusing. they are really abusive parents out there (and i mean a lot). who leave their kids hungry but the parents are out partying all night. who hits their kids with no reason at all and thats child abuse. who call their kids names and humiliate their kids in public then thats child abuse. and i agree with you if they always cries out like the boy who cried wolf people will get used to it then when the real trouble comes along nobody will care.
| |
| |
|
|
|
Online College Degrees Enjoy Online College Convenience! 100's of Career-Advancing Degrees. Education.NexTag.com/Online-Degrees | add comment |
|
|
|
5. brokentia (7812) | 3 years ago | I think what also makes it harder is when the child claims child abuse just because the child does not like a situation. I have heard many cases where the child will claim abuse to either get out of trouble or to cause trouble to the parent to get the upper hand. Which is very sad! Then the parent can not parent due to fear that the child will try to yell child abuse. Then there are complete strangers out in public that have to stick their nose in your business! It has gotten to the point that I will have to walk my child out of the store before I even say anything. But on the flip side, for others that see me ignore the child and walk the child out think that I do not know how to parent! Now...the best thing is...stay home! LOL But wait...then that could be abuse because the child never gets out o the house besides school and playing in the backyard. *sigh* It has become a sad sad world!
| |
| |
|
|
emeraldisle (8978) | 3 years ago | That it has and you are right, you can't win. You take the child out to talk to them they begin to think something is giogn on. If you do it in there then you get yelled at. It can be very scary to be parent now a days because you never know who will accuse you over what minor thing.
| |
|
|
|
|
|
6. APMorison (276) | 3 years ago | It is fear of the rampant 'child abuse' alarms going off that I think is contributing to the lack of any kind of discipline on children who a obviously out of control.
When someone is afraid to correct their child because someone might call the cops, its time to reassess the way child abuse is reported and for what reason. I am old enough to have been a kid who was in danger of being spanked in school for infractions and knew if it happened I'd be facing the same or worse once I got home. Beating me near bloody with a belt was not called child abuse when my mother did it. My father tried to protect my sister and I but back then, if he'd sought a divorce the court would have likely have given us to the abuser anyway. He was also suffering from spousal abuse, but again Back Then, they didn't recognize a man as being abused.
We go from one extreme to the other and its sad. Really sad.
| |
| |
|
|
emeraldisle (8978) | 3 years ago | Oh I agree. I think that is a major reason why paents are afraid to discipline. I see it happen. I've seen how some can be and why parents are leery because of it. They shouldn't have to be. They should be allowed to be parents.
I feel for what you went through. That had to have been horrible. Even now for men to file abuse against a woman is hard to do. So many don't want to think that a man can be but sadly it does happen more then many realize.
| |
|
|
|
|
|
7. GardenGerty (20103) | 3 years ago | I love this post! First, I have heard a foster child from a family explaining to our pastor's son:"My parents will let me do such and such, and if they don't, I will call SRS (child protective services) and say they are abusing me." (I was transporting them in a bus as a volunteer, at the time, and they were sitting right behind me.) The best experts in the world on any subject are the ones who have no experience in the field. I know I am not an expert. I have had some pretty angry thoughts about some things. I have heard people "getting even" with each other in relationships by playing the Child abuse card. I am enjoying the responses you have received so far.
| |
| |
|
|
emeraldisle (8978) | 3 years ago | Oh I've seen people use that Child Abuse card to get people to bend to their will. they use it as blackmail even if they know it's not true. Kids will use it too as you pointed out. It's sad that people will do that but even sader that they can.
| |
|
|
|
|
|
8. dragonryder (3573) | 3 years ago | I think children and family services would laugh at most of those things that people are using as an excuse to cry child abuse about.I do know what you mean though about the petty things getting investigated and the serious stuff being overlooked. Stephanie
| |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
9. princess07031980 (1850) | 3 years ago | I agree with you. The media/public eye stick their noses too far in other people's business constantly. And sadly we as parents cannot raise our children often times the way we feel the need to. Anymore, discipline means child abuse and it seems the organizations (local law enforcement, protective services, etc.) agree with this too! I was spanked as a child, and I feel it did me well, and as you can guess my children are disciplined the same way if necessary. A very true statement you had mentioned too-the real children will be ignored when they need the help. The fine line between discipline and abuse-what is it, people are more concerned with time outs than a child with broken bones form an abusive hand? Yeah, this system needs some help and a lot of work....Excellent post.
| |
| |
|
|
emeraldisle (8978) | 3 years ago | I agree there is a difference between discpline and abuse. People need to realize that difference and keep their noses out of the non-abuse ones. I know I've seen local organizations feed into it as well. It doesn't help at all especially when they tell kids "Well if mommy or daddy ever do something that makes you feel bad you call 911". Yeah that's what my neice was told by the schools. That went over real well especially since they gave her the impression if she called 911 was that they'd come out and talk with mommy and make her give in to what she wanted.
| |
|
|
|
|
|
10. GnosticGoddess (3490) | 3 years ago | That is really true. I hear that a lot myself even though I'm not a parent. I disagree with a lot of the way children are raised but I don't cry child abuse. I might not like it and wouldn't raise my children that way but at the same time I keep my mouth shut and complain about it to my husband. LOL
| |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| | Online College Degrees Enjoy Online College Convenience! 100's of Career-Advancing Degrees. Education.NexTag.com/Online-Degrees
| | |
|
|
|
|