would you rather have apple pie or fruit salad?

well the way i see it is you get many more flavors to enjoy when eating the fruit,instead of the pie and ice cream we've got a bunch of weird and great tasting fruit here in florida. can i have both ?

I think I would have to go with good homemade apple pie. Unless I got to customize the fruit salad. I am very picky. A good fruit salad for me would have grapes and apples and maybe a strawberry or two with a good yogurt for a dressing.

Please please let me have both, I am feeling so hungary and both your offers are too tempting, none is worth leaving. Why giving a choice be generous and give both.

I do like both but would prefer applie pie. My grandmother use to make apple pie from scratch and it was wonderful. I use to watch her roll out the dough once she had it just to the right consistency. She added cinnamon and used fresh apples. Know for sure I couldn't copy her recipe for pie and also apple dumplings. She had amazing baking and cooking talents.

Hmmm... I always love fruit salad. It's a nutritious recipe and I just love tasting the different fruits in it. However, I haven't tasted yet a homemade apple pie with a vanilla ice cream. So for now, I'd go for the apple pie. Please send me my order now.

I'd have the fruit salad so I could get the variety of fruit. I love apple pie, but apple's just one fruit.

I like both so it is hard for me to say, so I won't. hahaha A lot of it has to do with the weather or the time of year. I would tend to lean more towards apple pie in the cooler weather and the fruit salad in the warmer months.

I would eat both if it were offered to me. It would be such a waste to refuse such good food. Cheers!!

I'm not a huge fan of apple pie so I would probably take the fruit salad one question though could I still have the ice cream with the fruit salad? That might make it even better. Fruit salad yum. It is so delicious. I really like it and think it would taste really good.

I will go for the apple pie every time, with double ice cream if possible.. I love fruit salad but my idea of dessert is something along the lines of cake or pie.. Fruit salad would be good on a hot summer day to go along with a sandwich for a meal.. Both are making me hungry now.. Sounds great, do you have any extra pie you can send me?? I will be watching the mail..

Since I know how to make a fruit salad, I will prefer a home-made apple pie. But can it not only be a piece but a whole pie instead? I don't mean to be greedy here, it's just that it is also one of my twin daughters' favorite. i don't know how to do it and it takes a lot of time and effort to do it compared to fruit salad, so whenever someone will offer apple pie, then hey! Count me in!

I think I'll take apple pie with ice cream please :D I like fruit salad but not as much as I like fresh fruits - I treat is as a "salad" by tossing it in my vegetable salad, but I'm not a fan of sweetened fruits in all purpose cream and condensed milk :P Apple Pie on the other hand is something I would never say No to. Thanks for the response on my discussion!

I would opt for the fruit not only because it is healthier but I like fruit better than sweets usually. I'm not really crazy about apple pie anyway so you made that decision pretty easy. Now throw a piece of hot fudge cake in there and I'll have to re think the whole thing!

I'd definitely have to say the fruit salad! Juicy fruit is so tasty and good for you. I am being very conscious about what I eat lately, so I think the fruit salad would be a wonderful addition to my diet! It's making me crave it now just thinking about it!!

Thats a tough choice, both sound really good. If I had to pick, I think I would go with the pie and ice cream, specially if it was a dutch apple.

I don't really care for cooked fruits or vegetables. I would have to choose the fruit salad. It would be alot healthier for me also.

Hi TnWoman! I would rather have an apple pie with a delicious scoop of vanilla ice cream on top of it at this time rather than the fruit salad. You see I have fruit salads all the time because I can easily prepare one but never learn how to bake pies. haha..So, I think an apple pie is a nice treat for me at this time. Take care and have a nice day! lovelots..faith210

Im on a diet at the moment so would probbaly choose the fruit salad but generally I would prefer the apple pie with ice cream. I like fruit salad but sometimes find that the fruit in them may be a bit sour. I think it may depend on what kind of fruit was in the fruit salad.

Well when it was just apple pie against a fruit salad I would have said fruit salad. Since you added the ice cream on the apple pie I am leaning a little more towards that. I guess it would depend on the time of day. But a nice warm apple pie with vanilla ice cream sounds really good to me right now.

Heck! I would eat an apple pie! I don't like homemade ones though. I like them from Taco Bell, or McDonalds! LOL