Do You Think That India Should Attack Pakistan,For Spreading Terror In India?

Should India Attack Pakistan,To Respond To 40 Year - Should India Attack Pakistan,To Respond To 40 Years OF Terror Spread by Pakistan
@Ganesh44 (5547)
India
November 30, 2008 10:46pm CST
Dear Friends Pakistan has been spreading terror in India for almost last 40 years ,killing huge number of innocent citizen and soldiers everyday in India . Indian goverment has not taken any strong action yet but to keep blaming Pakistan and showing evidence to world community . It has been proved that 10 Pakistani terrorist has been behind recent terrorist attack on Mumbai(India) and one Paksitani national(terrorist) captured has told the whole plan/story . Do You think that Indian goverment should take world community in confidence ,seeking their help and should order attack on Pakistan ,to end 40 years of innocent killing and terror in India ? Thanks Ganesh
10 people like this
40 responses
@Anne18 (11029)
1 Dec 08
I don't thinl India should attack Pakistan as fighting never solved anything and I don't think the world has found this fact out yet as we are still having pointless fights and lives lost. Lets just live in peace
2 people like this
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
1 Dec 08
My Dear Friend Yes I agree that fighting does not solve any problem ..... But India has been trying to convince Pakistan for last 40 years to stop sending terrorist to India ,but it has not yet stopped ... Hope peaceful ways will work for Pakistan to understand before it is too late Thanks for your response and such a nice information...! Happy Mylotting Take Care Ganesh
2 people like this
• India
1 Dec 08
yeah now you will say it is also propoganda of Indian Government ,Indian Army,Indian intelligence etc . There are solid proofs of links and also pakistan is harbouring Dawood Ibrahim openly and is not ready to hand it over.
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
2 Dec 08
Salaam Ayub Sahab I have read your discussion suggesting Indian goverment to think 100 times before taking a decision . My answer to this is Indian goverment has been thinking for last 40 years and not for just 100 times but for billion of times but now it is the time to take strict decision. I think ,with continuous attacks by America and Afghanistan on terrorist outfits in Pakistan , I need not give anybody more proofs . Do you think that countries like USA and Afghanistan are mad attacking terrorist camps in your country with missiles everyday . Are USA and Afghsnistan attacking common people in Afghanistan offcourse not ? Dont they need proof dont they need to think 100 times ?Dear all have enough evidences and proofs .... Please read about your own country they are not my words by report by BBC london ,I think it will help all in this discusssion and you too .... http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/7705373.stm http://www.mylot.com/w/discussions/1783644.aspx Dear Ayub I think stage where proof needs to be shown to world has been long over ,the whole world is convinced that Pakistan is a country that hosts huge number of terrorist organissation like ,Lashkaraey Taeban ,Mujaheedeen and so on . Do you ever realize that the haterd act of terrorism in India supported by Pakistan has caught Pakistan adversly ? I dont want war with Paksitan ....I never wanted India to attack Pakistan's innocent people like Pakistan has been doing through terroris organisation in India .....But I think India should attack all the terrorist camps in Pakistan without allowing them to kill more innocent people in our country ....... And I think Paksitan goverment should take part in joint military action against terrorist organisation in Pakistan ,in association with USA and Afghanistan . I think India ,Pakistan ,USA , Afghanistan attacking terrorists camp in your counntry would be a peacful solution to this problem for once and last and this will save lot of innocent lives . What do you think ? Thanks Ganesh
• India
1 Dec 08
I don't think we should attack Pakistan because of the terrorist activities. Terrorists aim is to destroy the relationship between India and Pakistan, and therefore create problem between Muslim and Hindus. Since Pakistan is also a victim of terrorists like we are, attacking Pakistan compound the problem further and both the countries would fall victim to the evil design of the terrorist. I also think that it is important for us to think critically why terrorists did what they did. Human being just don't give up one's life without some reasons which appear valid to them. And I think one factor, apart from their religious indoctrination, is that they think that the 'criminals' who engineered the Gujarat riot and the Babri Masjid demolition etc are still not yet punished by the govt. So they thought that revenge must be taken. I don't think killing innocent people and terrorising citizens is a right way to deal with issues like this, but the point is that if we are not careful and wise enough more killings will ensue. The cycle would keep on going. I wish our politicians would also stop indulging in religious thing to get vote. Jai Hind!
