can not be grateful

@indahfth (11161)
Indonesia
August 24, 2011 2:42am CST
Someone told me, if you want to be happy, I should be grateful. Be grateful with what I have right now. But, what I have now, makes me very miserable. Apparently, I am someone who can not be grateful. So, worth if I was unhappy.
2 people like this
19 responses
@djbtol (5493)
• United States
25 Aug 11
I think you are saying you won't be grateful because you are resentful of your current circumstances. Remember, things can always be worse. Make yourself realize some of those 'worse' scenarios and you will have reason to be grateful.
1 person likes this
@djbtol (5493)
• United States
25 Aug 11
So you long for independence and the ability to make your own decisions. That is a strong drive. It is difficult to live under a controlling person. In the end, though, even the most free person finds they are indirectly controlled by decisions of others. Not all the time, but sometimes.
1 person likes this
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
25 Aug 11
Under the control of others, really made me very hard. In fact, I'm afraid to say what I wanted.
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
25 Aug 11
I better not have anything, than to live under the control of others.
@jdex_143 (1093)
• Philippines
24 Aug 11
Hi,there.. You sounded like you're in some big problem.. Why can't you be grateful? Aren't you grateful that you are still alive? You know what, everyone is busy dealing with their own problems in life. You're not alone but I say to you, you must not feel that way. You must be grateful with the little things that is going on with your life now.. By negative thinking, you are just getting yourself down.. I hope you'll feel fine sooner.. Have a great day!
1 person likes this
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
24 Aug 11
Too many problems I faced. Every time I tried to solve the problem, never succeeded, but instead adds a new problem. I feel, there is no room for me to feel happy. Even if given the joy, happiness will soon disappear quickly.
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
24 Aug 11
Even I am not grateful, I am still alive. In fact I hope, God, please take my life.
@samaire (154)
• United States
24 Aug 11
OOOhhhh stop saying that you have to be grateful for that i am alive or for the sun and the moon!!!! If my life is miserable why i have to be grateful that i am alive??? Tell me that! If she has a son why is she have to be grateful when he can't live a good life? She is alone! If she wasn't alone she won't be having problems! Don't tell her that everyone have problems! This is not the answer of her or anyone's problems! You can just hope for something to change in the future and trying to make a change!
@gaiza12 (4884)
• Philippines
17 Apr 12
Most of the comments above are true. There are so many things in life that you should be grateful for, even for having an imperfect life. I learn this from my own experience, I always thank God for giving me life full of challenges. Learn to fight the miseries that you experienced, don't let your son's life be miserable as well. If you are happy, then your son will also be happy. Be thankful for what you have even if you think it's making you unhappy. What you should do is to learn how to cope up with all those things and make them into something that will make you and your family happy.
1 person likes this
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
17 Apr 12
My life is now, increasingly chaotic, and more difficult to be lived. I felt, always depressed. I never was given a chance, to enjoy life. All of that makes me hard to be grateful. I can only be grateful, for having given a perfect body.
@roxxtime (299)
• United States
24 Aug 11
Is there nothing you have that you can be grateful for? I think it does help a lot to be grateful for at least something. If you dont have kids you love or a significant other or a pet or just something you can take some kind of joy in maybe just be greatful to be alive. It could help maybe? I do hope u cheer up though.
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
24 Aug 11
I do not know. I can not even recognize myself. In fact, I forgot how to say thank you.
1 person likes this
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
24 Aug 11
I feel what happened to me unfair.
@roxxtime (299)
• United States
24 Aug 11
Is that something you want to learn again? To say thank you I mean. Its just sad that you feel so sad. I remember my mom telling me "you dont know the true meaning of guilt until you become a parent" i dont know where she heard it but it is the truth. Of course we will always feel like we should have done something better as parents but that shouldnt make you sad to see him. It is maternal instinct to do the best you can with what you have to work with, my parents could have done things differently but i know now being a parent that they did their best and i appreciate them for it. Even if it doesnt feel like it you can change the way you see things and react to them and innevitably change the way you feel.
1 person likes this
@ariyanti (205)
• Indonesia
24 Sep 11
What happened to you, you never have to have, what you have now. You are afraid to do anything, because you are afraid. You have to start thinking about your own, do not think about others.
1 person likes this
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
25 Sep 11
Yes. You are right. I find it difficult to change it all.
@asliah (11137)
• Philippines
8 Jan 12
hi, for me that grateful in life meaning is being contented on what i have in my life,no matter what it is i should have to be grateful and everything and happening in my life.even sometimes we feel empty and difficulties there are always a side to make us happy and complete.
1 person likes this
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
8 Jan 12
I also tried, to be like you. I try to be grateful for, what I have. Despite all that I have, makes me confused, sad, and guilty.
@neildc (17239)
• Lapu-Lapu City, Philippines
28 Aug 11
sometimes i feel like this when i have problems. but when i think about the other people, those people who lives under the bridge, the people who begs for coins, and others, i said, i should be thankful to God that i still live this way. that i have a job and happy family. though there are really times problem comes to us, but this is really something to be grateful.
