Replica mania..what a waste of money...

@vandana7 (98834)
India
October 9, 2012 12:16pm CST
I was watching Discovery channel off and on, and some rich guy had decided to rebuild part of Venice in Nevada. This morning I read somewhere that Saudi plans to build a larger Taj Mahal, without its love saga of course.. And we have a lot of Disneyworlds, and Essel worlds, we've lost track of where they originated from. Now my question is, why replicate. Why not be original? How does it help to replicate? Is it a statement, what you did, I can do it better? Or is it a way to say since I cant own Venice, I will recreate one. Or is it just insane display of wealth? I find it insane because it creates false demand for construction material. Such projects are large scale projects. So production is increased in cement companies, painting companies, plaster of paris companies, etc. etc. etc., only to supply to these people. Thereafter that capacity lies idle, and business enterprises go bankrupt. People loose jobs. So what do you think? Is it worthwhile to replicate a historic monument or places like Disneyworlds? And should such structures be allowed at all, without co-ordinating demand for construction material from them at national level?
6 people like this
9 responses
@Janey1966 (24170)
• Carlisle, England
9 Oct 12
I'm with you on this one and I've actually been in the Venetian Hotel in Las Vegas and the 'copy' of Venice is a bit tacky, I agree and DOES look fake, which is the worst bit in my opinion, plus it's indoors lol. I believe some billionaire wants to have a Titanic made in China - just so he can.
@vandana7 (98834)
• India
10 Oct 12
Did I tell you it is 10 hours cut for us right now? Oh no, I didnt.
@Janey1966 (24170)
• Carlisle, England
10 Oct 12
Very good point. Apparently, the UK will probably experience black-outs in 3 year's time. God help us!
@thesids (22180)
• Bhubaneswar, India
10 Oct 12
We had the 10 hrs cut here a couple of days back and is scheduled again this coming sunday
@dfollin (24172)
• United States
9 Oct 12
I do not think it is a waste of money.Those places are for people to go to that can't afford to go to the original places for various reason's such as money,time or medical reason's.For instance a few years ago Disney wanted to make a theme park in this area,northern Virginia.That would have provided a lot of jobs in this area as well as a family fun location here.But people protested it because they said that it would bring too much traffic and construction.However they are still building other not so family fun oriented places in those same area's,such as more store that there is one of just down the street,and office buildings that are not even being used for the purpose intended for they are used as a tax right off. I am 51 years old and was fortunate enough to scrap together the funds to take my daughter to Disney World in Florida this past summer,as my late husband wished.And it is not a copy of the original Disneyland in southern California or like any of the other Disney theme parks in the world. Disneyworld is a much larger and broader minded place then Disneyland is.I have some friends that prefer one or the other.We had a fabulous time at Disney World and wnat to go back.
@vandana7 (98834)
• India
11 Oct 12
Disneyland originally belongs to the US. Creating one in India makes no sense. Why? Ok..first and foremost the equipment required for setting up an amusement park would have to be imported unlike in the US. We would lose some fertile lands for setting up amusement park, in the process we would become dependent for food on International markets, which in turn will make your bread expensive. But coming back to imported equipment, we would have to pay for it right? Disney is not donating it to us. So more important medical equipment or other technologies get side tracked and this gets priority. Finally, some monies would be required for upkeep and some profits need to be earned from the entire initiative right? Less than 25 percent of people out here can afford to visit it. Will people from other countries come here, or go to the US for visiting Disneyland? In any event, isn't it wrong to make a dent on another country's tourism by copying something? Isn't it like plagiarism?
1 person likes this
@dfollin (24172)
• United States
19 Oct 12
I don't really see how it's plaiarismThere are other companies like Coke,Pepsi,7-11 and McDonalds that are in other countries so what is wrong with Disney being in other countries.You said that Disney is a US company and doesn't belong in other countries.That is the same as saying that all these peoducts and people in the US don't belong here then. Maybe India isn't the best place for Disney to go to.Because,that is right they are not giving it to you,but at the same time they are not asking India to provide the supplies either.Also because it appears they are not welcome there.
@vandana7 (98834)
• India
19 Oct 12
Sorry typo..ditto for pepsi....