1 person likes this
• India
2 Dec 08
I have not personally seen, but I do not doubt that many times Pakistan's soldiers are involved. For example, Kargil was Musharraf's plot. But it is also true that Nawaz Sharif was in India talking about building relationship with India when Musharraf was busy engineering how to destroy India. So Pakistan's leadership was divided. Even now I believe it is divided. But recently things have changed. I believe Pakistan is seriously trying to sort out the issue themselves. Help the moderates in Pakistan so that they can carry out reformation within Islam and Pakistan. I guess that's the better approach. War will repeat the cycle till both bleed terribly. That's my view.
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
3 Dec 08
My Dear Friend I think suspecting and blaming each other would not help . What would you say about organisation like Laskarae Taebaan,Jaeshae Mohammad, Hizbul Mujhaheedeen in Pakistan . Would you say that these organisation are not in Paksitan? I think instead of blaming each other Indian and Pakistan along with US should take a strict action against terrorist camps in Pakistan . I think destroying terrorist camps will help in the growth of Pakistan and citizen of your country . If you are already doing this than it is really great All the best !! Happy Mylotting! Take Care! Ganesh!
• India
4 Dec 08
Well simple question what are those 20 hardcore criminals doing in pakistan?
@alokn99 (5717)
• India
1 Dec 08
Ganesh, Tha anger is so much that we feel like doing that , but in the process will also be taking innocent lives. Rather get enough pressure put on them by whatever means to get them to act on the fundamentalists and terrorists within thier country.
1 person likes this
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
7 Dec 08
Dear Friend Yes I totally agry with you that every Indian is angry that is why lot of resentment is expressed by people all over . Yes I dont want that any inncoent people get killed by anymeans anywhere but I think some strict alternative is required ....... Thanks for your response and such a nice information...! Happy Mylotting Take Care Ganesh
@riyasam (16556)
• India
1 Dec 08
innocent lives are lost because of these terriorist activities.instead of blaming others,we could fortify our commandoes and security measures.
1 person likes this
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
1 Dec 08
My Dear Friend Yes I agree with you to some extent. But how will you check for terrorist in 120 crore population . Even if we employ our all 3 forces we cannot check the whole country and places . I think instead of blaming as we have been doing for last 40 years we should take a strict action against Paksitan . Thanks for your response and such a nice information...! Happy Mylotting Take Care
@mtata23 (354)
• India
2 Dec 08
Enough is Enough. We have bared a lot. No more terrorist attacks should occur in my country. It is time for action. We have warned Pakistan umpteenth time for harboring terrorists. LISTEN, O LEADERS and POLITICIANS of INDIA, Pakistan will never ever agree of harboring terrorists on their soil nor will cooperate with INDIA, in eliminating terrorism and restore peace in the subcontinent. It is our motherland that is getting bleed again and again and it is we and we countrymen only have to save it and fight against terrorists irrespective of cast or religion. So, think, rise o leaders, politicians, businessmen, bureaucrats, corporate INDIA and every citizen of INDIA whether he or she is Muslim, Hindu, Christian, or Sikh. Also, it is not just the question of waging a war of weapons but also bringing international pressure on Pakistan, making our intelligence more effective and securing our borders is essential.
@piya84 (2581)
• India
1 Dec 08
another thing if we attact..it gonna kill several army men....nt terrorist...recently india pakistan relations have improved a lot...it will ruin every effort done last 3 yrs...war is nt economycally afordable also in this condition..where pakistan is already beggin 4 loan ...indian economy also suffering due to world economic crisis...war will only increase troubles for common man of both countries.
