Is it really worthwhile investing all your money and buying a house?

India
June 2, 2010 4:07am CST
I have bought a house, but not in a city because I could not afford to buy even a small piece of land or an apartment .So, I decided to move out to a smaller place and bought a opiece of land there and built a little house which I have given for rent. I am now living in the city in a rented place. On second thoughts what have I achieved by doing this? I wonder if it was really wortwhile having put all my savings into buying the house where I may or may not ever live. The only consolation seems to be the fact that the prices have appreciated and the returns , if I decide to sell would be good. What do you all think? is it worth it? is it better to rent out a place instead and enjoy all that money that has gone into the house ?
3 people like this
21 responses
@kiran8 (15348)
• Mangalore, India
2 Jun 10
Hi sumant, I am all for investing in land , property , house or apartment.In your case you can never be sure what happens in the future and no matter what you have a house of your own.As of now you may be living away from it, but it is still helping you out by providing an income. As for having put in all your savings, I feel that since you have more time to save, there is no worry and the property price will always appreciate. I feel that what you have done is wise and a good investment in the long run...
• India
2 Jun 10
Hi kiran, I guessed it !that you would be all in support of buying a house, most ladies are !No doubt there is more opportunity to save and enjoy the good life, but sometimes I have a little doubt about the wisdom of my decision to build a house!
@kiran8 (15348)
• Mangalore, India
4 Jun 10
Hi sumant, I happened to listen to a friend who is in the mutual funds and is a financial advisor.He was showing me facts and figures where in he actually showed me that even by investing 10 lakhs in bank deposits after 20 years the money grew more than the real estate prices...It makes one wonder.. have I confused you lol, different view point each time
• India
8 Jun 10
Not at all kiran, We have to take all view points into account.One can never be rigid about any subject because there is evolution and addition all the time and we have to change according to times.One cannot be a stick in the mud holding on to some ancient views and ideas.I too have gone through these figures which are amazing ! If one had the wisdom to put away even a fraction of what an individual spends on trivialities !have a nice day :))
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
3 Jun 10
To put all your money in a house where you may or not live is not a wise decision. Liquid assets , [provided you are the controlling authority of your house, holds your pursestrings firmly and would not allow indiscriminate spending by wife or children just because money is in the bank or in liquid assets]are better to handle. Long term appreciation is possible from stock markets if you invest wisely on professional counselling, have the right attitude and is patient. If you use the word' enjoy' all the money that has gone into the house then it implies that the money is there to be spent.THen , it would not be there for a rainy day. In that case, this built asset may come in handy [in the event of a daughter's marriage or son's education]. On the other hand, money used prudently and kept carefully for emergencies , is better in other forms of liquid assets. Objectively speaking house should be bought for living purposes[if you are unable to handle the shifting hasslesand if you are to stay in one place throughout your career]. In your case , you have already done it. THere is no point thinking over what you have done already unless you want to sell it and are sure to reinvest it elsewhere for better returns..'Better returns' is the operative word.
• India
3 Jun 10
WOW resounding argument there ! thanks a lot kalav for a very detailed and complete understanding of the economics of investment in property and home.I agree with you argument that liquid cash is always more handy when it comes to emergencies and that is one of the major drawback of a land asset.In my case as I explained elsewhere the land was bought because I liked the setting and more importantly the price !The house construction followed and now I have rented it out.As of now, I have no intention of living there, but I am trying to think on those terms for my future days...
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
5 Jun 10
Thank you Sreesumant and I pass on the compliment to my chartered accountant of a husband.Though he did not give me the answer, I derived this kind of thought proccess from him when earlier, he used to talk about inflation, the appreciation of money ,the hassles of using a house property as an investment proposition. As far as you are concerned, what is done is done. Perhaps , one day you may go and settle there and the area may beocome a developed self sufficent one. Till then you may have to manage. But normally, to own a house and collect rent does bring in its share of troubles because you have to assess the tenant, get a good one and keep maintaining the house too spending money and repairing it periodically after the first few years.
• India
8 Jun 10
So it is borrowed and fine tuned knowledge and that is the way it should be.We all learn from each other and add our own experience to it and come up with a different dimension ! What you say is true as regarding the renting out of a house.It has its negativities.But so far so good.I have good tenants who have even constructed a car shed for their second car at their own expense , the only favor asked was not to increase the rent for a year which suits me fine.My future as of now is vague, but as days and months pass by I am more inclined to the idea of going and living in my house some day !
@reckon21 (3479)
• Philippines
9 Jun 10
I think you had done a good decision while investing for a house and lot area. A property especially land and house is a good investment. It is also good that you have it rented for others because you were not even around to live it and take care of it. One day the prices of lands and houses will soar up and you can sell it and buy another one and sell it again. It's like a buy and sell business. It's an exciting business if you just have to really approach it the way it should be.
• India
22 Aug 10
I too thought so that it is good to invest in a house instead of in shares or let it lying around in my bank account.Prices have shot up beyond my imagination and I am glad I did what I did though I was skeptical at that time .Now I am thinking of buying a small apartment in the city where I live so that I can save on the rent and pay it toward s loan .
