husband and wife 50/50 with expenses? Interesting to know this!!!!

@Bebs08 (10681)
United States
April 29, 2009 10:45pm CST
It makes me ponder upon this situation or family set up. A friend of mine told me that she and her husband share 50/50 with the household expenses. They will split the bills. For example their telephone bills is $50? the wife will give her $25 share and husband give his $25 share too!! then I said.. WHAT? why you are doing that? Can you not pay it as a whole with your joint money? anyway, you are husband and wife? She then told me.. NOPE, they have separate account so every thing they will spend, they will share 50/50 hahaha... it makes me laugh.. Our set up is not like that. For sure I can not give 50/50 because I am not working... hubby does all. When I have money, I just use it for my own thing... nor for the general need in the house. Well, I am just wondering if how many of you also adopt this style? 50/50 share? I know of a few who have different cases.. like the husband is the one controlling the money that even the ATM of the wife, the husband has it. I also know of someone who split the expenses.. they divided it.. and both will be incharge for the specific bills they agreed to take charge. Well, it works good for them. How about you? do you have something to share?
8 people like this
32 responses
@lynnemg (4529)
• United States
30 Apr 09
My husband and I believe that the money that is brought into the house is not his/mine, it is ours. He chose not to have his name anywhere on the bank account, so I have to handle the finances. That works fine for us, but only because we don't try to hide anything from each other. If he asks how much is in the bank, i tell him, if he asks to see the check book, I show him. If he asks me to take money out for him, I do it as long as I know that the bills are covered first. I don't think that a 50/50 style would work for us at all. I guess it does for some people, but to me, when you are married, everything is for the entire family.
2 people like this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
correct!! I agree with that. I don't understand why it is like that. She then said that it is suppose to be the husband's responsibility to provide the family but then she earns more than he does so, she decided to handle her own money and share half of the bills they have. hehehe well, it works for them but I think it unusual for husband and wife. Maybe that is good for lived in partner.
@ebsharer (5515)
• United States
30 Apr 09
My husband and I know that our bills are about $2,000 a month so we each put $250 a week from our paychecks in the “bill” account and the remainder goes in to the “spending” account. Both of us use the spending account and never has either one of us said I put X amount in so I get to spend more then you. We both use it for what we want. We also both know that’s all we get for the week. We respect that one of us may need more then the other because of gas in the car or because I use some of the “spending” for extra groceries. See we budget $150 a month in groceries and any thing over that has to come from the spending account. Same with gas we budget $100 a month from our bill account anything over that comes from the spending account. The reason we put equal amounts in the bill account is neither one of us brings home $500 a week at this point (sad isn’t it!) I work part time and although he works full time half his paycheck goes to child support for his 2 kids from a previous relationship. Boy it would be nice if we had is entire paycheck only 6 more years on one kid and 10 more on the other … I know that’s mean of me but if you knew the whole story you wouldn’t think so. My point is we both pay the bills equally but not because we have separate accounts or anything but because its what works for the way we budget.
1 person likes this
@ebsharer (5515)
• United States
1 May 09
Our budget for groceries is 150 from that account. We spend more then that but it comes from our spending account. The same goes with our gas ... it costs more then a hundred to fuel up both cars every month but anything over the 100 comes from spending. Like I said BILL account is for NEEDS and SPENDING account is for WANTS. 100 a month is gas would get both of us to and from work thats it. Over that becomes a want and has t come out of that account.
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
Oh!! I do understand that. Mu hubby also is supporting his kids from the previous marriage but they are now older. He has the full custody of the kids and that he has to pay everything. But no the eldest is already in his own. He is 20 years old and in college. The other one is 17 years old and in Junior high. She will be 18 next year and soon will be in her own. Well, yours is too long yet. Good that your expenses for food and gas are just very small. Our weekly grocery budget is $120 with the 3 of us.. because our teen ager has lots of beauty needs and her food are too expensive. She is the one who will select her food. And the gas is $50 a week. Imagine that? and only my husband is working? I hope I can have a job this year.