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Dec 08
we cant follow the same steps the u.s. did wen they accused afghanistan of attacking us when it was al queda
@JG1950 (27)
• India
1 Dec 08
First we should attack the present system of governance which has not been successful in containing terrorism locally. The Naxalite problem is a classic example. The government and the opposition parties do not have a concrete policy to contain terrorism. We have no sincerity in our approach.In these circumstance containing international terrorism is beyond us. Pakistan should also realize that encouraging terrorists has made themselves victims of terrorism.The first step would be a sincere joint meeting of all political parties to resolve to fight terrorism with no political leanings. They should arrive at an agenda which will be implemented by governments irrespective of their political policies. This should be taken as a national policy and amending this should require consensus. If there is a political Will there is a way out of this.
@JG1950 (27)
• India
2 Dec 08
It is unfortunate that our government has the heavy responsibility of containing both local and international terrorism. Our Government is elected by the people to not only provide a decent standard of life but also to protect their lives from terrorism. Therefore, any future government should strive hard to contain terrorism irrespective of cast,religion and nationality.It really calls for a full time concentrated efforts from the politicians. It will not leave any time for them to play dirty politics. If this happens then our Country will be the best in the world.Hope wisdom dawns on our politicians. Pakistan should be told in no uncertain terms that encouraging terrorism will be viewed as anti-human and tress pass on individual freedom internationally. An International Committee should be urgently formed to stress the point of maintaining peace and harmony globally. Internal politics cannot result in international terrorism. The committee should also be equipped and empowered to chase the terrorists in any part of the world. This would surely discourage countries to ignore or indirectly support terrorism.
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
2 Dec 08
My Dear Friend I appreciate your view and suggestions hope things will improve .... Thanks for your response and such a nice information...! Happy Mylotting Take Care Ganesh
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
1 Dec 08
My Dear Friend Yes I agree with you to some extent. I agree that war is not a solution to any problem. I think we need to understand the problem of our goverment too . Our government is not elected to fight terrorism all the time . They have hell lot of other responsibilities . But due to increase in terror attacks by Pakistan in our country , I think goverment is also over burdened with responsibilities. Pakistan has not realized something in 40 years how can you expect Pakistan to understand it now ? Thanks for your response and such a nice information...! Happy Mylotting Take Care
@jennybianca (12912)
• Australia
25 Nov 09
No, I dont. I know it has been a huge problem for India with the terrorists attacks. Howerver, it is not all of Pakistan that are doing this, nor is it the Pakistani Government. There are many many good people in Pakistan. The problem is with a minority terrorist group. I have a friend in Pakistan and he wants this trouble to end to. Really both governments should get together and communbicatre a lot more, try to help each other out to solve the problems. No one wants to see more innocent victims suffer in a war.
@jennybianca (12912)
• Australia
27 Nov 09
Okay, Im sure you are more informed on this than me. But I would not want to see a war over it. It may be that the Pakistani government are sponsoring their terorists, but I think many ordinary Pakistani people would not approve of this (they probably have no say over it).
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
28 Nov 09
Yes I do agree war is not a solution to any problem and people of both country want friendly relationship but it is unfourtunate that for last almost 50 years Pakistan is sponsering and exporting terror to India I hope that some peaceful solution will come out as 50 year of Indian patience is coming to end
@jillmalitz (5131)
• United States
1 Dec 08
From what I have seen, these two countries have been on the brink of war for some time now. I have heard that they don't get along. Terrorism is never an answer to any conflict. Add to the mix, they both have nuclear weapons and you have a recipe for disaster for the entire world. I don't know the answer but if they could learn to agree to disagree and quit threatening the region's safety which ultimately would affect the whole world, we would all be better off.
