Are you spiritual or religious?

United States
February 23, 2011 7:52am CST
I found that many people seem to have the notion that religious is the same as being spiritual.- My findings are this: Religion is a way to become spiritual. But someone can be spiritual without religion. What do you think about this and also what do you think is the difference between spirituality and religion?
4 people like this
12 responses
• United States
25 Feb 11
I think religion is a social aspect of spirituality. It makes people feel like they belong to something they believe in. Spirituality is beyond this physical universe in my opinion. I think we are all binded together and to the universe with a source of energy that flows abundantly through us. When it flows freely through us, we get that great feeling of love and appreciation. Religion is based on externalities while spirituality is about cultivating inner peace and happiness. People that are truly spiritual know that all they need is their inner loving voice to guide them.
1 person likes this
@_sketch_ (5742)
• United States
30 Apr 11
@meditated1 I love your explanation so much, very well worded, kinda poetic. :)
• United States
25 Feb 11
Hey meditated, I love your comment and I think it is on the right spot to sum it all up. Thank you.
@deebomb (15304)
• United States
23 Feb 11
I wish someone would explain just what being spiritual really is. I know what being religious is but don't understand the being spiritual is.
• United States
23 Feb 11
Agreed. After reading this, I was going to describe myself as partially spiritual, as I'm not religious yet still feel many things are connected with energy and bla yada, but I wasn't sure if that was "spiritual" or not. Is it like believing in ghosts or something?
• United States
25 Feb 11
To be spiritual means that you have experienced 'God's' existence. These experiences are usually very difficult to describe in words.
@_sketch_ (5742)
• United States
30 Apr 11
I agree with you lakshmi11 for the fact that you put parenthesis around "God". For me, God is nature, God is all of us, not a higher being, not separate from us.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
23 Feb 11
I am not given to emotions, so figure I am not that spiritual. I am a little bit but that is in trusting God, but not in the fact that others feel, that I stare out in the sky and meditate and look at the trees and sigh. I am religious in that I studied the Bible, and took catechism, read the scriptures, etc., but not that like some of my friends who when the question comes up about an aspect of the Commandments come up with "we must not steal" or repeats an adage instead of giving an example or expanding on it. For instance some say "you must not lie," but I will go into "what if you were protecting Jews from the Nazis," would you say "come right in they are in the basement?" So I guess I am rather evenly balanced between the both. And a person can be spiritual, the gazing into the sky and sighing, for instance and that leads to people becoming Buddhists or believers in the American Native beliefs. Whereas in religion you believe in that particular religion because you study it. Spiritualism just needs emotion, it does not need studying.
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
26 Feb 11
It depends on what spiritual experiences they are. After all, staring into your naval might lead to entering into the realm of dark forces. That is the danger of just going into spiritual experiences. It would be merely entering into your own mind and wold be compared to those who sit under a tree and feel that they do not need to join a church. Even spiritual experiences have to come from the right place. God can commune with you when you walk or do your work, but it is not in a human voice, but by HIS spirit. And HE will reveal something to you, but you do not need to be swept up into the sky, levitate, or have a mist like figure appear in front of you. Of course, if you are on your bed asleep and dreaming, God may speak to you then and you may be floating or in my case, I mght be at a concert hall, but I would not know if it is God trying to reveal a spiritural truth or whether I am upset because I was not able to be a concert singer when I was growing up.
• United States
25 Feb 11
You can study something with your consciousness as most people do, but you can also study something with your subconscious, which leads to spiritual experiences.
1 person likes this
• Mexico
23 Feb 11
Hi lakshmi: I agree with you. In fact a person can be religious, which means following in theory what a religion says you have to do but not a spiritual person. You are being spiritual when you make a real connection with God and change the way you live so I have to say that I totally agree with you. ALVARO
• United States
25 Feb 11
Thank you starsailover, I agree with you. Great explanation of what being spiritual is!!