@urbandekay (18278)
10 Oct 12
I think most ridiculous is the foolish yank that bought London Bridge and had it disassembled and moved to US without realising that London Bridge is just an ordinary bridge believing that it was Tower Bridge! all the best urban
@urbandekay (18278)
11 Oct 12
I think there is something sick in their culture, children shooting their class mates, plastic surgery for vanity, valuing revenge, these are products of a sick culture all the best urban
@vandana7 (98834)
• India
14 Oct 12
It is possibly the ultimate outcome of nuclear families where the child has nobody to talk to and get solutions to his or her problems. That might be the cause for children shooting other school mates. I cant call it culture though. Plastic surgery has invaded India as well..:( Valuing revenge..lets face it, it is very very tempting.. if there was no price to be paid for it, each one of us would try for that. Come on Urban..we are human beings, and we are basically sick people that is why we have so many wars and so many reasons for wars and blood shed. :)
@vandana7 (98834)
• India
10 Oct 12
I have to agree to that... Do you think they have an insanity gene or does excess money trigger insanity? lol
@Maggiepie (7816)
• United States
26 Nov 12
[b]Hi Vandana! Listen, I think you would benefit in an old-fashioned economics class. You may need one in order to see why I agree with everything in Defollin's last letter, about how things would greatly improve wherever a business such as Disney's goes. Somewhere you've been given the incorrect notion that capitalism is a zero-sum system. That's the opposite of the truth! And even bette4r, it's capitalism which has made things far better for nature in the U.S. Do some research on it & you'll change your mind. By the way, I'm just now becoming active in MyLot again, as I was ill for most of the year--but I'm back--& am I ever glad! Good to find you're still here & going strong! Maggiepie[/b]
@Maggiepie (7816)
• United States
26 Nov 12
[b]Oh, & just for the record, I've no idea what motivates such builders (probably mainly money, with admiration for the original), nor am I infatuated with going to any (though I'd not turn down a ticket to get in--if I were fond of the original place). It's just not high on my list. Maggiepie[/b]
@vandana7 (98834)
• India
20 Dec 12
Hello Maggiepie...I am so glad you are back. And honestly, your responses are truly thought provoking. I, however, do have some doubts...I mean one rule may not be right for everybody, capitalistic or otherwise. Out here, an average Indian earns less than 1000 dollars per month. Ok? Even if cost of living is lower, thanks to our unawareness of lower quality, and less stringent quality norms, and bad laws, and lack of law enforcement, and slow mode of justice, that is barely sufficient for a family of four. From where is that person going to have enough monies to take kids out frequently to a place like that? So you are targetting only the top brass. Our finance minister yesterday expressed a shock that only 1440000 people have an income of over 2000 dollars per month out of total strength of individual taxpayers ..30000000 or so. And there is a large section of those 1440000 people that can afford to travel to countries like the US, and UK, and stay there, and study there, and travel up and down, and even do business there. So lets just say, you are targetting roughly 1000000 individuals. Now, even these folks...they would rather save over a period, and travel abroad for vacation, rather than visit Disney world within the country. At least 500000 of them would. This is partly because they get to brag about their travel, and partly because they get to see more for their monies. Effectively, we make the project a non-starter. Agreed technologies will be imported, and temporarily there would be employment. But over a period, these people would realize that viability is a suspect. Then, they would close the shop. But the farmer from whom the land is taken for development...as eminent domain, at lower than market price, is hardly likely to get it back. Instead, the government will sit over the land for ages till the farmer forgets about the issue, and then the land will be leased to one of the politicians or his friends or family members. Eventually, the government will forget to increase the lease rentals and even forget that it owns the land. Then the politician and his or her clout will claim the land under "adverse possession", and Supreme Court (Apex court out here), will give it to these people. And they would become the rightful owners without paying a thing! Get what I mean?
@allknowing (130064)
• India
10 Oct 12
Is there anything sane going on anywhere in this world anyway!?
@vandana7 (98834)
• India
10 Oct 12
Kejriwal..and his attack on Vadra Anna and his fasting Vandy and her lamenting..
@allknowing (130064)
• India
10 Oct 12
That is just a drop in the ocean of madness
@thesids (22180)
• Bhubaneswar, India
10 Oct 12
Well, whats wrong if someone is creating some employment opportunities somewhere and paying off to copy-paste or even try out something already done and tested...? We all copy paste... dont we But, let me also tell you... I did hear that trying to reinvent the wheel was insanity...
@vandana7 (98834)
• India
10 Oct 12
sid..for one..nobody wants vacation within their country. They want to travel out of their familiar environment and do everything new. Now Nevada is part of the US. Vacation within US cant come that cheap, especially if you are in costly state as Nevada. Right? Ditto for UAE tourism. Not every tourist is rich.. Wheel has undergone a lot of study and now it is linked with some microchip to make it balance itself, did you know that..Honda has a two wheeler car on that principle.
@thesids (22180)
• Bhubaneswar, India
10 Oct 12
Of course not many want a vacation within their country but then there are more of the poor around. And they might never afford a vacation beyond their country. So maybe this would work out good for them, though they might surely miss the original. For the wheel, I had read about some microchips but didnt know about the 2-wheeler car on that funda.
@JAYMAR777 (840)
• Philippines
11 Oct 12
They said that "Imitation is the highest form of flattery". I probably understand how you feel and the thing is they can imitate structures esp. with historic significance but they can never imitate the life and the spirit of it. Like for instance the Taj Mahal. The beauty of it is far beyond the structures (love as you have mentioned). So even if they will build a bigger or more high tech, they will just boost the popularity and beauty of the Taj Mahal. So there maybe a positive side to this after all.
@vandana7 (98834)
• India
11 Oct 12
Hope so..:)
• India
14 Oct 12
Hello my friend vandana7 Ji, Well, I think it is due to the fact taht human-beings wants to ahve variety of things and pose they can do it. One may look around at one's own premises. People will have lot many fancies, will have plenty of cloths in their wardrobes, they may not get time to use them even once a year. It is greedyness of human kind and just to show off their wealth. Recently there was a study whetre Tons of food is wasted during Marriage parties, where people can be fed dying of hunger. No one can stop such things. It will remain. May God bless You and have a great time
@rog0322 (2829)
• Cagayan De Oro, Philippines
10 Oct 12
Hi, That's the result of too much money with too little imagination. The best way to spend it is to imitate the famous and popular. Happens all the time, too lazy to be original, so why not copy and enjoy it. In my case, if I have the money, I would explore new means to do things other than what has been done. Maybe, I could find a way to make this world a better place to live in.
@vandana7 (98834)
• India
10 Oct 12
"too much money with too little imagination" They leave nothing for posterity with that..since the books that talk about Venice cant be destroyed, literature about Venice cant be destroyed, romance about Taj Mahal cant be destroyed.. So there is all the more need to be original..