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
1 Dec 08
My Dear Friend I totally agree with you .... India has been trying to convince Pakistan for last 40 years to stop sending terrorist to India,but it has not yet stopped ... Hope peaceful ways will work for Pakistan to understand before it is too late I think 40 years of peacful and diplomatic measures are enough how long can we bear injustice fearing nuclear war ..... But I will be happy if Pakistan stop supporting huge number of terrorists camps bordering India and realize that peace is important and needed for the world and all of us . Thanks for your response and such a nice information...! Happy Mylotting Take Care Ganesh
@ClassyCat (1214)
• United States
1 Dec 08
Hi Ganesh - - so sorry to hear of what has happened in your country. Sometimes it seems there are no answers to these horrible wars and or attacks. Terrorists are stirring up the whole world, wherever and whenever they can. It is their goal to dominate the world, and kill off those who disagree with them, or will not submit to their demands. I think that all of us who do believe in prayer, need to be praying for peace in your region, and for wisdom to the leaders of these two nations. I hope you did not lose any family or close friends in this attack. What those terrorists did was so bad, and the world needs to wake up, and come together in unity to remove their threats to all of humanity. You can't negotiate with hate filled murders, who are determined to destroy anyone who gets in their way of their plann for world domination.
• India
1 Dec 08
pakistan knows if it goes for nuclear war it will be finishes completely ,also pakistan doesnt have lauchpad for nuclear missiles
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
2 Dec 08
I don't think anyone should be attacking anyone. I do think they should go after those that are guilty of the attack but to attack a country for these few men is absurd. Innocent people always get killed in these aituations. fighting never brings peace...not ever. It is a dumb concept. FIGHTING for peace makes about as much sense as FCKING for virginity. It has never solved anything and never will.
1 person likes this
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
2 Dec 08
Hi Ganesh, I hope that the government of India will reflect upon what the father of your country, the late Mahatma Gandhi would do in such a situation. What would an attack on Pakistan accomplish other then revenge? Emotions run high at a time like this, but is more killing really the answer. I realize that your government has a big decision to make and I pray that they make the right one. This is a very difficult time in the history of the world. Blessings.
1 person likes this
@mayka123 (16584)
• India
2 Dec 08
Till now it is only known that some people living in Pakistan are responsible for the terrorists attacks. I dont think we should just now be blaming the whole country just because of a handful of people. Till it is not proved that the Government itself is responsible for these attacks I do not think we whould think of any counter attacks. It is the duty of our Government to find the actual culprits before they do more harm to others and only after that think of the action to be taken.
1 person likes this
• India
8 Dec 08
pakistan is playing a double game, in one hand they are making money from USA and United Kingdom and also harbouring and protecting the terrorists elements the bad 20 people, hardcore criminals and terrorists are staying in pakistan with full protection from pakistani army and ISI, if they say they are against terrorism then what this 20 criminals doing in pakistan.. it doesnt take more than 7 years to kill talibani militants hiding in pakistan hilly area, pakistan says bin laden is not in pakistan, but USA intelligence says he is.. pakistan is not allowing US Army to attack these terrorists camps and they even are not attacking it.. everytime there military claims they killed 100/150 talibani fighters but are they really killing talabani elements or they are killing poor people and labeling it taliban They are supporting it, one can easily find by there actions, are they not harbouring and protecting those terrorists.. they are why the world is waiting, god knows
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
9 Dec 08
Dear Friend Yes I agree with you to some extent. But dear Pakistan has become victim of its own creation called terrorism Initially Pakistan supported terrorists against India and a few other countries but later Pakistan fell victim to its own created terrorist groups . Although still some of the terrorists groups have hidden support from the goverment of Pakistan . Today Pakistan has accepted the involvement of its citizens from Laskarein Taiba behind the mumbai blasts and main suspects are arrested . Hope Pakistan's goverment will stop supporting some of the terrorist groups . Thanks for your response and such a nice information...! Happy Mylotting Take Care Ganesh
• India
10 Dec 08
well you got to see what they are doing, on the one hand all pretty good things against terrorism and also they are giving shelter to all those criminals.. is govt there not aware of these terrorists criminal staying there?, they are, and they allowing them to stay there, so that they can use them for ploy against india.. kuber came in and out from pakistan and india, pakistani navy was aware of it, it is also assumed that we were supporting it, army and isi chief were aware of it, may be they even played part in it.. Pakistani Army /Navy and ISI are involved in it there is a clear proof, that many from the pakistani authorities were involved in it, what do you make of it ?