@lexus54 (3572)
• Singapore
30 Apr 09
When I got married 22 years ago, my wife and I decided that we will open a joint account, from which we will draw for paying household expenses and bills. How much we each contribute to this joint account depends on each of our earning ability. We are both university graduates, came out to work almost the same time, so we didn't earn too differently from one another. Therefore our contribution to the joint account was almost equal. This arrangement worked well for us through all these years, and still do. Sometimes we vary the amount of giving because of changes in income, and we normally don't count every penny that goes in. Not once have we quarreled over our contributions to the joint account. I guess in an arrangement like this, if one party does not work and earn, then the other party has to contribute the lion's share to the household bills.
1 person likes this
@lexus54 (3572)
• Singapore
1 May 09
I really think your friend should maintain a joint account. What goes in depends on what's equitable to the couple; whether a 50/50 arrangement is fair or not is really for them to say. Different couples have different yardsticks to determine how much each should contribute to the household expenses. Once there's a joint account and the money goes into the pool, the couple just makes all payments from this account and they do not have to assess for each bill if each person has to split 50/50 or 40/60 or whatever ratio. I think it is easier to manage this way.
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
Well, in the case of my friend, this happened when she starts working. Before when her husband had the income. he has to pay everything. Now that they both are working, she said, it's now the time to share but 50/50 to be fair. hahahah I don;t understand why she does that. I did not say anything.. I just listened to her. Well, your set up is very common to a typical couple.
@SomeCowgirl (32191)
• United States
4 May 09
My fiance and I aren't going to be splitting anything like that. It's our money so while we do have separate accounts we still consider it our money. We did have a joint account but having no job and making money online, we had to have separate accounts. In any case, I think that a man and woman should spend together and not apart, and if one doesn't work any money that the one who doesn't work does retrieve should be considered to be used as part of the bills, or used for a day out, etc. To each their own though, and I respect your using your money as you wish, I know though that if I were to not work and my fiance do, I would consider any money I make as our money, as I do now.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
12 May 09
That is right!! all the money we have should be considered as out money but when I spend the money I earned for other things, I will let hubby know about it.
@zweeb82 (5653)
• Malaysia
30 Apr 09
I think this is no laughing matter as this setup will kill!~ This legalism / religious setup is so rigid & selfish, well, at least that's my humble opinion!~When it comes to marriage, it's about a covenant of love & was that not the foundation in the beginning? If not, I think things will definitely go haywire along the way!~Of course both the husband & wife takes equal responsibility but in such a rigid manner!~
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
Well, things like this will work fine to other couples and it does not to some.
1 person likes this
@zweeb82 (5653)
• Malaysia
1 May 09
Well, I guess so. But the love & mutual trust must always be there!~
@silverjam (969)
• United States
11 May 09
Well if it works fine for them then so be it. I heard similar cases among my friends too and I guess it's only applicable for those who ar earning well and has more or less the same income range. We cannot do that because I don't have a permanent job and we don't have a joint account as well. My husband does most of the bills as of the moment but am helping too.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
12 May 09
Oh!!! good because your husband earns more than you do and he is responsible of paying the bills? my friend's hubby's income is not enough for the bills now that both of them have work.. hahaha I don't know why. When my friend was not yet working she keeps on complaining because their money is not enough... that's maybe the reason why they share 50/50?
• Philippines
1 May 09
That is really interesting to know about that kind of set up. I and my hubby are combining our earnings, when I was yet working. I quit working few months ago and now he is the only one earning. But I am the one controlling the budget. He will give his salary to me. I just give him allowance for what he needs. We both agreed of what and how much to spend and with what. It is just funny to hear a married couple having that kind of set up. It might be normal if they are not married.
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
Well, that's a good thing for you. thanks for sharing..
