sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

Would you Return the Cheese? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 92/100. khalablue (234)   ranked 4,175 out of 38,129 in life3 years ago

A week or so ago, I had just finished my grocery shopping at the warehouse store where I shop when I noticed that someone had left 2 5 pound packages of individually wrapped processed cheese in a shopping cart, the value of which was close to $40.00 Canadian. After loading my groceries into my trunk I took the cheese into the store and gave it to the store manager, and told him that someone would be coming in to tell him that they paid for it but didn't get it. He took it and looked very surprised and thanked me profusely. Later when I mentioned this to some others, they told me that I should have kept it. My husband was the only one who agreed with my actions. What would you have done and why?

 
 
life
sponsors
used hatchback oil change
Used Hatchback Research, Reviews& Latest Prices. Free Info.
www.Edmunds.com

HP Pavilion Dv6400 Series
Only $69 8800mAh Double Capacity 1 Yr Warranty. 30 Day Money Back.
www.BattDepot.com

DC Area Attractions
Find museums, national monuments, historic homes, wineries and more.
www.fxva.com

Grandmaof2 (4356) response was accepted on 3/31/2007.
denotes best response.
tags:  honesty, cheese, return, karma, lost and found
 
1. myLot reputation of 96/100. maries1952 (1408)   ranked 877 out of 38,129 in life   3 years ago

If it was that much cheese I would think someone needed it for some reason.
Could be an organization or anything
you generally just don't buy that amount of cheese for a family.
I would have taken it back in
I somehow walked out without my milk last week in Walmart oh well had to go back and get milk LOL
we all do it but when its quantity its nice when someone does take it back and the person has a chance to get it back!
You are a jewel
I agree with your husband


myLot reputation of 92/100. khalablue (234)   ranked 4,175 out of 38,129 in life  3 years ago

Because this is a warehouse store, many small shopkeepers and restaurant owners purchase items for resale. So, I agree with you. It probably wasn't intended for family consumption.

used hatchback oil change Used Hatchback Research, Reviews & Latest Prices. Free Info. www.Edmunds.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 76/100. czechdoll1 (142)   ranked 10,298 out of 38,129 in life   3 years ago

I would definitely return the items to the store. Besides being the right thing to do, I would feel bad that somebody left the items there and would need them. If they weren't returned they would have to rebuy them and that isn't right to do to someone. I have left a box of diapers one time and you can bet someone did not return it to the store. I couldn't do that to someone else.


myLot reputation of 92/100. khalablue (234)   ranked 4,175 out of 38,129 in life  3 years ago

Its nice to know that I am not alone in my decision, and even after the discussion that I had where my friends told me I was crazy to return it, I would still do the same thing.

HP Pavilion Dv6400 Series Only $69 8800mAh Double Capacity 1 Yr Warranty. 30 Day Money Back. www.BattDepot.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 84/100. Phlamingho (7334)   ranked 1,614 out of 38,129 in life   3 years ago

If I could have used the cheese I would have kepts it, if it wasn't something I liked I would have returned it, simple as that:-)


myLot reputation of 92/100. khalablue (234)   ranked 4,175 out of 38,129 in life  3 years ago

Two of my friends both felt the same way as you do. They said that if someone is that careless as to leave something they just paid for in the shopping cart, then they deserve not to get it back. It might teach them a lesson to be more careful next time.

DC Area Attractions Find museums, national monuments, historic homes, wineries and more. www.fxva.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 97/100. jfeets726 (599)   ranked 10,297 out of 38,129 in life   3 years ago

I think that you did the right thing by returning it. It is nice to hear that there are still people out there. Someone was probably very happy when they called the store to find out that their cheese had been recovered.

Personally, I would have done the same thing too, as if I hadn't I would have felt as if I was stealing. Due to being a retail manager for 3 years before becoming a stay at home mom. I know how it works. It wouldn't have been too bad in your situation because a customer forgot their own goods, but like when a cashier gives back too much change, they can actually get in a lot of trouble. The company that I worked for as a manager had a three dollar or something like that limit and if you had more than three mistakes, you could and people were fired.