• India
10 Dec 08
i would like to add, ISI and Army were sharing intelligence with Laskhare taiba, now how can you say they were not involved in it
@oppofwar (46)
• India
1 Dec 08
I agree India has given too many proofs about the involvement of Pakistan in terrorist activities and it has been too many years to bear it .But war is not still the solution as many people will be killed on both sides.Indian Govt is the weakest Govt which doesnt take any action and these Govt belong to corrupt parties who do everything only for Vote Bank. One way it can Be resolved IS to NUKE PAKISTAN (I think only 1 missile is enough as it equal to size of MP)
1 person likes this
@zatak07 (699)
• India
10 Dec 08
hi Ganesh, this is my second response as i would like to add few points. First of all before India takes this stringent measures against Pakistan, it should look upon this few risks. 1. India may forfeit the sympathy of other countries of the world. 2. Whole attention may be on stopping war rather than on stopping terrorism. 3. It may disrupt polls & situations in J&K as voters percentage turn out to be unexpectedly higher than expected. 4. There is a general intuition that it might be the terrorist plan to divert the attention of Pakistan from West frontier towards Eastern frontiers ,where Pakistan has promise the US & the NATO to flush out the terrorist across their border with Afghanistan. 5.It is estimated that it'll cost India about Rs 6000 crores of budget with thousands of innocent lives if Pak also retaliated. And this will aggravate the the economic status of India amid this crisis. 6. Since it was engineered by rogue elements in the ISI & the army, war could weaken Zardari's govt which is against the interest of India.
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
23 Dec 08
Dear Friend I agree with you what you have said ,but it has been 40 years of sponsered terrorism by Pakistan in India and the whole world . Have you noticed the dramatic increase in terrorists attack in India .Delhi,Banglore,Aehmdabad,Mumbai How long do you think India should keep on blaming Pakistan and allowing it to kill innocent people in our country . Do you think any wisdom in people of India staying in there houses fearing terrorists attack. You said 6000 crore will be spent on war do you imagine India is loosing billion of dollars of foreign investment due to terrorist attack in India. Do you beleive in saving sympathy of the world towards India or saving the normal life and routine of people of India . Pakistan is doing nothing at Afghan Border but is allowing indirect/hidden killing of US forces ,can you think of Pakistan killing its own creation .It is only the propaganda that Pakistan is doing in pressure from US and the world . Pakistan gives huge support to millitants organisation like Taliban whom you said that it is fighting which is just a illusion to us . I think ISI and army is part of goverment they are not private agencies . Thanks for your response and such a nice information...! Happy Mylotting Take Care Ganesh
• India
11 Dec 08
6000 crorers is very small sum, pakistan is actually playing double game , trying to look like helping USA, it is also suspected of sharing information with Taliban,
@comfort55 (1574)
• India
1 Dec 08
Today I read in the paper about Army being alert on the war front with Pakistan and in Pakistan also there was a meeting between the PM and President about the forces to be shifted from Afghanistan towards India. Now the point is how far, if the war starts, this will help India in fighting terrorism . But now some strong step has to be taken as for how far this will go on and innocent people die. No wonder many innocent people die during the war, but it has to be do or die this time. Every time there is an attack, many people die , then again after a while , everything is wiped out from people's mind. So if war is the solution to stop these attacks , then it has to be done.
@MrNiceGuy (4141)
• United States
23 Nov 09
Why should the US solve your problem? What business of it of ours? Not to mention, terrorists in Pakistan are not the Pakistani army. Why make a fight between the nations when your business is with the terrorists.