@LeighB (700)
• Thailand
23 Feb 11
Yes, I think this statement is most probably true. A person in my eyes can be spiritual without religion. The difference between the two that I was once taught at school was - Religion is the belief or practice of faith in a religion and a higher being (God) to worship. A path of life with set ideals. Spirituality is an inner feeling and emotion, where people try to live by the doing of good deeds, meditation, acts of kindness and believe not in one rligion but in a multitude of different religious beliefs blending them into a set of values to live ones life by. These people don't need a temple, church or place of worship nor a written book to follow as they believe worship can be at any time, anywhere. Whether this is true or not I don't know. It was just what I was taught.
• United States
25 Feb 11
Hey LeighB, To have a spiritual experience is a wonderful thing, which makes you very peaceful and humble. Even if the experience is very small. Maybe you can have some kind of experience in this direction also. For example if you are out in nature you can feel a certain kind of connection to the universe which is far beyond words. -
@DanaS2011 (351)
• United States
24 Feb 11
I agree that there's a difference between spiritual and religious. I have no religion but I am a very spiritual person. I have my own beliefs based off what I feel, dream or what I am witnessing with my own eyes.You are right people do become religious and you can be spiritual without a religion. Can someone please tell me the definition of a religion?
• United States
27 Feb 11
Religion seems to be a framework of what to think of and do with spiritual experiences. If God gives you a revelation or just 'makes contact' with someone who has never heard of God in any form, what does that person do? A spiritual experience doesn't fit into the normal thinking of that person and I was just wondering last night, what does a person with no knowledge of any religion do with a spiritual experience? Tell someone and start a new religion?
• United States
25 Feb 11
I think of Religion as a help to become spiritual. Sort of like someone who tries to learn how to walk and he needs a banister to hold on to,or a cane so he doesn't fall. He practices for a while until he can go without the help.- And then he has become spiritual.
@_sketch_ (5742)
• United States
30 Apr 11
I am spiritual, but I am not religious. I do not belong to any church nor identify with any religious group, but I believe in something more than just the physical world. I identify with what someone could call a spirit. Spirituality is connectedness with the true self; exploring and listening to your inner-self. I do not believe in any god or higher being. I believe that all things are equal and connected. I believe in a collective conscious. I believe in energy and the balancing force called karma. I agree that religion is a way to become spiritual. It is a type of spiritual path. We just all need to remember that you don't need to be religious to be spiritual and you don't need to be spiritual to be religious.
@LadyMarissa (12148)
• United States
23 Feb 11
I am a Christian who feels more spiritual than religious!!! I trust in my faith & my heart feels the blessings of the world. I don't feel the need to brow-beat everybody else into submission of my religion!!! I feel my faith is between me & my God & don't feel that you MUST believe the same as me in order for us to share this planet!!! Religions have started 99.9% of the wars since the beginning of time!!!
@Lore2009 (7378)
• United States
23 Feb 11
I consider myself to be spiritual and I am not religious. I don't follow any system that was already here from when I was born. I've created my own judgements based on my experience and others but nothing to categorize with. But I do believe in my spirit and my well-being for my spirit.
@sender621 (14894)
• United States
23 Feb 11
Anyone can be reliious in their faith and beliefs. It takes more than religion to be spiritual. Spirituality is a feeling that you have deep in your heart. I believe myself to be a very spiritual person and i find comfort each day in that.
• India
15 Apr 13
I am hindu, we believe in gods/goddesses and also on spirits/ ghosts too, spirituality is certainly part of religion.
@samaveda (25)
• India
1 Mar 11
Hi! lakshmi11! I agree with u. religion is the path to reach spirituality. Sirituality, I think relates to the soul where as religion relates to society. So many religions r there in our society. Though the religions r different spirituality is same. To attain the goal that never deals with any religion is , I think spirituality. It is above all religions. I want to name it humanity to its full core. Though we are not able to help others, we should not cause harm to any creature in this world. I think the scholars say that spirituality is to be always in thought and deeds of God. If we think our fellowmen r equal to god, we can serve them and make god happy.