That is why I always try and return stuff that isn't mine, especially when it comes to money.


myLot reputation of 92/100. khalablue (234)   ranked 4,175 out of 38,129 in life  3 years ago

One of my friends put forth the argument that the store probably just kept it and put it back on the shelf and when and if the customer called they were probably told that the loss of the cheese was their problem. I said, then that would be on their conscience, not mine. I figure I did the right thing, and I have no regrets.


myLot reputation of 93/100. arcadian (479)   ranked 874 out of 38,129 in life  3 years ago

I doubt that the store put it back. I would have done what you did. Here's what I think If everything we did could be considered a brick- and we were all building a world for the next generation, every misplaced, careless brick or ruined brick would make a hole in what we were all building., then anytime someone acts selfishly or immorally they create a hole in the structure. People don't realize that when they scrap their self worth for a package of cheese or any such thing, they have affected the whole of mankind. And made themselves a bit more worthless in their own eyes.

Stay at Home Mom Resume Give Your Resume the Boost it Needs with Degree– Online For Busy Moms www.FloridaTechOnline.com/Moms
 
5. myLot reputation of 95/100. kelly3 (4848)   ranked 1,048 out of 38,129 in life   3 years ago

I would have returned the cheese. I once found someone's wallet, and I returned it. I just think it's the right thing to do. It's what I would want someone to do for me.

Kelly


myLot reputation of 92/100. khalablue (234)   ranked 4,175 out of 38,129 in life  3 years ago

You state it clearly and simply and is how I feel too. The argument that if it was I who had lost something, it would probably not be returned is irrelevant to me.

Auditions & Casting Calls Do You Have It In You To Become An Actor? Apply For Casting Calls Now. www.Casting-Call.us
 
6. myLot reputation of 97/100. GardenGerty (20244)   ranked 63 out of 38,129 in life   3 years ago

For me, it is simple, I would return the cheese. I know, honesty is considered unusual nowadays, but it is still the best policy. I can see that you and your husband are well suited.


myLot reputation of 92/100. khalablue (234)   ranked 4,175 out of 38,129 in life  3 years ago

Perhaps that is one of the reasons we are still together after so many years.

KLM Washington to Accra Book Now: Frequent Return Flights & Permanently Low KLM Airfares. www.klm.com/accra
 
7. myLot reputation of 99/100. crazynurse (5708)   ranked 521 out of 38,129 in life   3 years ago

Wow, that is a lot of cheese. I would have returned it to the manager as well. Surely the person who purchased that much cheese will come back, as it seems they need a lot of cheese for something! I still live by the 'golden rule'.."do as to others as you would have them do unto you." If I bought that much cheese and forget it, I would hope that I could go back and get it without difficulty.


myLot reputation of 92/100. khalablue (234)   ranked 4,175 out of 38,129 in life  3 years ago

Your last sentence was the point that my friends made. They felt that if the person did return to the store for the cheese that they wouldn't get it anyway. My view was that there was nothing I could do to influence the honesty of others. So long as my integrity is intact thats what matters.

Macy's ® Wedding Registry Create or Find a Registry @ Macy's. Rewards Program Save 5-10%! MacysWeddingChannel.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 98/100. liranlgo (2887)   ranked 5,843 out of 38,129 in life   3 years ago

you did the right thing
i would have done the same
i am happy to hear that there are deacent
people like you


myLot reputation of 92/100. khalablue (234)   ranked 4,175 out of 38,129 in life  3 years ago

I think there are a lot of decent people. And I also think that a lot of decent people would have kept the cheese, and their reasons for doing so, could be well justified.

Would You Like To Work From Home? Discover Online Marketing. Start Making Money, You Found Your New Job. www.TimeToGetYours.net
 
9. myLot reputation of 88/100. uu4h708 (345)   ranked 5,130 out of 38,129 in life   3 years ago

yup!! have to agree with the other 7mylotters and you're husband.. its good that you were able to think and do the right thing when you were in that situation.. wish all people are like you...
if that was me, id return the cheese, first of all... because with that huge cheese, i dont think i would be able to eat all that till it expires can i??
and second, i firmly believe in "karma" and if i eat that food i'd probably be food poisoned or have diarrhea...

so again.. good job!!!!=)


myLot reputation of 92/100. khalablue (234)   ranked 4,175 out of 38,129 in life  3 years ago

I don't particularly care for processed cheese. However, I do have 2 very large dogs that love cheese and I could have added it to their dinner and they would have loved me for it, but it wasn't mine to keep.