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
4 Dec 08
My Dear Friend I do not want any attack on innocent people of Pakistan , I think attack on Pakistan's millitant organisation in association with Pakistan ,US and world can solve this problem forever. Thanks for your response and such a nice information...! Happy Mylotting Take Care Ganesh
@fizanali (478)
• Pakistan
1 Nov 09
I don't think that India should attack Pakistan as fighting doesn't solve anything. First of all I think Pakistan is even more badly struck by these terrorists attacks than India. Second there is no proof that terrorists from Pakistan attack India. Third maybe Pakistan should attack India then for sending terrorists in our country. Fourth India is such a big country with 1/6 the world population ! who knows of many bad guys you already have probably in the millions, why not take car of them first? Fifth I don't think India has the guts to attack Pakistan as we have nuclear bombs pointing right your way !
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
2 Nov 09
I think US is actively acting in Pakistan as US and world have all the proof needed to eradicate terror groups in Paksitan like Alqaida etc .......I think Pakistan must cooperate with US forces for their survival inspite of having all the nuclear bombs Pakistan badly needs US assistance to get rid of terrorism ....... Definetly we want friendly relation ships with Pakistan being our neighbouring country and if Pakistan's goverment wants Afghanistan , India ,Iran are alwayws ready to cooperate the so called joint operation of US forces in Pakistan to further help Pakistan in acheiving stability we are always ready to help Pakistan as much as we can
• India
11 Dec 08
Pakistan is sharing information with taliban and all those terrorists involved, they are also helping them, all the core criminals of the world are staying in pakistan, and pakistan denies it, whatever proof is given to pakistan, it will always say that they need concrete proof.. and will never accept there terrorists involvement, and will hardly take any steps towards them Pakistani Media and also some muslim groups of Uk are actively promoting hatred, i have seen many of there websites, they have there own logic and writing all kinds of anti american,anti uk,anti india,anti israel articles these groups from uk are abusing freedom of speech given to them by govt of uk
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
22 Dec 08
Dear Friend I think that such groups are spread all over the world especially in Paksitan . But the whole world know the fact about what Pakistan has been trying to do , but untill the whole world wont unite it is tough to control terrorism and countries supporting it . Thanks for your response and such a nice information...! Happy Mylotting Take Care Ganesh
• China
2 Dec 08
i do not think so, people now in India need a safer eviroment, rather than another big attact which will probably rise another conflicts between India and Pakistan. it is not a wise way to solve the problem, and i am not for it. there need be more talks between two in advance. I FEEL SAD TO HEAR THE LIFE LOSE IN THE ATTACT RECENTLY
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
4 Dec 08
My Dear Friend Yes I dont want to attack Pakistan's innocent people but I think their terrorists camps should be destroyed immediately . Quinstessa , in India its a routinge thing we have terrorists attacks almost daily in some part of country . I feel unsecure in my own country . I am sorry to people of Kashmir in India which have sufferred most terrorists attack in India. Thanks for your response and such a nice information...! Happy Mylotting Take Care Ganesh
• China
7 Dec 08
what we hope is nothing but peace and safe
• India
3 Dec 08
Hello my friend Ganesh44 Ji, We are self sufficient to take action, everytime pakistan was defeated. Why we should rest our responsibilities on others. There are many Jai-Chand even now. Why we have to wait for 40 long yrs. Go into the history. It is just sad. Now politicians should be replaced with CEO;s and take proper action. May god bless you and have a great time.
@Ganesh44 (5547)
• India
4 Dec 08
My Dear Friend Yes I totally agree with you ..... We should not allow innocent killings of Indian citizens anymore . I think when water goes beyond head only one solution is left . I think India should take stron action either in world's cooperation if possible else alone but I think it would be better if world community joins us . Thanks for your response and such a nice information...! Happy Mylotting Take Care Ganesh
1 person likes this
• India
5 Dec 08
Hello my friend Ganesh44 Ji, You have said truely, and we all should combine to raise our voice at different forums so that proper action is initiated. may God bless you and have agreat time.