1 person likes this
@jdyrj777 (6530)
• United States
24 Aug 11
Instead of continually being unhappy which can in the long run distroy your health. What can you do to change things so you can be happy???
@jdyrj777 (6530)
• United States
24 Aug 11
If there is nothing you can do in that household maybe you can leave there and be happy.
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
24 Aug 11
I really want to leave my life now. But, if I'm desperate, there will be a bigger problem appears again.
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
24 Aug 11
There is nothing I can do. Whatever I do, always wrong, and I always regarded as a selfish person.
@celticeagle (159008)
• Boise, Idaho
25 Aug 11
So, you are saying that you have NOTHING to be thankful for in your life. Is that right? Life totally makes you miserable. You don't have a place to sleep, food to eat, hot and cold running water, parents that love you. None of those things, right? Now that would be miserable.
@celticeagle (159008)
• Boise, Idaho
25 Aug 11
So you have nothing you can truly call yours? I would hate that kind of life.
1 person likes this
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
25 Aug 11
I also hate my life.
1 person likes this
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
25 Aug 11
Everything I have, over the control of others. I have a place to sleep, but when sleepy, I could not sleep immediately. If I sleep, there is due, should I accept. Food should I eat, is food that is determined. Even I, lacking the courage, to say, the food that I like. I feel, I live a ride, and as people who ride, I must be self-aware, and not arbitrarily.
@CJscott (4187)
• Portage La Prairie, Manitoba
24 Aug 11
Mylot makes you miserable? Your son makes you miserable? Having a house to live in makes you miserable? Having electricity makes you miserable? I might be wrong to question about your son, but the meaning of the statement is to focus on the things you have, that you can be grateful for. I am aware that you suffer from many difficulties in your life, family, husband, situations and so on, and these are very serious issues for you. I believe the same as the person that told you to be grateful and you will find happiness, it is part of it, be grateful for the things you are grateful to have. The main part is freedom, the key to happiness is freedom, and the key to freedom is courage. I am not aware of how much freedom you can grant yourself, but I know you are free to choose to dwell on the good or the bad in your life, choose to dwell on the good and the bad will improve. At least those are my thoughts, Sincerely and With Appreciation.
@roxxtime (299)
• United States
24 Aug 11
AMEN TO THAT!!! I find myself getting so depressed sometimes but there is always someone worse off and you should feel bad for them and even if you have nothing being alive is still something.
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
24 Aug 11
Every time I see my son, very painful, because I never could, provide a good life for my child. I was in the house, but I never felt in my own home, because I could not do what I want. MyLot does make me happy, and my best friend, but I logged MyLot, clandestinely.
@adhyz82 (36249)
• Indonesia
24 Aug 11
indah, so fight for your son happiness. if you think that you are unhappy in your life, don`t make it for your son.. let your son become happy in his life
@sql_cell (1427)
• Indonesia
24 Aug 11
With no thank you, means you do not believe in the existence of God. God gives much to be thankful. God will not make anything in vain. If you're in trouble, God must have a reason. You should take a lesson, for the problems you face Believe in Allah, surely your path will become easier.
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
26 Aug 11
Thank you. I was too desperate, so that makes me forget all that. may Allah forgive me.
1 person likes this
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
24 Aug 11
This desperation, made me very, very depressed.
@sql_cell (1427)
• Indonesia
25 Aug 11
If you are always near, and believe in God, you will feel calm. Dhikr, and prayer will make you calm.
• Indonesia
25 Aug 11
hi, indah, actually I agree with that statement... if you want to be grateful, you have to feel thankful.but when we stuck into problem, we forget how to enjoy life and become so thankless. I understand what you feel, but feel suffering and give up can help you anything.if you feel tired, have a rest for a while, out of your activity and take a vacation, meet new people with new atmosphere.breath in fresh new air help your heart to be much more relax, dear I have problem too anyway, but I'm tired to give up.I keep motivate my self and believe that bright way will coming true
1 person likes this
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
25 Aug 11
Vacation. There's no way I could be on vacation. I can not on vacation, because what I do, must get permission from my husband. My husband can not be allowed.
• Philippines
24 Aug 11
Learn to always look on the brighter side. Do not focus yourself just on the side of the problems. Don't limit your sight on a single dimension. Think of all what you have right now. Are you not grateful for having them? We all experience tough problems so you should not put all the blame on you. And if the problem still seems to be heavy, lean on God. I promise He'll lend a hand on you. :)
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
24 Aug 11
My life is very chaotic. In fact, I feel people who can not eat, who have no home, is more fortunate than me. I feel, I do not have anything now.
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
25 Aug 11
The time that I use to log in MyLot, is the time when I was hiding from the realities of life. Currently there are no people around me, I logged on MyLot. Not as easy as you know.
• Philippines
25 Aug 11
Oh man, please stop the crap! How can your life be chaotic if you have time to log in at myLot and do some online earnings? Many people there doesn't have money to go to a computer shop to rent a computer. You have your son with you? Then, that's great! There are people who are forced to leave their child to the orphanages because they can't give them proper lives. You are alive? That's great! Many are facing the everyday challenge of how to survive because they don't have a single money that can buy them even a piece of candy. Have you been talking to God? I'm gonna bet you're not. Because if you do, you don't want to say those unfortunate things you are saying. Cheer up man!