Actually, you wouldn't get diarrhea from cheese, you would get constipated, ha ha.

Get Gov Funding Now Billions Of Dollars In U.S. Money Is Available For All Citizens. www.GovGrantsHelp.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 96/100. mssnow (4138)   ranked 91 out of 38,129 in life   3 years ago

I would have taken it back. You never know, maybe the person who bought it was poor and that was all they could buy to make do for a week or something. I always think about what if it were me. I would want someone to return my items that I spent money on to buy. You did good. Bravo to you!! Don't let the ones who told you to "keep it" bother you. Just remember what goes around, comes around. Some day they might be in the same situation.


myLot reputation of 92/100. khalablue (234)   ranked 4,175 out of 38,129 in life  3 years ago

The only thing that really bothered me about my friends' opinion is that they really thought they were right and were very scornful about what I did. I thought it was interesting that we could be friends and differ so greatly in something as basic as this.

White Pages Directory Find a Person by Name, Address, Zip Code & More at YellowPages ® www.YellowPages.com/WhitePages
 
sponsors
Stay at Home Mom Resume
Give Your Resume the Boost it Needs with Degree– Online For Busy Moms
www.FloridaTechOnline.com/Moms

Auditions& Casting Calls
Do You Have It In You To Become An Actor? Apply For Casting Calls Now.
www.Casting-Call.us

KLM Washington to Accra
Book Now: Frequent Return Flights& Permanently Low KLM Airfares.
www.klm.com/accra

similar discussions
what will you do if your boyfriend has another girl?
well for me as a woman inlove its very normal that we get hurt. the usual i will ask my boyfriend...
Do it pay to be honest all the time?
Do you think it is always a good idea to be honest,i think it pays to be honest as that way there...
Why people lie more often?
A recent survey revealed that most of the people lie more often than in the past.Nowadays people...
is honesty always the best policy
I know we say that honesty is best, but is it really the best If someone is really sick and might...
Transparency
Retired now, I have worked for several employers. Some good, some not so much. I have just...
What kind of Honesty are you?
I belive there're different kinds of honesty. Total honesty is to be honest under any circumstances...
What was the most honest thing you have done to other people?
Everyone of us here have done something honest to someone like returning an extra change for your...
Are You a Man (OR Woman) of Your Word?
From child to adult, I was educated to be integrity from family, school and social. A book I read...
If you dont have answer?
Hi friends,if you don't know the answer for certain questions what will you do?just smile or search...
How honest are you?
While you're walking along the street you've spotted a wallet, picked it up and checked the...
sponsors
Stay at Home Mom Resume
Give Your Resume the Boost it Needs with Degree– Online For Busy Moms
www.FloridaTechOnline.com/Moms
Auditions & Casting Calls
Do You Have It In You To Become An Actor? Apply For Casting Calls Now.
www.Casting-Call.us
KLM Washington to Accra
Book Now: Frequent Return Flights & Permanently Low KLM Airfares.
www.klm.com/accra
Macy's ® Wedding Registry
Create or Find a Registry @ Macy's. Rewards Program Save 5-10%!
MacysWeddingChannel.com
Would You Like To Work From Home?
Discover Online Marketing. Start Making Money, You Found Your New Job.
www.TimeToGetYours.net
Get Gov Funding Now
Billions Of Dollars In U.S. Money Is Available For All Citizens.
www.GovGrantsHelp.com
White Pages Directory
Find a Person by Name, Address, Zip Code & More at YellowPages ®
www.YellowPages.com/WhitePages
Call Center Manager Positions
Find call center manager positions at iHire.
www.iHireCustomerService.com
Work From Home To Create
Financial Security, Use Proven Automated System for Your Success.
SuccessBuildingOnline.com
Relocating to DuPont WA?
Don’t Search Blindly - Area Info, Home Search, School Info and More.
RealEstateBuyerInfo.com/relocation
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.