@besthope44 (12123)
• India
12 Jun 10
Yes it really an asset investing on home. Its a life long asset for you and your generation.
• India
22 Aug 10
yup ! :) I am beginning to think so now - thanks for the participation !
• India
5 Jun 10
Buying a piece of land at a cheaper rate in a smaller place, building a house there is good idea, you can sell that at a much higher price later if you like, but if you hear my advise never sell a house you built or got as paternal property.. Thanks for sharing. Welcome always. Cheers. Prof
• India
8 Jun 10
Hi Pofessor that is sound advise ! It is another matter if you have more than one house or property.But when you have just one house and property , it doesnt make any sense to sell it .The price of land is normally on the rise and my house price too has appreciated.Thanks for your valid views and have a nice day :))
@jinjer168 (1596)
• Philippines
22 Aug 10
Hi there! For me, its a good thing that you buy a house of your own and be able to rented it for someone else so it would contribute additional money for you. Money nowadays is so hard to work for but so easy to spend. Its better that you invest it for something like a house and lot than you spend your money for something that's not appreciating its value like gadgets or brand new car. As we all know, lot always appreciates its value when years pass by so its a good move for you. Have a nice day ahead!
• India
26 Oct 10
Hello Jinjer, I agree that buying a house and renting it out was one of the few wise decisions I have made in life LolLol Buying a brand new car is defintely not for me since I am comfortable with my old car and as a financier know very well that it is a depreciating asset in the long run - in fact right from the day you buy it ! thanks a lot for your feed back , have a nice day !!
@youless (112146)
• Guangzhou, China
4 Jun 10
It seems it is a good investment to buy a house today. As the house price is keeping crazy expensive day after day. It doesn't make a sense at all. I love China
• India
8 Jun 10
Hello, I agree that the way the property market has been behaving seems kinda crazy ! One can never be sure of the future trends .thanks for the response ! Nice day :))
@elmiko (6630)
• United States
2 Jun 10
well at least your making money of the house you invested all your money into. personally i wouldn't invest all my money into any one thing. its too risky.
• India
2 Jun 10
Thats true elmiko ! So far so good as far as the prices are concerned and I have been earning through the rent - thanks a lot for the response :))
@haiershen (1080)
• China
4 Jun 10
most of people have no qulity skills of raising money,so they always treat buy a house is a good investment.sometimes,except the store at banking,that's the only way of investment.on the other hand, a house of they own always go on comfortable.so i think it is worth. tks!
• India
8 Jun 10
Hi, So you feel that buying a house is a worthwhile proposition ! It may be so, but one has to wait for a long long time to see any results in some places.Whereas in large cities and towns the fluctuation is far more ,so also the rise in price - all the best and thanks for the response :))
@artistry (4152)
• United States
2 Jun 10
...Hi there Sreesumant, What you have done is to make an investment in one of the best things you could invest in. Hopefully it didn't cost you too much to build even though you said you used all your savings. With time the appreciation will grow as you have already stated. But beyond that real estate is a tax shelter, you get a deduction on your income taxes, although I am assuming you are in the states, as I know nothing about other areas of the world. It may have been better for you to live in the property at least for a while rather than rent a place for yourself because in essence you have two house payments as you rent. But its an offset because the rent from your property should be paying some of your mortgage cost unless you were able to build the house mortgage free. Then you have a great investment property. The next home you purchase could be a duplex where you live in one part and rent out the other, letting the renter pay for the property and building equity. If you want to start a Donald Trump empire so to speak "o). Real estate is an excellent investment, try to hold the property as long as you can to get a better return on your investment. Take care.
• India
2 Jun 10
Hi artistry, those are very encouraging words !I did spend all my savings no doubt, but, I have built the house in the most economical manner possible. Material was supplied by me, which helped and I used contract labor , not an architect.I have no mortgage at all. I have spent my own money on buying the land and building the house as well !So the rent is an additional income which is helping me with my own rent.The property prices in that part has gone up.thanks a lot for your views and advice. Yes I will hold on to it :))
@p3ks626 (6538)
• Philippines
3 Jun 10
For me, a house is a good investment. Its part of our primary needs. When I was young, my dad bought a house when I was already 6 years old because that was the only time when we got to have money to buy a house good for all of us. My husband's family invested on getting a house later because they focused more on educational plans and every thing like that. Bottom line is that, house it still an important and a primary investment.
• India
3 Jun 10
Hi, That is a good sensible view ! House is no doubt a solid investment and an asset that is there to stay and appreciate in value. I am beginning to develop similar views now as regards my house and the investment on it. I am almost sure that I am not going to loose it- all the best :))
@tomitomi (5429)
• Singapore
2 Jun 10
Hi Sreesumant! Of course it's worth it. The value of a house would surely rise. In a few years time it is going to worth more than you bought it. That's where people start to think of selling it. But it's not that always easy because you have to think a new house to live in. Well, anyway it's worth investing your money into buying a house. If you have space to rent out a part of your house that would be a great idea. And it's also wise to save up on rainy days...