@parjono (39)
• Indonesia
9 Oct 11
All the problems we face, it makes us very desperate, and make us forget, for pleasure, and all that we already have, so that makes us forget to be grateful. What is needed, so we are always grateful, is the power of faith, and always pray to God. I am sure, you people who are very capable, to always be grateful.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163781)
• Garden Grove, California
12 May 12
indahfth you are one very intelligent woman who makes some really great discussions and I feel you are almost too giving and people you love are not as giving t o you as they should be. so know that you can be proud of you for being compassionate and loving. I think if you are miserable with what you have right now, its time to seel if some things can be changed to make it much better for you. Life I am afraid is not ever fair. three years ago I was happy and unaware of bad things to happen to me and myson, it all was ve ry unfair but it happened. he lost his job, we got behind in the rent so were evicted, we were the only family we had my adult son and I so we were made homeless and as I was 82 then and diabetic my son said he felt I should be off the streets so here I am in Gold C rest retirement c enter paid for by my social security and my SSi checks each month. He finally got free apt from Homes america and now has a job and is in transitional housing he pays 240 a month. I am stil here and while I hated b eing here I had to be here as there was no where else to go. I learned t o be happy and you can do that too.just thank God for what you have , and what you do enjoy as looking at the positive helps bring more positive things your way .
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
13 May 12
I am very confused with my life. The people that I love, makes me like does not mean, and can control me.
@stanley777 (9402)
• Philippines
24 Aug 11
My friend , it seems that you are carrying a heavy load.You can seek advice from your friends on whatever problems you are having right now.I know they are willing and also bear in mind that the Guy up there won't give you a challenge if you can not handle it.Believe in yourself and you can surpass anything that comes your way.
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
24 Aug 11
A lot of the advice I received. All told me to be patient, grateful, and always remember to God. But all that difficult for me to do. Not easy to run it. I have been very desperate.
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
25 Aug 11
I was losing hope. I just can surrender now.
• Philippines
25 Aug 11
I think you are losing hope which should not be the case.You are experiencing self pity which is not good you have to do something, I know you can do it.Hope you all the best.
• United States
24 Aug 11
Hi indahfth! Sometimes people do not understand that sadness is not something one can change like the light switch. You can turn on and off your emotions simply because you want them to. I can at times understand that yes while a lot of things make us miserable and unhappy there are those with life threatening diseases that are far worse, so it is easy for someone to say to you and or me that we should be grateful. I believe you are grateful indahfth, I don't think this is what is hurting you. You are a good person and you do believe in helping others. You have put the needs of others before you own. This is partly the reason for your sadness. Do know that although you have put your needs before others and are so sad in life, some day indahfth, you will be very blessed with happiness. Sad that we cannot reach that happiness when we want it. Do not feel bad that someone does not understand your feelings. Know that you are a really good person as you have been devoting your life for others. I do not find you ungrateful, just going through a really hard time in life. You are in constant prayer so I know you are not ungrateful. You are HUMAN, and part of being human is having feelings.
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
25 Aug 11
I am so desperate right now. I feel, I live only to succumb, and always relented.
• Malaysia
24 Aug 11
Would this stop you from saying that you cannot be grateful? Be grateful before everything is taken away from you....Do you have a gratitude journal? If you dont have one get one. Write down whatever grateful things that you receive like you get to drink, eat, shower, walking, typing etc etc. write a few things a day that you are grateful of than you can add more or naturally you will get to see all the things that you should be grateful about. Do your part and i do mine.
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
25 Aug 11
What I eat, and I drink, very painful. Because, everything I eat, or I drink, not mine. I had to eat whatever he eats although I do not like.
1 person likes this
@adhyz82 (36249)
• Indonesia
29 Aug 11
don`t say like that indah... thanks to your God for your live now.. thanks to your God for your kids now thanks to your God for your marriage even sometimes it doesn`t make you happy thanks to your God for being a moslem...
• Philippines
24 Aug 11
Yes, it is true indeed that if you want to be happy you should be thankful for all the blessings that comes your way. There may be things or something that you want that you don't have right now so you will feel that there is nothing to be thankful for but if you try to reflect more there are many things that you can be grateful for. First is the life that you have right now, the healthy body that you have, you heart that pumps every second every day, never ceasing even when you are asleep. You have the brain that lets you think and do mental activity. You have the voice to speak. Try to look around you, the flowers and tress, the mountains and birds, they are wonders to behold and they are there for us to enjoy. If you cannot be happy in spite of this, create your happiness. Do something that you really want no matter how silly it is as long as it is not dangerous or illegal. And then when you do that you will be able to feel grateful. Life is short so you have to make the most of it and be happy always!
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
24 Aug 11
My body healthy, but my heart and mind are very sick. I like being played by fate.
1 person likes this
@adhyz82 (36249)
• Indonesia
24 Aug 11
dont blame fate,,
@indahfth (11161)
• Indonesia
24 Aug 11
I do not know, have to blame? I am to blame.