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
30 Apr 09
I could be completely wrong, but I think that couples who split 50/50 are those who have trouble emotionally giving 100% or surrendering 100% of their love. I think it is a power struggle that is indicative of the power struggle that goes on in their heart with being married in general. In other words, I think it's a way of saying "you can have THIS much of me, but I'm reserving some of me that YOU can't have!"
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
I'm not so sure of what they are thinking in this situation bu according to my friend, there are times that her husband would let her pay some of the expenses that he suppose to do as a husband and provider. So, then the wife said, she will just give 50 percent not the total amount. hahahaha.... I don;t know,, but that is what she said.
@UK_Shree (3603)
30 Apr 09
I am not married yet but when I do get married I would not like it to be this way. I would like to think that we can trust and love each other enough so that we do not feel anything one thing belongs solely to either of us. My mum and dad have always shared everything and it is my mother that has always kept an eye on the finances. My father has always trusted her and it has worked well for over 30 years!
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
Wow!! that is a typical Family in certain races. I like that also but when the other is not honest in spending the joint money, the problem arise. Maybe this is one of the reasons why my friend had this idea.
• Philippines
30 Apr 09
i don't have any issues if ever we shared 50/50. But i have been here for years and my visa doesn't allow me yet to work, so sorry for hubby i can't give that 50/50 thing he needs. Besides, he doesn't mind it at all if he shoulders all of our expenses including his parents. But i would be glad to help if i have too. This work online will be just an extra income, but i don't consider it as an exchange for a regular paying job. If i can find and be allowed to work, i will do that, no questions asked. About joint account and separate account, i don't know if this country i am now would allow me to open up anew. Not unless i applied for international bank, probably they will allow it, but i am not sure. i would like to have a separate account and i also like a joint account with hubby.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
I am not working also, but we have joint account. I can put in some extra bucks also from my online earnings but that is not enough for bills or other things. hehehe.. I would love to help too whenever I can.
@cobra1368 (702)
• United States
30 Apr 09
We started like that, then we merged into one account, because that is just so much easier. He does our finances, but we both have unlimited access to OUR account. We are both owners of OUR account. I can spend what I want to, and so can he. Large purchases are discussed first, but he pays all the bills, and I just shop. Works very well for us. :)
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
Well, that works with others very well too. Big purchase would be discuss and the little amount just leave up to each partner. Anyway, it's not that big to ruin the budget.
@meandmy3 (2227)
• United States
1 May 09
yea, not I am a SAHM so I do not share in our cost 50/50 I do however keep our house clean, him feed, clothes clean etc.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
Oh well, that is your 50/50 share in the household.. That is more than money can buy.
@pickoy (733)
• Philippines
1 May 09
lol... I've heard couples like that and their arrangement works for them, its just strange for me. Coz they're like brothers and sisters in a transaction... lol... We're pretty much the same, hubby takes care of all the expenses in our house, he gives me his whole salary and he just takes a certain amount for his allowance. I do the budgeting and separate certain portions for the groceries, utility bills, wage of the maid, my own allowance and some for our monthly savings. I sell my artworks and I earn from them. My earnings remain to be my own and he does not take it from me. But I save them for future investments, the things i've earned from my paintings and part of his salary that i've saved when combined is the one i use to buy our own pc and other stuff in the house. We talk about the stuff we wish to buy and we compromise how much part of our savings will be used. 50/50 is not the case for us, my husband believes he's the provider and the man of the house and its a good thing... at some point i love being a woman... lol...
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
That is a good setting too. Well, good for you, you can have saving from your earnings and that of your hubby. I don't have anything like that.
@kenange (21)
• United States
30 Apr 09
I did taxes this year for a local CPA, and we came upon a couple similar to this. They filed jointly, but each had their share of the property taxes and any charitable donations were in one name or the other. They even had copies of the tax checks, showing that each spouse wrote a check for 1/2 of the amount owed. My husband's and my checks go into a joint account where the bills are paid from. We each have an amount that separately goes into our own savings accounts, and we kind of consider it our personal "play" money. But, we don't track anything to insure that we're each paying for 50% of the household's expenses.