• India
2 Jun 10
Hi tomitomi, I too thought on similar lines.If you decide to sell your house, you need aplace to live , unless of course you are planning to buy a smaller, cheaper place which would leave you with some money !
@winjayoma (186)
• Philippines
3 Jun 10
It is good also to buy houses as a way of investment... but it is more good if you buy farms. After few years, you will see that your money is being doubled
• India
3 Jun 10
I am not too sure about buying farm land.It needs upkeep and labor force to keep it going, and, only when that is taken care of can one expect any sort of returns.
• Canada
2 Jun 10
You should probably read this: http://www.mint.com/blog/goals/rent-vs-buy/ The belief that buying a house is a good investment is really outdated and, often, simply not true. "Houses are assets too, but it's a mistake to expect them to offer a regular rise in price. Houses pay hefty dividends to their owners in the form of living space - that's the real return on housing investment - and the basic economics of housing doesn't point to perpetual price growth."
• India
3 Jun 10
Hi, Thanks for providing the link.Will go through it at leisure.I too have had certain reservations about buying a house initially.However , I bought it on the spur of the moment , simply because the plot of land was going cheap as compared to metros and I was told that keeping money in bank account attracts more tax...
@ellago (127)
• Philippines
18 Jun 10
If your work is in the city, it's ok to rent if you don't have a money to buy a house. But since you already bought a house in another place, try to maximize it's potential by getting tenants for the house. By doing this, you can leverage on the rental of your property vs. the rent in the place of your work. On your question about investing all your money in a house is not a good idea if this house would not generate you income. We need to know how to leverage time and money. You can use your cash for investments that can give you passive income.
@rajaiv0810 (1012)
• Philippines
2 Jun 10
I couldn't say you did the right thing or not. Buying a house could only be considered as an investment when it is earning money for you. A lot of people actually have a misconception of buying a house. They always thought that buying a house is an investment what they didn't know that it is not. In fact, it is a liability. Why? Because you are paying mortgages, maintenance, taxes etc. In your case, if you bought it for future use like selling it in the future for a bigger bucks then it is good. It's just like investing in a stock market, letting your money stay their for the time being until it will earn its value. Just cross your finger that real estate market there will always be good. Now if you bought it with a mortgage and you are also renting at the same time i think it's quite bad idea unless the rent can cover the mortgage. Now if you bought it cash and the rent there can cover for your expenses then that is a good investment.
• India
2 Jun 10
Hi rajaiv, what you say makes sense ! There are expenditures involved when you have a house of your own.Although I have no mortgage payments, I have to pay the tax and other so far minor repair charges, get it painted etc;But since I am renting it out , it is adding to my income so it is not a bad proposition.I am crossing my fingers and hoping that property market will see an upward trend in the future and not stagnate.
@srganesh (6340)
• India
2 Jun 10
it should have happened in the reverse.Building a house in the city and leaving it for rent and you,living in the outskirts of the city in a peaceful environment is what I would suggest.No problem,what you have done now is also good.The house you have bought in the outer can be a good place on your retirement.
• India
2 Jun 10
Hello srganesh, If that were possible then I would not have to worry.It is because i dint want to take a mortgage and dint want to spend an astronomical sum that I ended up buying a house in a small town.I too would think that it might come in handy at a later stage in my life ! thanks for the response :))
@chillpill90 (1936)
2 Jun 10
I think if you buy a house you should live in it if you can , if not then renting it out is a good way as you can use the rent to pay off the mortgage. By owning a house it means that unlike so many people in the world you can actually say that you own some where not many people buy houses anymore they just rent.
• India
2 Jun 10
Hi chillpill, I have no mortagage , the house is totally mine.But I have put in all my savings into it and thats what makes me wonder at times.Whether it is worth it? I could have had a blast with all that money !
@med889 (5941)
2 Jun 10
I think instead of renting a house and live in it it is better you had not invested the money in the other house, you could have saved the money till you get a bigger sum and decide what you can do with it. Now since you have already purchased the house so maybe you can put a sign which says "for renting", you can get money from there too.
• India
2 Jun 10
Hello med, I am already getting rent out of the house that I have purchased and utilising it for the rent that I pay for the house I am living in - in a different city.It was an impulsive decision to buy the land and build the house . i was in such a frame of mind !
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
2 Jun 10
It worth it. You are having some income in return for having it rented. If you asks my opinion,i won't sell the house. I will keep it for rent,at least,for years your expenses will be returned to you,and still the house is yours. You can never tell,one day you will find yourself wanting to live in the house that you've built.
• India
2 Jun 10
Hi jaiho, that makes sense ! Yes it does seem like it is worth having bought the house.I may never sell the house since that is the only asset I have and unless I am desperate I am not likely to see that house.As of now it is helping me with the rent and who knows about tomorrow ?