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
Well, this set up depends upon the couple. But for me I still want to have joint spending. Not considering the 50/50.
• India
30 Apr 09
My hubby and me have individual accounts too and whatever we spend for the family, we spend from our individual accounts and salary cheques. If not exactly 50/50 then I think its almost equal of how much each of us spend though it might not be always in cash. My hubby pays all the bills and I pay for our son’s education, for various AMCs of machineries and also some fixed insurance savings for our son’s future education. That way the burden is not too much on any particular person yet the things do get done.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
That is also good!! well this things are applicable to couples who are both earning. I also have another friend who have this kind of set up like yours. And when the other needs money he/she will borrow from each other and they should pay in dues time.. hahahah they both are accountants that is why they are very meticulous when it comes to finances.
@sudalunts (5523)
• United States
30 Apr 09
I have always made more money than my husband, even now on unemployment I am bringing more home. I handle all of the finances. All of the money, goes into the checking account, and I handle the bills. I know of people who split bills etc. I even know a woman who does not contribute to the mortgage at all, she pays only her personal bills, (selfish). Our method works very well, with the little money we have.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
I agree with you. That's the right description SELFISH. Well, if they both are earning, they should each contribute whatever is the expenses. I don't like this type where the wife pays only her bills?
@crasks (49)
30 Apr 09
The wife is certainly, what can I call her, maybe 'lovely'? I work, so does my husband but he would never even dream of asking for me to contribute 10%! I contribute as I see fit. But isn't it the husband's responsibility to care for the wife materially, whether or not she makes money. Like the others have said, maybe there's not much of a marriage to talk about there.
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
Well, her husband's earning is not enough for everything. Well, maybe for the bills he can afford it but for some other personal needs of the wife? nothing more left for that. So, then when the wife has work, she does contribute 50/50. hahahaha weird but that's the ways it is in their set up.
@chulasa (69)
• Philippines
30 Apr 09
I'm a full time house wife. When my husband was still here, (he is now working abroad) he gave me his ATM and I take care all the bills, then we would go to the grocery and buy stuffs for the house. He would just ask for some allowance from me. Then the rest of the moneys is mine (hehe) to save. I just tell him if we lack some money (he'll find extra work) or we had saved a lot for this month. Now that he's abroad he send me almost all his salary and left himself a little sum for his allowance. He knows that all of his money goes to bills, food and our child need. I'm not into clothes or jewelries or make ups, etc. so we don't argue about my spendings.
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
Oh!! that is really good!! if a wife is a wise spender, the husband will entrust all the earnings he has.. well if he earns also enough or more than enough for the family needs. A good wife knows how manage the finance and buy only things needed and with the husband's knowledge and approval.
• Australia
30 Apr 09
This sort of lifestyle seems sort of greedy. In my relationship, i believe what's mine is also hers. Living like this seems like a bad way to connect and share with each other
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
Well, whatever we call it, that's what it is and they are doing it right now. I think they are comfortable with this set up.
• United States
30 Apr 09
I don't think that would work for my relationship. I know that some people use money as power in relationships so I can understand the thought process behind splitting expenses 50/50. The problem for me is that there are necessary and beneficial things people do that don't earn money. If you don't work outside the home you still work. It takes time, energy, and talent to manage a household. If my partner comes home from a really bad day and I'm able to be there, listen to him, offer advice and support, in addition to having taken care of the household, isn't that as valuable as paying half the electric bill?
1 person likes this
@Bebs08 (10681)
• United States
1 May 09
I agree with you. Exactly right!! That is really sweet to be always there for him even if you are not earning a lot to contribute to the family finance. That is a good partnership than splitting the expenses. If that happens, as if they are not husband and wife but just a lived in partner who wants to survive.